{ "asOf": "2026-10-15", "release": "0.3", "researchSupplement": { "id": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18", "checkedAt": "2026-10-18", "outcomeCutoff": "2026-10-15" }, "scope": "Selected source-matched forecast versions; not lifetime accuracy.", "predictions": [ { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "HIGH", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "A machine wins a standard match against the reigning world chess champion; either cited 1998 or 2000 deadline suffices.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines. The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 1997, "at_deadline_rationale": "IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines.", "at_review_rationale": "The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O01" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 1998, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "A machine wins a standard match against the reigning world chess champion; either cited 1998 or 2000 deadline suffices.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines. The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 1997, "at_deadline_rationale": "IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines.", "at_review_rationale": "The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O01" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 1998, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "A machine wins a standard match against the reigning world chess champion; either cited 1998 or 2000 deadline suffices.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines. The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 1997, "at_deadline_rationale": "IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines.", "at_review_rationale": "The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O01" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 1998, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": 1997, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "EXACT_EVENT", "label": "1997; 1–3 years early across the cited 1998/2000 deadlines", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": [ -3, -1 ] }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ATTRIBUTION_UNRESOLVED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "IBM documents the 1997 match victory. The intake alternates 1998 and 2000. The author’s retrospective names 1998, but the relevant original-edition passage was not obtained. Outcome is confirmed; the historical attribution and exact drift remain open.", "first_full_achievement_year": 1997, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "UNREVIEWED -> CORRECT: immaterial date conflict no longer blocks the outcome." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K001", "slug": "k001-chess-champion-resolve-the-original-deadline", "title": "Computer defeats the world chess champion", "prediction_paraphrase": "A computer defeats the world chess champion.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "chess", "benchmark" ], "subcategory": "Game-playing AI", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K001", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-001", "DEC-001", "EXE-001" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1990, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "UNRESOLVED_ORIGINAL_EDITION" }, "target": { "text": "1998 in the author retrospective; 2000 in earlier summaries. Reference 1998; success invariant.", "deadline_year": 1998, "precision": "EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR", "year_start": 1998, "year_end": 1998, "interpretation": "1998 in the author retrospective; 2000 in earlier summaries. Reference 1998; success invariant." }, "source_verification": { "state": "ATTRIBUTION_CONFLICT", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "A machine wins a standard match against the reigning world chess champion; either cited 1998 or 2000 deadline suffices.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines.", "at_review_rationale": "The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines. The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.", "first_full_achievement_year": 1997, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": [ -3, -1 ], "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "Overview, printed p. 5", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O01", "locator": "Documents the 1997 match victory; not proof of the original date or wording of Kurzweil’s forecast.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Attribution to the broad chess forecast is strong; the exact original deadline is less secure. Do not publish a single precise drift.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-001", "relation": "HOLD_ATTRIBUTION_CONFLICT" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-001", "relation": "HOLD_ATTRIBUTION_CONFLICT" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-001", "relation": "HOLD_ATTRIBUTION_CONFLICT" } ] }, "id": "K001", "familyId": "K001", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K001", "category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "chess", "benchmark", "Game-playing AI" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "A computer defeats the world chess champion.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "A computer defeats the world chess champion.", "successCriteria": "A machine wins a standard match against the reigning world chess champion; either cited 1998 or 2000 deadline suffices.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1990, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "Overview, printed p. 5", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "1998 in the author retrospective; 2000 in earlier summaries. Reference 1998; success invariant.", "year": 1998, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O01", "id": "O01-0", "title": "IBM — Deep Blue", "url": "https://www.ibm.com/history/deep-blue", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Documents the 1997 match victory; not proof of the original date or wording of Kurzweil’s forecast.. Documents the 1997 match victory; not proof of the original date or wording of Kurzweil’s forecast." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": 1997, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines. The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Attribution to the broad chess forecast is strong; the exact original deadline is less secure. Do not publish a single precise drift.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. IBM documents the 1997 match victory. The intake alternates 1998 and 2000. The author’s retrospective names 1998, but the relevant original-edition passage was not obtained. Outcome is confirmed; the historical attribution and exact drift remain open. Change: UNREVIEWED -> CORRECT: immaterial date conflict no longer blocks the outcome." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines. The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"A machine wins a standard match against the reigning world chess champion; either cited 1998 or 2000 deadline suffices.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines. The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":1997,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O01\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":1998,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"A machine wins a standard match against the reigning world chess champion; either cited 1998 or 2000 deadline suffices.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines. The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":1997,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O01\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":1998,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"A machine wins a standard match against the reigning world chess champion; either cited 1998 or 2000 deadline suffices.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines. The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":1997,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O01\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":1998,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":1997,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"EXACT_EVENT\",\"label\":\"1997; 1–3 years early across the cited 1998/2000 deadlines\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":[-3,-1]},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ATTRIBUTION_UNRESOLVED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"IBM documents the 1997 match victory. The intake alternates 1998 and 2000. The author’s retrospective names 1998, but the relevant original-edition passage was not obtained. Outcome is confirmed; the historical attribution and exact drift remain open.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":1997,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"UNREVIEWED -> CORRECT: immaterial date conflict no longer blocks the outcome.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K001\",\"slug\":\"k001-chess-champion-resolve-the-original-deadline\",\"title\":\"Computer defeats the world chess champion\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"A computer defeats the world chess champion.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"AI & software\",\"tags\":[\"chess\",\"benchmark\"],\"subcategory\":\"Game-playing AI\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K001\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-001\",\"DEC-001\",\"EXE-001\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1990,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"UNRESOLVED_ORIGINAL_EDITION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"1998 in the author retrospective; 2000 in earlier summaries. Reference 1998; success invariant.\",\"deadline_year\":1998,\"precision\":\"EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR\",\"year_start\":1998,\"year_end\":1998,\"interpretation\":\"1998 in the author retrospective; 2000 in earlier summaries. Reference 1998; success invariant.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"ATTRIBUTION_CONFLICT\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"A machine wins a standard match against the reigning world chess champion; either cited 1998 or 2000 deadline suffices.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"IBM documents Deep Blue’s 1997 match win, before both candidate deadlines. The outcome remains a full success. Resolving the edition changes only whether it was one or three years early.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":1997,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":[-3,-1],\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"Overview, printed p. 5\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O01\",\"locator\":\"Documents the 1997 match victory; not proof of the original date or wording of Kurzweil’s forecast.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Attribution to the broad chess forecast is strong; the exact original deadline is less secure. Do not publish a single precise drift.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-001\",\"relation\":\"HOLD_ATTRIBUTION_CONFLICT\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-001\",\"relation\":\"HOLD_ATTRIBUTION_CONFLICT\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-001\",\"relation\":\"HOLD_ATTRIBUTION_CONFLICT\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Portable computers are substantially lighter and thinner than typical 1999 notebooks; not every computer must shrink.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator. Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2008, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator.", "at_review_rationale": "Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O02", "O03", "O04" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Portable computers are substantially lighter and thinner than typical 1999 notebooks; not every computer must shrink.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator. Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2008, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator.", "at_review_rationale": "Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O02", "O03", "O04" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Portable computers are substantially lighter and thinner than typical 1999 notebooks; not every computer must shrink.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator. Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2008, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator.", "at_review_rationale": "Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O02", "O03", "O04" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2008, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2008", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Apple’s 2000 PowerBook weighed 5.7–6.1 lb, and its 2001 model was one inch thick. The 2008 MacBook Air weighed 3 lb and was at most 0.76 inch thick. These are contemporaneous manufacturer specifications supporting the qualitative trend before 2009.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2008, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K002", "slug": "k002-lighter-and-thinner-portable-computers", "title": "Lighter and thinner portable computers", "prediction_paraphrase": "Portable computers become markedly lighter and thinner.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "notebooks", "weight", "thickness" ], "subcategory": "Miniaturization", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K002", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-004" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Portable computers are substantially lighter and thinner than typical 1999 notebooks; not every computer must shrink.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator.", "at_review_rationale": "Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator. Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2008, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 2, printed p. 12", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O02", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O03", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O04", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-004", "relation": "CANONICALIZE" } ] }, "id": "K002", "familyId": "K002", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K002", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "notebooks", "weight", "thickness", "Miniaturization" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Portable computers become markedly lighter and thinner.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Portable computers become markedly lighter and thinner.", "successCriteria": "Portable computers are substantially lighter and thinner than typical 1999 notebooks; not every computer must shrink.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 2, printed p. 12", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O02", "id": "O02-0", "title": "Apple unveils new PowerBook", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2000/02/16Apple-Unveils-New-PowerBook-The-Fastest-Portable-Ever/", "publishedAt": "2000-02-16", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Product-feature bullets: notebook weight with battery, and with DVD drive. The manufacturer lists 5.7 lb with a weight-saving module and 6.1 lb with the DVD drive. Evidence limits: Configuration-specific comparison, not a market-wide average." }, { "sourceId": "O03", "id": "O03-1", "title": "Apple introduces MacBook Air", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2008/01/15Apple-Introduces-MacBook-Air-The-Worlds-Thinnest-Notebook/", "publishedAt": "2008-01-15", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Opening product description; storage-options paragraph. The launch announcement specifies 0.16–0.76-inch thickness and describes hard-disk and optional SSD configurations. Evidence limits: This page does not give a three-pound weight; the added October 2008 source supplies that specification." }, { "sourceId": "O04", "id": "O04-2", "title": "Apple unveils one-inch-thick Titanium PowerBook G4", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2001/01/09Apple-Unveils-One-Inch-Thick-Titanium-PowerBook-G4/", "publishedAt": "2001-01-09", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Opening product description and thickness/weight feature bullets. Apple specifies a one-inch enclosure and 5.3 lb including battery and DVD drive. Evidence limits: A named model is a comparator, not proof of every notebook’s specifications." }, { "sourceId": "SUP005", "id": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18-SUP005", "title": "Apple updates MacBook family (October 2008)", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2008/10/14New-MacBook-Family-Redefines-Notebook-Design/", "publishedAt": "2008-10-14", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Paragraph announcing updates to MacBook Air and the 17-inch MacBook Pro. The October 2008 release explicitly specifies a three-pound MacBook Air and a maximum enclosure height of 0.76 inches. Evidence limits: This confirms the weight missing from the January release; it does not establish an exact first-achievement date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator. Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: CORRECT. Apple’s 2000 PowerBook weighed 5.7–6.1 lb, and its 2001 model was one inch thick. The 2008 MacBook Air weighed 3 lb and was at most 0.76 inch thick. These are contemporaneous manufacturer specifications supporting the qualitative trend before 2009. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator. Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary." }, { "date": "2026-10-18", "note": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18: 4 primary citation checks/additions. Primary citation locators, source-specific support limits and additional corroborating references; no changes to verdicts, eligibility or timing judgments." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Portable computers are substantially lighter and thinner than typical 1999 notebooks; not every computer must shrink.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator. Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2008,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O02\",\"O03\",\"O04\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Portable computers are substantially lighter and thinner than typical 1999 notebooks; not every computer must shrink.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator. Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2008,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O02\",\"O03\",\"O04\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Portable computers are substantially lighter and thinner than typical 1999 notebooks; not every computer must shrink.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator. Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2008,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O02\",\"O03\",\"O04\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2008,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2008\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Apple’s 2000 PowerBook weighed 5.7–6.1 lb, and its 2001 model was one inch thick. The 2008 MacBook Air weighed 3 lb and was at most 0.76 inch thick. These are contemporaneous manufacturer specifications supporting the qualitative trend before 2009.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2008,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K002\",\"slug\":\"k002-lighter-and-thinner-portable-computers\",\"title\":\"Lighter and thinner portable computers\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Portable computers become markedly lighter and thinner.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[\"notebooks\",\"weight\",\"thickness\"],\"subcategory\":\"Miniaturization\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K002\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-004\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Portable computers are substantially lighter and thinner than typical 1999 notebooks; not every computer must shrink.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The 2008 MacBook Air was three pounds and at most 0.76 inches thick; earlier PowerBooks provide a concrete size/weight comparator. Commercial thin laptops substantiate the direction and magnitude. A single earliest breakthrough year is unnecessary.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2008,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 2, printed p. 12\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O02\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O03\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O04\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-004\",\"relation\":\"CANONICALIZE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Computing in wearable body ornaments is a common product/use category; watches count and every example need not be equally adopted.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached. By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached.", "at_review_rationale": "By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N01", "N02", "N25" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Both everyday clothing and a broad range of jewelry commonly embed computers.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Smartwatches satisfy part of the list, but broadly computerized clothing and the full jewelry assortment are not comparably established.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N01", "N02", "N25" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Computing in wearable body ornaments is a common product/use category; watches count and every example need not be equally adopted.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached. By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached.", "at_review_rationale": "By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N01", "N02", "N25" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2019, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2019; after 2009, no later than 2019", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The original scope is stronger than “smartphones exist.” The retrospective relies partly on counting carried devices. Independent adoption evidence for literal clothing/jewelry integration has not been established here.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K003", "slug": "k003-computers-embedded-in-clothing-and-jewelry", "title": "Computers embedded in clothing and jewelry", "prediction_paraphrase": "Clothing and jewelry commonly contain computers.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "embedded computing", "adoption" ], "subcategory": "Wearables", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K003", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-005", "DEC-011" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Computing in wearable body ornaments is a common product/use category; watches count and every example need not be equally adopted.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached.", "at_review_rationale": "By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "LATE", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached. By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2019, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 3, printed pp. 12–13", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N01", "locator": "June 2019 US survey: 21% regularly wear one. Common does not mean majority, and US adult prevalence is not global prevalence.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N02", "locator": "US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N25", "locator": "ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; ECG deployment corroborated by December 2018 release O22. Not diagnosis of all diseases or autonomous treatment.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "US wearable prevalence is a regional proxy. The reference treats the examples as an illustrative class; the fuller clothing-plus-jewelry reading remains partial.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-005", "relation": "MERGE_SAME_SCOPE" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-011", "relation": "MERGE_SAME_SCOPE" } ] }, "id": "K003", "familyId": "K003", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K003", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "embedded computing", "adoption", "Wearables" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Clothing and jewelry commonly contain computers.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Clothing and jewelry commonly contain computers.", "successCriteria": "Computing in wearable body ornaments is a common product/use category; watches count and every example need not be equally adopted.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 3, printed pp. 12–13", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N01", "id": "N01-0", "title": "Pew: About one-in-five Americans use a smartwatch or fitness tracker", "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2020/01/09/about-one-in-five-americans-use-a-smart-watch-or-fitness-tracker/", "publishedAt": "2020-01-09", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "June 2019 US survey: 21% regularly wear one. Common does not mean majority, and US adult prevalence is not global prevalence.. June 2019 US survey: 21% regularly wear one. Common does not mean majority, and US adult prevalence is not global prevalence." }, { "sourceId": "N02", "id": "N02-1", "title": "Pew: Americans and their gadgets", "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2010/10/14/americans-and-their-gadgets/", "publishedAt": "2010-10-14", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks.. US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks." }, { "sourceId": "N25", "id": "N25-2", "title": "Apple: Watch Series 4 health, ECG and fall detection", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2018/09/redesigned-apple-watch-series-4-revolutionizes-communication-fitness-and-health/", "publishedAt": "2018-09-12", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; ECG deployment corroborated by December 2018 release O22. Not diagnosis of all diseases or autonomous treatment.. ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; ECG deployment corroborated by December 2018 release O22. Not diagnosis of all diseases or autonomous treatment." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached. By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.", "alternativeInterpretation": "US wearable prevalence is a regional proxy. The reference treats the examples as an illustrative class; the fuller clothing-plus-jewelry reading remains partial.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "US wearable prevalence is a regional proxy. The reference treats the examples as an illustrative class; the fuller clothing-plus-jewelry reading remains partial.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. The original scope is stronger than “smartphones exist.” The retrospective relies partly on counting carried devices. Independent adoption evidence for literal clothing/jewelry integration has not been established here. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict LATE. Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached. By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Computing in wearable body ornaments is a common product/use category; watches count and every example need not be equally adopted.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached. By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N01\",\"N02\",\"N25\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Both everyday clothing and a broad range of jewelry commonly embed computers.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Smartwatches satisfy part of the list, but broadly computerized clothing and the full jewelry assortment are not comparably established.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N01\",\"N02\",\"N25\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Computing in wearable body ornaments is a common product/use category; watches count and every example need not be equally adopted.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached. By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N01\",\"N02\",\"N25\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2019; after 2009, no later than 2019\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The original scope is stronger than “smartphones exist.” The retrospective relies partly on counting carried devices. Independent adoption evidence for literal clothing/jewelry integration has not been established here.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K003\",\"slug\":\"k003-computers-embedded-in-clothing-and-jewelry\",\"title\":\"Computers embedded in clothing and jewelry\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Clothing and jewelry commonly contain computers.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[\"embedded computing\",\"adoption\"],\"subcategory\":\"Wearables\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K003\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-005\",\"DEC-011\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Computing in wearable body ornaments is a common product/use category; watches count and every example need not be equally adopted.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Wearable and embedded devices existed, but the 2009 common-use threshold was only partly reached. By the June 2019 US survey, 21% regularly wore a smartwatch or fitness tracker. That is common, not universal; it supports a late wearable-form-factor success.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2019,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 3, printed pp. 12–13\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N01\",\"locator\":\"June 2019 US survey: 21% regularly wear one. Common does not mean majority, and US adult prevalence is not global prevalence.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N02\",\"locator\":\"US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N25\",\"locator\":\"ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; ECG deployment corroborated by December 2018 release O22. Not diagnosis of all diseases or autonomous treatment.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"US wearable prevalence is a regional proxy. The reference treats the examples as an illustrative class; the fuller clothing-plus-jewelry reading remains partial.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-005\",\"relation\":\"MERGE_SAME_SCOPE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-011\",\"relation\":\"MERGE_SAME_SCOPE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Typical users have at least twelve separately functional worn/carried computing devices linked in a body network.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks. Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks.", "at_review_rationale": "Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N02", "N01" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Typical users have at least twelve separately functional worn/carried computing devices linked in a body network.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks. Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks.", "at_review_rationale": "Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N02", "N01" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "People use several mutually connected personal devices and sensors.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Phone/watch/earbud ecosystems realize the body-network direction, but this drops the explicit twelve-device threshold.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Drops at-least-twelve threshold" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2021, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N02", "N01" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "UNSCORABLE", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "Counting chips inside a phone is not the same as counting independently networked worn devices. The legacy paraphrase removed both the numerical threshold and body-LAN condition. No stable counting convention is specified.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K004", "slug": "k004-at-least-a-dozen-body-networked-computers", "title": "At least a dozen body-networked computers", "prediction_paraphrase": "Typical people use at least twelve body-networked computers.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "body-area networks", "device counts" ], "subcategory": "Wearables", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K004", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-006" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Typical users have at least twelve separately functional worn/carried computing devices linked in a body network.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks.", "at_review_rationale": "Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks. Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 5, printed pp. 14–15", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N02", "locator": "US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N01", "locator": "June 2019 US survey: 21% regularly wear one. Common does not mean majority, and US adult prevalence is not global prevalence.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "A phone’s internal chips are not counted as separate body-LAN computers; that redefinition would make the original list of personal functions misleading. No global body-LAN census is available.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-006", "relation": "RESTORE_THRESHOLD" } ] }, "id": "K004", "familyId": "K004", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K004", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "body-area networks", "device counts", "Wearables" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Typical people use at least twelve body-networked computers.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Typical people use at least twelve body-networked computers.", "successCriteria": "Typical users have at least twelve separately functional worn/carried computing devices linked in a body network.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 5, printed pp. 14–15", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N02", "id": "N02-0", "title": "Pew: Americans and their gadgets", "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2010/10/14/americans-and-their-gadgets/", "publishedAt": "2010-10-14", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks.. US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks." }, { "sourceId": "N01", "id": "N01-1", "title": "Pew: About one-in-five Americans use a smartwatch or fitness tracker", "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2020/01/09/about-one-in-five-americans-use-a-smart-watch-or-fitness-tracker/", "publishedAt": "2020-01-09", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "June 2019 US survey: 21% regularly wear one. Common does not mean majority, and US adult prevalence is not global prevalence.. June 2019 US survey: 21% regularly wear one. Common does not mean majority, and US adult prevalence is not global prevalence." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks. Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.", "alternativeInterpretation": "A phone’s internal chips are not counted as separate body-LAN computers; that redefinition would make the original list of personal functions misleading. No global body-LAN census is available.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "A phone’s internal chips are not counted as separate body-LAN computers; that redefinition would make the original list of personal functions misleading. No global body-LAN census is available.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNSCORABLE. Counting chips inside a phone is not the same as counting independently networked worn devices. The legacy paraphrase removed both the numerical threshold and body-LAN condition. No stable counting convention is specified. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks. Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Typical users have at least twelve separately functional worn/carried computing devices linked in a body network.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks. Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N02\",\"N01\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Typical users have at least twelve separately functional worn/carried computing devices linked in a body network.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks. Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N02\",\"N01\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"People use several mutually connected personal devices and sensors.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Phone/watch/earbud ecosystems realize the body-network direction, but this drops the explicit twelve-device threshold.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Drops at-least-twelve threshold\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2021,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N02\",\"N01\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"UNSCORABLE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"Counting chips inside a phone is not the same as counting independently networked worn devices. The legacy paraphrase removed both the numerical threshold and body-LAN condition. No stable counting convention is specified.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K004\",\"slug\":\"k004-at-least-a-dozen-body-networked-computers\",\"title\":\"At least a dozen body-networked computers\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Typical people use at least twelve body-networked computers.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[\"body-area networks\",\"device counts\"],\"subcategory\":\"Wearables\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K004\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-006\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Typical users have at least twelve separately functional worn/carried computing devices linked in a body network.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Contemporary device-ownership surveys show a handful of gadgets, not typical twelve-node body networks. Phones, watches and earbuds create useful small networks, but not typical twelve-device ensembles. This is a medium-confidence prevalence judgment, not a claim that no enthusiast has twelve devices.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 5, printed pp. 14–15\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N02\",\"locator\":\"US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N01\",\"locator\":\"June 2019 US survey: 21% regularly wear one. Common does not mean majority, and US adult prevalence is not global prevalence.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"A phone’s internal chips are not counted as separate body-LAN computers; that redefinition would make the original list of personal functions misleading. No global body-LAN census is available.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-006\",\"relation\":\"RESTORE_THRESHOLD\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "The pocket/worn personal computers in the surrounding passage generally use electronic storage rather than rotating media.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009. This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N03", "O07" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Apply the solid-state/no-moving-parts claim to portable PCs including laptops, not just the pocket/worn context.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Hard drives were common in 2009 laptops; current widespread SSDs fulfill storage substitution, but a literal no-moving-parts condition still conflicts with many cooling fans.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_POPULATION", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N03", "O07" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "The pocket/worn personal computers in the surrounding passage generally use electronic storage rather than rotating media.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009. This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N03", "O07" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2009, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2009", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "Phones and notebooks cannot be silently combined or separated to obtain a favorable majority. Apple’s 2008 Air still offered a hard disk as well as an SSD option. A sales/installed-base denominator is needed.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K005", "slug": "k005-personal-devices-largely-without-moving-parts", "title": "Personal devices largely without moving parts", "prediction_paraphrase": "Most personal computing devices have no moving parts.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "solid state", "moving parts" ], "subcategory": "Storage and device design", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K005", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-007" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "The pocket/worn personal computers in the surrounding passage generally use electronic storage rather than rotating media.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009. This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2009, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 6, printed p. 15", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N03", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O07", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "The reference does not extend a contextual claim about truly personal devices to servers. Current cumulative fulfillment does not mean every laptop or computer is fanless.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-007", "relation": "CANONICALIZE" } ] }, "id": "K005", "familyId": "K005", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K005", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "solid state", "moving parts", "Storage and device design" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Most personal computing devices have no moving parts.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Most personal computing devices have no moving parts.", "successCriteria": "The pocket/worn personal computers in the surrounding passage generally use electronic storage rather than rotating media.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 6, printed p. 15", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N03", "id": "N03-0", "title": "Apple: Small clip-on iPod shuffle", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2009/03/11Apple-Announces-Incredible-New-iPod-shuffle/", "publishedAt": "2009-03-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." }, { "sourceId": "O07", "id": "O07-1", "title": "iPhone App Store downloads top 10 million", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2008/07/14iPhone-App-Store-Downloads-Top-10-Million-in-First-Weekend/", "publishedAt": "2008-07-14", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Opening announcement and descriptions of wireless application downloads and Multi-Touch features. The release establishes downloadable applications on iPhone/iPod touch and their touch interface. Evidence limits: It does not establish storage technology or the absence of moving components; see the added flash-player source." }, { "sourceId": "SUP001", "id": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18-SUP001", "title": "Apple introduces iPod shuffle (2005)", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2005/01/11Apple-Introduces-iPod-shuffle/", "publishedAt": "2005-01-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "USB flash-drive paragraph and Pricing & Availability section. Apple documents a shipping flash-storage player in January 2005. Interpreting flash storage as avoiding mechanical disk storage supports the portable-device criterion. Evidence limits: This is an editorial inference about storage; physical switches remain, and the source does not establish a majority across all personal devices." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009. This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”", "alternativeInterpretation": "The reference does not extend a contextual claim about truly personal devices to servers. Current cumulative fulfillment does not mean every laptop or computer is fanless.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "The reference does not extend a contextual claim about truly personal devices to servers. Current cumulative fulfillment does not mean every laptop or computer is fanless.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. Phones and notebooks cannot be silently combined or separated to obtain a favorable majority. Apple’s 2008 Air still offered a hard disk as well as an SSD option. A sales/installed-base denominator is needed. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009. This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”" }, { "date": "2026-10-18", "note": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18: 2 primary citation checks/additions. Primary citation locators, source-specific support limits and additional corroborating references; no changes to verdicts, eligibility or timing judgments." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"The pocket/worn personal computers in the surrounding passage generally use electronic storage rather than rotating media.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009. This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N03\",\"O07\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Apply the solid-state/no-moving-parts claim to portable PCs including laptops, not just the pocket/worn context.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Hard drives were common in 2009 laptops; current widespread SSDs fulfill storage substitution, but a literal no-moving-parts condition still conflicts with many cooling fans.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_POPULATION\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N03\",\"O07\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"The pocket/worn personal computers in the surrounding passage generally use electronic storage rather than rotating media.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009. This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N03\",\"O07\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2009\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"Phones and notebooks cannot be silently combined or separated to obtain a favorable majority. Apple’s 2008 Air still offered a hard disk as well as an SSD option. A sales/installed-base denominator is needed.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K005\",\"slug\":\"k005-personal-devices-largely-without-moving-parts\",\"title\":\"Personal devices largely without moving parts\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Most personal computing devices have no moving parts.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[\"solid state\",\"moving parts\"],\"subcategory\":\"Storage and device design\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K005\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-007\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"The pocket/worn personal computers in the surrounding passage generally use electronic storage rather than rotating media.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Flash-based phones and small music players fit the devices described in the passage by 2009. This remains a full success for that device class. Buttons, haptic motors and exceptions do not defeat “for the most part.”\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2009,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 6, printed p. 15\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N03\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O07\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"The reference does not extend a contextual claim about truly personal devices to servers. Current cumulative fulfillment does not mean every laptop or computer is fanless.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-007\",\"relation\":\"CANONICALIZE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Across newly sold portable computing devices, including smartphones and tablets, most lack physical keyboards.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then. By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2015, "at_deadline_rationale": "Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then.", "at_review_rationale": "By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O07", "N02", "N53" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Conventional notebook/laptop computers mostly lose their physical keyboards.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "That narrower population does not fulfill the prediction. It is a population sensitivity, not the only legitimate meaning of portable computer.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_POPULATION", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "O07", "N02", "N53" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Across newly sold portable computing devices, including smartphones and tablets, most lack physical keyboards.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then. By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2015, "at_deadline_rationale": "Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then.", "at_review_rationale": "By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O07", "N02", "N53" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2015, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "EDITORIAL_ERA_BOUND", "label": "By the mid-2010s on the stated market reading; exact threshold year not established", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "bound_is_editorial": true }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The input changed keyboard absence into touch/voice use. Those are not equivalent. The required 2009 device-population comparison is still missing.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K006", "slug": "k006-most-portable-computers-lack-keyboards", "title": "Most portable computers lack keyboards", "prediction_paraphrase": "Most portable computers have no keyboards.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "keyboards", "portable computing" ], "subcategory": "Input hardware", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K006", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-008" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Across newly sold portable computing devices, including smartphones and tablets, most lack physical keyboards.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then.", "at_review_rationale": "By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "LATE", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then. By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2015, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 7, printed p. 16", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O07", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N02", "locator": "US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N53", "locator": "968 million smartphones; Android plus iOS dominated. Inferring physical-keyboard-free portable computing requires a population definition, not simply counting all feature phones.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Physical keyboards, not on-screen keyboards. Reference is new-device unit mix, not lifetime installed computers; 2015 is a conservative documented-era estimate with medium timing confidence, not a counted exact crossover.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-008", "relation": "CORRECT_SCOPE" } ] }, "id": "K006", "familyId": "K006", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K006", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "keyboards", "portable computing", "Input hardware" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Most portable computers have no keyboards.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Most portable computers have no keyboards.", "successCriteria": "Across newly sold portable computing devices, including smartphones and tablets, most lack physical keyboards.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 7, printed p. 16", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O07", "id": "O07-0", "title": "iPhone App Store downloads top 10 million", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2008/07/14iPhone-App-Store-Downloads-Top-10-Million-in-First-Weekend/", "publishedAt": "2008-07-14", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Multi-Touch feature paragraph and cellular/Wi-Fi application-delivery paragraphs. This documents touch-based software use on the supported devices. Evidence limits: It does not quantify the share of keyboard-free portable computers; the added original iPhone announcement directly describes a soft keyboard." }, { "sourceId": "N02", "id": "N02-1", "title": "Pew: Americans and their gadgets", "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2010/10/14/americans-and-their-gadgets/", "publishedAt": "2010-10-14", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks.. US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks." }, { "sourceId": "N53", "id": "N53-2", "title": "Gartner: Worldwide smartphone sales in 2013", "url": "https://www.pressebox.com/pressrelease/gartner-uk-ltd/Gartner-Says-Annual-Smartphone-Sales-Surpassed-Sales-of-Feature-Phones-for-the-First-Time-in-2013/boxid/658123", "publishedAt": "2014-02-13", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "968 million smartphones; Android plus iOS dominated. Inferring physical-keyboard-free portable computing requires a population definition, not simply counting all feature phones.. 968 million smartphones; Android plus iOS dominated. Inferring physical-keyboard-free portable computing requires a population definition, not simply counting all feature phones." }, { "sourceId": "SUP002", "id": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18-SUP002", "title": "Apple reinvents the phone with iPhone", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2007/01/09Apple-Reinvents-the-Phone-with-iPhone/", "publishedAt": "2007-01-09", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "iPhone is a Revolutionary Mobile Phone section: SMS and touch-keyboard paragraph. The original iPhone announcement explicitly describes an onscreen keyboard, directly supporting the availability of physical-keyboard-free portables. Evidence limits: The announcement is not a device-population share study and does not establish majority adoption in 2009." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then. By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Physical keyboards, not on-screen keyboards. Reference is new-device unit mix, not lifetime installed computers; 2015 is a conservative documented-era estimate with medium timing confidence, not a counted exact crossover.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Physical keyboards, not on-screen keyboards. Reference is new-device unit mix, not lifetime installed computers; 2015 is a conservative documented-era estimate with medium timing confidence, not a counted exact crossover.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. The input changed keyboard absence into touch/voice use. Those are not equivalent. The required 2009 device-population comparison is still missing. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict LATE. Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then. By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established." }, { "date": "2026-10-18", "note": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18: 2 primary citation checks/additions. Primary citation locators, source-specific support limits and additional corroborating references; no changes to verdicts, eligibility or timing judgments." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Across newly sold portable computing devices, including smartphones and tablets, most lack physical keyboards.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then. By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O07\",\"N02\",\"N53\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Conventional notebook/laptop computers mostly lose their physical keyboards.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"That narrower population does not fulfill the prediction. It is a population sensitivity, not the only legitimate meaning of portable computer.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_POPULATION\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O07\",\"N02\",\"N53\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Across newly sold portable computing devices, including smartphones and tablets, most lack physical keyboards.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then. By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O07\",\"N02\",\"N53\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"EDITORIAL_ERA_BOUND\",\"label\":\"By the mid-2010s on the stated market reading; exact threshold year not established\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"bound_is_editorial\":true},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The input changed keyboard absence into touch/voice use. Those are not equivalent. The required 2009 device-population comparison is still missing.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K006\",\"slug\":\"k006-most-portable-computers-lack-keyboards\",\"title\":\"Most portable computers lack keyboards\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Most portable computers have no keyboards.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[\"keyboards\",\"portable computing\"],\"subcategory\":\"Input hardware\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K006\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-008\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Across newly sold portable computing devices, including smartphones and tablets, most lack physical keyboards.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Touchscreen portables were real by 2009, but widespread keyboard-equipped phones and notebooks make full majority fulfillment unpersuasive then. By the mid-2010s, touch-first smartphones dominated portable computing unit volumes. Gartner’s 2013 smartphone/platform mix supports the transition; the exact crossover is not established.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2015,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 7, printed p. 16\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O07\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N02\",\"locator\":\"US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N53\",\"locator\":\"968 million smartphones; Android plus iOS dominated. Inferring physical-keyboard-free portable computing requires a population definition, not simply counting all feature phones.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Physical keyboards, not on-screen keyboards. Reference is new-device unit mix, not lifetime installed computers; 2015 is a conservative documented-era estimate with medium timing confidence, not a counted exact crossover.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-008\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_SCOPE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Most users keep large personal digital collections on servers physically at home or in their offices.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model. Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model.", "at_review_rationale": "Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N02", "O10", "O06" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Most users keep large personal digital collections on servers physically at home or in their offices.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model. Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model.", "at_review_rationale": "Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N02", "O10", "O06" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Personal digital collections live on servers accessible across devices, regardless of location.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Cloud-backed libraries and synchronization realize the function. This deliberately relaxes the home/office location requirement.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Server location" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2011, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N02", "O10", "O06" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The server/cloud distinction was blurred in the intake. The source is located, but no appropriate adoption denominator has been established. Missing evidence is not a WRONG verdict.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K007", "slug": "k007-home-and-office-servers-for-most-users", "title": "Home and office servers for most users", "prediction_paraphrase": "Most users maintain home and office servers.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Networks & communications", "tags": [ "home servers", "adoption" ], "subcategory": "Local storage infrastructure", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K007", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-009" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Most users keep large personal digital collections on servers physically at home or in their offices.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model.", "at_review_rationale": "Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model. Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 8, printed p. 17", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N02", "locator": "US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O10", "locator": "Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O06", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-009", "relation": "CORRECT_SCOPE" } ] }, "id": "K007", "familyId": "K007", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K007", "category": "Networks & communications", "tags": [ "home servers", "adoption", "Local storage infrastructure" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Most users maintain home and office servers.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Most users maintain home and office servers.", "successCriteria": "Most users keep large personal digital collections on servers physically at home or in their offices.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 8, printed p. 17", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N02", "id": "N02-0", "title": "Pew: Americans and their gadgets", "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2010/10/14/americans-and-their-gadgets/", "publishedAt": "2010-10-14", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks.. US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks." }, { "sourceId": "O10", "id": "O10-1", "title": "Apple launches iPhone 4S, iOS 5 and iCloud", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2011/10/04Apple-Launches-iPhone-4S-iOS-5-iCloud/", "publishedAt": "2011-10-04", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release.. Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release." }, { "sourceId": "O06", "id": "O06-2", "title": "iTunes Store tops over five billion songs sold", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2008/06/19iTunes-Store-Tops-Over-Five-Billion-Songs-Sold/", "publishedAt": "2008-06-19", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Opening sales paragraph and descriptions of digital movie distribution. The release documents billions of digital song downloads and a substantial movie-download business. Evidence limits: This is digital-collection context only, not evidence of home-server ownership or the adoption denominator." }, { "sourceId": "SUP003", "id": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18-SUP003", "title": "Microsoft unveils Windows Home Server at CES 2007", "url": "https://news.microsoft.com/source/2007/01/08/bill-gates-unveils-windows-home-server-at-the-2007-international-consumer-electronics-show/", "publishedAt": "2007-01-08", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Simplifying Digital Life and Connecting Digital Devices and Experiences sections. Microsoft describes automatic PC backups, centralized home media and remote Internet access from a home-local server. Evidence limits: This adds direct architecture evidence. The January announcement projected release later in 2007 and supplies no evidence that most households adopted it." }, { "sourceId": "SUP004", "id": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18-SUP004", "title": "Windows Home Server — Microsoft Lifecycle", "url": "https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/lifecycle/products/windows-home-server", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Support Dates table: Windows Home Server start date. The official lifecycle entry gives 2007-10-11 as the product start date, corroborating a pre-2009 product timeline. Evidence limits: A support start date is not a retail shipment count or evidence of widespread home-server ownership." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model. Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. The server/cloud distinction was blurred in the intake. The source is located, but no appropriate adoption denominator has been established. Missing evidence is not a WRONG verdict. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model. Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture." }, { "date": "2026-10-18", "note": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18: 3 primary citation checks/additions. Primary citation locators, source-specific support limits and additional corroborating references; no changes to verdicts, eligibility or timing judgments." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Most users keep large personal digital collections on servers physically at home or in their offices.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model. Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N02\",\"O10\",\"O06\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Most users keep large personal digital collections on servers physically at home or in their offices.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model. Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N02\",\"O10\",\"O06\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Personal digital collections live on servers accessible across devices, regardless of location.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Cloud-backed libraries and synchronization realize the function. This deliberately relaxes the home/office location requirement.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Server location\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2011,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N02\",\"O10\",\"O06\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The server/cloud distinction was blurred in the intake. The source is located, but no appropriate adoption denominator has been established. Missing evidence is not a WRONG verdict.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K007\",\"slug\":\"k007-home-and-office-servers-for-most-users\",\"title\":\"Home and office servers for most users\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Most users maintain home and office servers.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Networks & communications\",\"tags\":[\"home servers\",\"adoption\"],\"subcategory\":\"Local storage infrastructure\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K007\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-009\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Most users keep large personal digital collections on servers physically at home or in their offices.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Home/network storage and office servers existed, but home servers were not the typical personal-computing model. Large digital collections and server-backed access are ordinary, but cloud hosting displaced much of the predicted home-server architecture.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 8, printed p. 17\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N02\",\"locator\":\"US survey, seven broad device categories; median three categories. A proxy for device ownership, not a direct census of worn processors or 2009 body networks.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O10\",\"locator\":\"Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O06\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-009\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_SCOPE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Books, music, video and software can routinely be delivered as downloadable wireless data without a physical carrier.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline. Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline.", "at_review_rationale": "Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O05", "O06", "O07" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Books, music, video and software can routinely be delivered as downloadable wireless data without a physical carrier.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline. Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline.", "at_review_rationale": "Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O05", "O06", "O07" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Books, music, video and software can routinely be delivered as downloadable wireless data without a physical carrier.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline. Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline.", "at_review_rationale": "Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O05", "O06", "O07" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2009, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2009", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Kindle offered wireless books and periodicals in 2007. Apple documented large-scale music and film downloads in 2008 and wireless application delivery over cellular/Wi-Fi that July. This verifies a digital-distribution capability, not a majority share of all books or media.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2008, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K008", "slug": "k008-wireless-delivery-of-digital-media-and-software", "title": "Wireless delivery of digital media and software", "prediction_paraphrase": "Digital media and software arrive as wireless files.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [ "ebooks", "music", "film", "software" ], "subcategory": "Digital distribution", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K008", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-010" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Books, music, video and software can routinely be delivered as downloadable wireless data without a physical carrier.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline.", "at_review_rationale": "Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline. Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2009, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 9, printed p. 18", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O05", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O06", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O07", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-010", "relation": "CORRECT_SCOPE" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-005", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" } ] }, "id": "K008", "familyId": "K008", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K008", "category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [ "ebooks", "music", "film", "software", "Digital distribution" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Digital media and software arrive as wireless files.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Digital media and software arrive as wireless files.", "successCriteria": "Books, music, video and software can routinely be delivered as downloadable wireless data without a physical carrier.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 9, printed p. 18", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O05", "id": "O05-0", "title": "Introducing Amazon Kindle", "url": "https://press.aboutamazon.com/2007/11/introducing-amazon-kindle", "publishedAt": "2007-11-19", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Wireless-delivery section and Books, Blogs, Magazines and Newspapers section. The 2007 Kindle release describes EVDO delivery of books and periodicals without a computer or Wi-Fi hotspot. Evidence limits: This establishes available functions; it does not establish the share of all media delivered wirelessly." }, { "sourceId": "O06", "id": "O06-1", "title": "iTunes Store tops over five billion songs sold", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2008/06/19iTunes-Store-Tops-Over-Five-Billion-Songs-Sold/", "publishedAt": "2008-06-19", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Opening sales paragraph and catalogue descriptions. Apple reports five billion song downloads and more than 50,000 daily movie rentals/purchases by June 2008. Evidence limits: These are digital-distribution counts, not wireless-only transactions or all-media market share." }, { "sourceId": "O07", "id": "O07-2", "title": "iPhone App Store downloads top 10 million", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2008/07/14iPhone-App-Store-Downloads-Top-10-Million-in-First-Weekend/", "publishedAt": "2008-07-14", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Wireless-download paragraph and cellular/Wi-Fi distribution paragraph. The July 2008 release explicitly describes direct app downloads over cellular networks and Wi-Fi. Evidence limits: The same release also describes USB syncing; wireless availability does not mean cables had disappeared." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline. Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: CORRECT. Kindle offered wireless books and periodicals in 2007. Apple documented large-scale music and film downloads in 2008 and wireless application delivery over cellular/Wi-Fi that July. This verifies a digital-distribution capability, not a majority share of all books or media. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline. Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital." }, { "date": "2026-10-18", "note": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18: 3 primary citation checks/additions. Primary citation locators, source-specific support limits and additional corroborating references; no changes to verdicts, eligibility or timing judgments." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Books, music, video and software can routinely be delivered as downloadable wireless data without a physical carrier.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline. Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O05\",\"O06\",\"O07\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Books, music, video and software can routinely be delivered as downloadable wireless data without a physical carrier.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline. Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O05\",\"O06\",\"O07\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Books, music, video and software can routinely be delivered as downloadable wireless data without a physical carrier.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline. Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O05\",\"O06\",\"O07\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2009\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Kindle offered wireless books and periodicals in 2007. Apple documented large-scale music and film downloads in 2008 and wireless application delivery over cellular/Wi-Fi that July. This verifies a digital-distribution capability, not a majority share of all books or media.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2008,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K008\",\"slug\":\"k008-wireless-delivery-of-digital-media-and-software\",\"title\":\"Wireless delivery of digital media and software\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Digital media and software arrive as wireless files.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Media, education & culture\",\"tags\":[\"ebooks\",\"music\",\"film\",\"software\"],\"subcategory\":\"Digital distribution\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K008\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-010\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Books, music, video and software can routinely be delivered as downloadable wireless data without a physical carrier.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Kindle, iTunes and the App Store supplied the listed media/software functions before the deadline. Continued paper-book or disc sales do not refute routine file distribution; the claim does not require every purchase to be digital.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2009,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 9, printed p. 18\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O05\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O06\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O07\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-010\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_SCOPE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-005\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Wireless links substantially displace short peripheral cables in ordinary use; “disappearing” describes a trend, not zero cables.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009. The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O08", "O09" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "The full listed peripheral set, including most displays, ordinarily communicates wirelessly.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Wireless input and networking are established, but wired monitors and other peripherals preserve an important part of the listed ecology.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "O08", "O09" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Wireless links substantially displace short peripheral cables in ordinary use; “disappearing” describes a trend, not zero cables.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009. The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O08", "O09" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2009, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2009", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "PARTIAL", "at_review": "FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Bluetooth keyboards and mice were shipping years before 2009. This supports meaningful substitution, but does not establish the whole range of links, including displays. The intake’s “cables will vanish” wording was too absolute.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K009", "slug": "k009-wireless-links-replace-some-peripheral-cables", "title": "Wireless links replace some peripheral cables", "prediction_paraphrase": "Short-range wireless links reduce peripheral cabling.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Networks & communications", "tags": [ "Bluetooth", "cables" ], "subcategory": "Peripheral connectivity", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K009", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-011" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Wireless links substantially displace short peripheral cables in ordinary use; “disappearing” describes a trend, not zero cables.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009. The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2009, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 12, printed p. 20", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O08", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O09", "locator": "US adult survey. Ever-used wireless access is not a majority-of-traffic measure and is not global coverage.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-011", "relation": "CORRECT_SCOPE" } ] }, "id": "K009", "familyId": "K009", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K009", "category": "Networks & communications", "tags": [ "Bluetooth", "cables", "Peripheral connectivity" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Short-range wireless links reduce peripheral cabling.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Short-range wireless links reduce peripheral cabling.", "successCriteria": "Wireless links substantially displace short peripheral cables in ordinary use; “disappearing” describes a trend, not zero cables.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 12, printed p. 20", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O08", "id": "O08-0", "title": "Apple introduces wireless keyboard and mouse", "url": "https://www.apple.com/ca/newsroom/2003/09/16Apple-Introduces-Wireless-Keyboard-Mouse/", "publishedAt": "2003-09-16", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Opening Bluetooth product description and cable-replacement feature paragraphs. Apple introduced Bluetooth keyboards and mice in September 2003, directly supporting peripheral cable substitution. Evidence limits: The release does not show that monitor cables or power leads were eliminated." }, { "sourceId": "O09", "id": "O09-1", "title": "Wireless Internet Use — Pew Research Center", "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2009/07/22/wireless-internet-use/", "publishedAt": "2009-07-22", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "US adult survey. Ever-used wireless access is not a majority-of-traffic measure and is not global coverage.. US adult survey. Ever-used wireless access is not a majority-of-traffic measure and is not global coverage." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009. The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PARTIAL. Bluetooth keyboards and mice were shipping years before 2009. This supports meaningful substitution, but does not establish the whole range of links, including displays. The intake’s “cables will vanish” wording was too absolute. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009. The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed." }, { "date": "2026-10-18", "note": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18: 1 primary citation checks/additions. Primary citation locators, source-specific support limits and additional corroborating references; no changes to verdicts, eligibility or timing judgments." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Wireless links substantially displace short peripheral cables in ordinary use; “disappearing” describes a trend, not zero cables.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009. The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O08\",\"O09\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"The full listed peripheral set, including most displays, ordinarily communicates wirelessly.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Wireless input and networking are established, but wired monitors and other peripherals preserve an important part of the listed ecology.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O08\",\"O09\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Wireless links substantially displace short peripheral cables in ordinary use; “disappearing” describes a trend, not zero cables.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009. The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O08\",\"O09\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2009\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTIAL\",\"at_review\":\"FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Bluetooth keyboards and mice were shipping years before 2009. This supports meaningful substitution, but does not establish the whole range of links, including displays. The intake’s “cables will vanish” wording was too absolute.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K009\",\"slug\":\"k009-wireless-links-replace-some-peripheral-cables\",\"title\":\"Wireless links replace some peripheral cables\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Short-range wireless links reduce peripheral cabling.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Networks & communications\",\"tags\":[\"Bluetooth\",\"cables\"],\"subcategory\":\"Peripheral connectivity\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K009\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-011\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Wireless links substantially displace short peripheral cables in ordinary use; “disappearing” describes a trend, not zero cables.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Commercial Bluetooth keyboards/mice and ordinary Wi-Fi demonstrate the predicted transition by 2009. The broad direction holds. Charging leads and remaining monitor cables are not evidence that the trend failed.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2009,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 12, printed p. 20\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O08\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O09\",\"locator\":\"US adult survey. Ever-used wireless access is not a majority-of-traffic measure and is not global coverage.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-011\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_SCOPE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Wireless Internet is a routine built-in capability with useful broadband availability in connected markets.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity. Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity.", "at_review_rationale": "Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O09", "O07" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "The network is instantly available with high bandwidth across essentially all ordinary locations.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Coverage and reliability qualifications remain. This gives additional weight to the “ever-present” language without treating an isolated outage as failure.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "O09", "O07" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Wireless Internet is a routine built-in capability with useful broadband availability in connected markets.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity. Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity.", "at_review_rationale": "Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O09", "O07" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2009, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2009", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "PARTIAL", "at_review": "FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Built-in Wi-Fi was real, and Pew found 56% of US adults had ever used wireless Internet in 2009. Only 19% had used handheld Internet the previous day. This supports substantial use, not universal reliable high-bandwidth access.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K010", "slug": "k010-routine-reliable-high-bandwidth-wireless-access", "title": "Routine, reliable, high-bandwidth wireless access", "prediction_paraphrase": "Computers routinely reach an ever-available high-bandwidth network.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Networks & communications", "tags": [ "Wi-Fi", "mobile access", "adoption" ], "subcategory": "Wireless Internet", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K010", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-012", "DEC-013" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Wireless Internet is a routine built-in capability with useful broadband availability in connected markets.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity.", "at_review_rationale": "Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity. Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2009, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 13, printed p. 21", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O09", "locator": "US adult survey. Ever-used wireless access is not a majority-of-traffic measure and is not global coverage.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O07", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "US survey is evidence of routine connected-market use, not worldwide universal access. “High bandwidth” is judged relative to the forecast era.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-012", "relation": "CORRECT_AND_MERGE_SCOPE" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-013", "relation": "CORRECT_AND_MERGE_SCOPE" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-004", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-025", "relation": "QUARANTINE_DATE_DISTORTION" } ] }, "id": "K010", "familyId": "K010", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K010", "category": "Networks & communications", "tags": [ "Wi-Fi", "mobile access", "adoption", "Wireless Internet" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Computers routinely reach an ever-available high-bandwidth network.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Computers routinely reach an ever-available high-bandwidth network.", "successCriteria": "Wireless Internet is a routine built-in capability with useful broadband availability in connected markets.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 13, printed p. 21", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O09", "id": "O09-0", "title": "Wireless Internet Use — Pew Research Center", "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2009/07/22/wireless-internet-use/", "publishedAt": "2009-07-22", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Wireless Internet Use overview: opening wireless-use finding and mobile-use comparison bullets. Pew reports 56% of Americans had ever used wireless Internet and 19% used mobile Internet the previous day in its April 2009 survey. Evidence limits: These are US adult survey measures, not global population coverage, wireless traffic share or a continuous-service guarantee." }, { "sourceId": "O07", "id": "O07-1", "title": "iPhone App Store downloads top 10 million", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2008/07/14iPhone-App-Store-Downloads-Top-10-Million-in-First-Weekend/", "publishedAt": "2008-07-14", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Paragraph describing cellular-network and Wi-Fi access to the App Store. The release confirms operational wireless software delivery on shipping mobile platforms. Evidence limits: It does not measure continuous coverage, throughput or population-wide usage." }, { "sourceId": "SUP002", "id": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18-SUP002", "title": "Apple reinvents the phone with iPhone", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2007/01/09Apple-Reinvents-the-Phone-with-iPhone/", "publishedAt": "2007-01-09", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Data-networking paragraph and Breakthrough Internet Communications Device section. Apple describes EDGE and Wi-Fi web/email access on the announced 2007 iPhone. Evidence limits: This documents product capability, not reliable universal coverage or usage prevalence." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity. Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.", "alternativeInterpretation": "US survey is evidence of routine connected-market use, not worldwide universal access. “High bandwidth” is judged relative to the forecast era.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "US survey is evidence of routine connected-market use, not worldwide universal access. “High bandwidth” is judged relative to the forecast era.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PARTIAL. Built-in Wi-Fi was real, and Pew found 56% of US adults had ever used wireless Internet in 2009. Only 19% had used handheld Internet the previous day. This supports substantial use, not universal reliable high-bandwidth access. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity. Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements." }, { "date": "2026-10-18", "note": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18: 3 primary citation checks/additions. Primary citation locators, source-specific support limits and additional corroborating references; no changes to verdicts, eligibility or timing judgments." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Wireless Internet is a routine built-in capability with useful broadband availability in connected markets.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity. Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O09\",\"O07\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"The network is instantly available with high bandwidth across essentially all ordinary locations.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Coverage and reliability qualifications remain. This gives additional weight to the “ever-present” language without treating an isolated outage as failure.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O09\",\"O07\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Wireless Internet is a routine built-in capability with useful broadband availability in connected markets.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity. Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O09\",\"O07\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2009\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTIAL\",\"at_review\":\"FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Built-in Wi-Fi was real, and Pew found 56% of US adults had ever used wireless Internet in 2009. Only 19% had used handheld Internet the previous day. This supports substantial use, not universal reliable high-bandwidth access.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K010\",\"slug\":\"k010-routine-reliable-high-bandwidth-wireless-access\",\"title\":\"Routine, reliable, high-bandwidth wireless access\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Computers routinely reach an ever-available high-bandwidth network.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Networks & communications\",\"tags\":[\"Wi-Fi\",\"mobile access\",\"adoption\"],\"subcategory\":\"Wireless Internet\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K010\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-012\",\"DEC-013\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Wireless Internet is a routine built-in capability with useful broadband availability in connected markets.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Pew found 56% of US adults had used wireless Internet by 2009; shipping devices included Wi-Fi/cellular connectivity. Routine access is established. Universal coverage, perfect uptime and unlimited bandwidth were not imposed as extra requirements.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2009,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 13, printed p. 21\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O09\",\"locator\":\"US adult survey. Ever-used wireless access is not a majority-of-traffic measure and is not global coverage.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O07\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"US survey is evidence of routine connected-market use, not worldwide universal access. “High bandwidth” is judged relative to the forecast era.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-012\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_AND_MERGE_SCOPE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-013\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_AND_MERGE_SCOPE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-004\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-025\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_DATE_DISTORTION\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "More than half of generated text comes from continuous-speech dictation.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009. Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "O10", "N46" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "More than half of generated text comes from continuous-speech dictation.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009. Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "O10", "N46" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Accurate everyday dictation and speech input become ordinary computer features.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Speech features and assistants fulfill the capability reading, but capability is not majority use.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Majority-of-text threshold" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2015, "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "O10", "N46" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "WRONG_MISSED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Kurzweil’s own retrospective expressly concedes the majority threshold was not reached. That is direct evidence of the historical deadline miss, though not an independent global usage survey. Subsequent speech-recognition progress cannot retroactively make 2009 an on-time hit.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K011", "slug": "k011-dictation-creates-the-majority-of-text", "title": "Dictation creates the majority of text", "prediction_paraphrase": "Speech dictation produces most text.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "dictation", "text input", "adoption" ], "subcategory": "Speech recognition", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K011", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-013" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "More than half of generated text comes from continuous-speech dictation.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009. Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 14, printed p. 22", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O10", "locator": "Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N46", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "AI-generated text is not speech-dictated text. Product availability alone is not evidence for the quantitative original. Current miss has medium confidence because global composition shares are not directly measured.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-013", "relation": "RESTORE_THRESHOLD" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-010", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" } ] }, "id": "K011", "familyId": "K011", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K011", "category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "dictation", "text input", "adoption", "Speech recognition" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Speech dictation produces most text.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Speech dictation produces most text.", "successCriteria": "More than half of generated text comes from continuous-speech dictation.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 14, printed p. 22", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P01", "id": "P01-0", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.. Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices." }, { "sourceId": "O10", "id": "O10-1", "title": "Apple launches iPhone 4S, iOS 5 and iCloud", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2011/10/04Apple-Launches-iPhone-4S-iOS-5-iCloud/", "publishedAt": "2011-10-04", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release.. Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release." }, { "sourceId": "N46", "id": "N46-2", "title": "Microsoft Teams reaches 13 million daily active users", "url": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/blog/2019/07/11/microsoft-teams-reaches-13-million-daily-active-users-introduces-4-new-ways-for-teams-to-work-better-together/", "publishedAt": "2019-07-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009. Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.", "alternativeInterpretation": "AI-generated text is not speech-dictated text. Product availability alone is not evidence for the quantitative original. Current miss has medium confidence because global composition shares are not directly measured.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "AI-generated text is not speech-dictated text. Product availability alone is not evidence for the quantitative original. Current miss has medium confidence because global composition shares are not directly measured.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: WRONG_MISSED. Kurzweil’s own retrospective expressly concedes the majority threshold was not reached. That is direct evidence of the historical deadline miss, though not an independent global usage survey. Subsequent speech-recognition progress cannot retroactively make 2009 an on-time hit. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009. Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"More than half of generated text comes from continuous-speech dictation.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009. Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"O10\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"More than half of generated text comes from continuous-speech dictation.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009. Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"O10\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Accurate everyday dictation and speech input become ordinary computer features.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Speech features and assistants fulfill the capability reading, but capability is not majority use.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Majority-of-text threshold\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"O10\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG_MISSED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Kurzweil’s own retrospective expressly concedes the majority threshold was not reached. That is direct evidence of the historical deadline miss, though not an independent global usage survey. Subsequent speech-recognition progress cannot retroactively make 2009 an on-time hit.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K011\",\"slug\":\"k011-dictation-creates-the-majority-of-text\",\"title\":\"Dictation creates the majority of text\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Speech dictation produces most text.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"AI & software\",\"tags\":[\"dictation\",\"text input\",\"adoption\"],\"subcategory\":\"Speech recognition\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K011\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-013\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"More than half of generated text comes from continuous-speech dictation.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The author’s own retrospective acknowledges that dictation had not become the majority input method in 2009. Dictation is effective and widely available, but typing and non-dictated text remain central. The majority claim is still not supported; this assessment is an inference, not a global text-volume census.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 14, printed p. 22\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O10\",\"locator\":\"Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N46\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"AI-generated text is not speech-dictated text. Product availability alone is not evidence for the quantitative original. Current miss has medium confidence because global composition shares are not directly measured.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-013\",\"relation\":\"RESTORE_THRESHOLD\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-010\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Task-oriented natural-language interfaces are broadly routine, including the forecast’s frequent animated-personality presentation.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline. Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline.", "at_review_rationale": "Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "O10", "N46" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Task-oriented natural-language interfaces are broadly routine, including the forecast’s frequent animated-personality presentation.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline. Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline.", "at_review_rationale": "Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "O10", "N46" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Routine spoken-language personal assistants, without requiring visible avatars.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Commercial smartphone assistants provide the functional result. This omits the frequent avatar requirement.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Frequent visual avatars" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2015, "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "O10", "N46" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "PARTIAL", "at_review": "FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The author’s retrospective acknowledges non-ubiquity while describing narrower implementations. Apple’s 2011 Siri launch is later evidence of a capable assistant, not proof that the full 2009 adoption claim was met.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K012", "slug": "k012-ubiquitous-language-interfaces-and-animated-assistants", "title": "Ubiquitous language interfaces and animated assistants", "prediction_paraphrase": "Routine-task language interfaces become ubiquitous, often with avatars.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "voice assistants", "avatars", "adoption" ], "subcategory": "Language interfaces", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K012", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-014" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Task-oriented natural-language interfaces are broadly routine, including the forecast’s frequent animated-personality presentation.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline.", "at_review_rationale": "Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline. Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 15, printed p. 23", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O10", "locator": "Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N46", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-014", "relation": "RESTORE_QUALIFIERS" }, { "legacy_id": "AUD-027", "relation": "QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_UNLOCATED" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-007", "relation": "QUARANTINE_CONFLICTING_VERSIONS" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-003", "relation": "QUARANTINE_CONFLICTING_VERSIONS" } ] }, "id": "K012", "familyId": "K012", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K012", "category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "voice assistants", "avatars", "adoption", "Language interfaces" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Routine-task language interfaces become ubiquitous, often with avatars.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Routine-task language interfaces become ubiquitous, often with avatars.", "successCriteria": "Task-oriented natural-language interfaces are broadly routine, including the forecast’s frequent animated-personality presentation.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 15, printed p. 23", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P01", "id": "P01-0", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.. Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices." }, { "sourceId": "O10", "id": "O10-1", "title": "Apple launches iPhone 4S, iOS 5 and iCloud", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2011/10/04Apple-Launches-iPhone-4S-iOS-5-iCloud/", "publishedAt": "2011-10-04", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release.. Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release." }, { "sourceId": "N46", "id": "N46-2", "title": "Microsoft Teams reaches 13 million daily active users", "url": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/blog/2019/07/11/microsoft-teams-reaches-13-million-daily-active-users-introduces-4-new-ways-for-teams-to-work-better-together/", "publishedAt": "2019-07-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline. Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PARTIAL. The author’s retrospective acknowledges non-ubiquity while describing narrower implementations. Apple’s 2011 Siri launch is later evidence of a capable assistant, not proof that the full 2009 adoption claim was met. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline. Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Task-oriented natural-language interfaces are broadly routine, including the forecast’s frequent animated-personality presentation.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline. Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"O10\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Task-oriented natural-language interfaces are broadly routine, including the forecast’s frequent animated-personality presentation.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline. Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"O10\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Routine spoken-language personal assistants, without requiring visible avatars.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Commercial smartphone assistants provide the functional result. This omits the frequent avatar requirement.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Frequent visual avatars\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"O10\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTIAL\",\"at_review\":\"FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The author’s retrospective acknowledges non-ubiquity while describing narrower implementations. Apple’s 2011 Siri launch is later evidence of a capable assistant, not proof that the full 2009 adoption claim was met.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K012\",\"slug\":\"k012-ubiquitous-language-interfaces-and-animated-assistants\",\"title\":\"Ubiquitous language interfaces and animated assistants\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Routine-task language interfaces become ubiquitous, often with avatars.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"AI & software\",\"tags\":[\"voice assistants\",\"avatars\",\"adoption\"],\"subcategory\":\"Language interfaces\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K012\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-014\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Task-oriented natural-language interfaces are broadly routine, including the forecast’s frequent animated-personality presentation.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Language interfaces existed, but the retrospective concedes that they were not ubiquitous at the deadline. Siri and later assistants fulfill routine natural-language interaction. The recurring avatar/personality presentation is less fully realized, so the full compound remains partial.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 15, printed p. 23\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O10\",\"locator\":\"Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N46\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-014\",\"relation\":\"RESTORE_QUALIFIERS\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-027\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_UNLOCATED\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-007\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_CONFLICTING_VERSIONS\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-003\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_CONFLICTING_VERSIONS\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Small book-sized displays provide high contrast, readable resolution, broad viewing angles and no distracting flicker; digital reading is routine.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions. The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2007, "at_deadline_rationale": "Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions.", "at_review_rationale": "The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O05" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Small book-sized displays provide high contrast, readable resolution, broad viewing angles and no distracting flicker; digital reading is routine.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions. The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2007, "at_deadline_rationale": "Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions.", "at_review_rationale": "The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O05" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Small book-sized displays provide high contrast, readable resolution, broad viewing angles and no distracting flicker; digital reading is routine.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions. The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2007, "at_deadline_rationale": "Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions.", "at_review_rationale": "The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O05" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2007, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2007", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "PARTIAL", "at_review": "FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The 2007 Kindle provided a paper-like electronic display and wireless books, newspapers and magazines. That establishes a substantial realization, but this review does not equate its 167-ppi display with every quality of paper or establish the full adoption scope.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K013", "slug": "k013-paper-like-displays-and-routine-electronic-reading", "title": "Paper-like displays and routine electronic reading", "prediction_paraphrase": "Paper-like small displays support routine electronic reading.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "e-ink", "display quality" ], "subcategory": "Electronic reading", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K013", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-015" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Small book-sized displays provide high contrast, readable resolution, broad viewing angles and no distracting flicker; digital reading is routine.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions.", "at_review_rationale": "The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions. The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2007, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 16, printed p. 24", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O05", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-015", "relation": "CORRECT_SCOPE" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-012", "relation": "QUARANTINE_SCOPE_DISTORTION" } ] }, "id": "K013", "familyId": "K013", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K013", "category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "e-ink", "display quality", "Electronic reading" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Paper-like small displays support routine electronic reading.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Paper-like small displays support routine electronic reading.", "successCriteria": "Small book-sized displays provide high contrast, readable resolution, broad viewing angles and no distracting flicker; digital reading is routine.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 16, printed p. 24", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O05", "id": "O05-0", "title": "Introducing Amazon Kindle", "url": "https://press.aboutamazon.com/2007/11/introducing-amazon-kindle", "publishedAt": "2007-11-19", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Reads Like Paper section; Books, Blogs, Magazines and Newspapers section. Amazon describes a reflective electronic-paper screen and wireless access to books and periodicals in 2007. Evidence limits: The display description is a manufacturer claim, not an independent equivalence test against paper." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions. The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PARTIAL. The 2007 Kindle provided a paper-like electronic display and wireless books, newspapers and magazines. That establishes a substantial realization, but this review does not equate its 167-ppi display with every quality of paper or establish the full adoption scope. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions. The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper." }, { "date": "2026-10-18", "note": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18: 1 primary citation checks/additions. Primary citation locators, source-specific support limits and additional corroborating references; no changes to verdicts, eligibility or timing judgments." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Small book-sized displays provide high contrast, readable resolution, broad viewing angles and no distracting flicker; digital reading is routine.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions. The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2007,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O05\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Small book-sized displays provide high contrast, readable resolution, broad viewing angles and no distracting flicker; digital reading is routine.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions. The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2007,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O05\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Small book-sized displays provide high contrast, readable resolution, broad viewing angles and no distracting flicker; digital reading is routine.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions. The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2007,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O05\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2007,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2007\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTIAL\",\"at_review\":\"FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The 2007 Kindle provided a paper-like electronic display and wireless books, newspapers and magazines. That establishes a substantial realization, but this review does not equate its 167-ppi display with every quality of paper or establish the full adoption scope.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K013\",\"slug\":\"k013-paper-like-displays-and-routine-electronic-reading\",\"title\":\"Paper-like displays and routine electronic reading\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Paper-like small displays support routine electronic reading.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Interfaces & virtual worlds\",\"tags\":[\"e-ink\",\"display quality\"],\"subcategory\":\"Electronic reading\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K013\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-015\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Small book-sized displays provide high contrast, readable resolution, broad viewing angles and no distracting flicker; digital reading is routine.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Kindle’s 2007 electronic-paper display and wireless book delivery materially meet the listed visual and reading functions. The forecast did not require all books to abandon print or the screen to share every physical property of paper.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2007,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 16, printed p. 24\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O05\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-015\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_SCOPE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-012\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_SCOPE_DISTORTION\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Practical see-through head-worn displays project imagery onto the retina and are used, without a mass-adoption requirement.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009. This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2004, "at_deadline_rationale": "Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N04" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "The retinal display is built into ordinary eyeglass-form eyewear rather than a headband/industrial head-mounted unit.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The located deployment is materially similar optical technology but not the exact eyeglass form. The strict mechanical-form reading remains partial.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N04" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Practical see-through head-worn displays project imagery onto the retina and are used, without a mass-adoption requirement.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009. This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2004, "at_deadline_rationale": "Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N04" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2004, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2004", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The scope is located. Early retinal-display leads must be checked against manufacturer documentation. Neither “Google Glass appeared in 2013” nor generic VR headset availability establishes a first date or a missed 2009 deadline.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K014", "slug": "k014-see-through-glasses-with-direct-retinal-projection", "title": "See-through glasses with direct retinal projection", "prediction_paraphrase": "See-through glasses project imagery directly onto retinas.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "laser projection", "AR" ], "subcategory": "Retinal displays", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K014", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "DEC-015" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Practical see-through head-worn displays project imagery onto the retina and are used, without a mass-adoption requirement.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009. This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2004, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 17, printed p. 25", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N04", "locator": "Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "DEC-015", "relation": "RESTORE_MECHANISM" } ] }, "id": "K014", "familyId": "K014", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K014", "category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "laser projection", "AR", "Retinal displays" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "See-through glasses project imagery directly onto retinas.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "See-through glasses project imagery directly onto retinas.", "successCriteria": "Practical see-through head-worn displays project imagery onto the retina and are used, without a mass-adoption requirement.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 17, printed p. 25", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N04", "id": "N04-0", "title": "Microvision: Nomad retinal display installed at Chevrolet dealership", "url": "https://www.theautochannel.com/news/2004/08/10/208323.html", "publishedAt": "2004-08-10", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption.. Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009. This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. The scope is located. Early retinal-display leads must be checked against manufacturer documentation. Neither “Google Glass appeared in 2013” nor generic VR headset availability establishes a first date or a missed 2009 deadline. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009. This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Practical see-through head-worn displays project imagery onto the retina and are used, without a mass-adoption requirement.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009. This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2004,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N04\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"The retinal display is built into ordinary eyeglass-form eyewear rather than a headband/industrial head-mounted unit.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The located deployment is materially similar optical technology but not the exact eyeglass form. The strict mechanical-form reading remains partial.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N04\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Practical see-through head-worn displays project imagery onto the retina and are used, without a mass-adoption requirement.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009. This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2004,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N04\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2004,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2004\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The scope is located. Early retinal-display leads must be checked against manufacturer documentation. Neither “Google Glass appeared in 2013” nor generic VR headset availability establishes a first date or a missed 2009 deadline.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K014\",\"slug\":\"k014-see-through-glasses-with-direct-retinal-projection\",\"title\":\"See-through glasses with direct retinal projection\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"See-through glasses project imagery directly onto retinas.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Interfaces & virtual worlds\",\"tags\":[\"laser projection\",\"AR\"],\"subcategory\":\"Retinal displays\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K014\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"DEC-015\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Practical see-through head-worn displays project imagery onto the retina and are used, without a mass-adoption requirement.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Microvision’s Nomad retinal display was deployed in a dealership in 2004, establishing practical use before 2009. This is a capability/use success, even though the product was specialized rather than popular fashion eyewear.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2004,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 17, printed p. 25\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N04\",\"locator\":\"Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-015\",\"relation\":\"RESTORE_MECHANISM\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Both glasses and contact-lens display forms deliver the predicted retinal imagery.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard. Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard.", "at_review_rationale": "Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N04", "N05" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2010, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Both glasses and contact-lens display forms deliver the predicted retinal imagery.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard. Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard.", "at_review_rationale": "Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N04", "N05" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2010, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Head-worn retinal/near-eye displays; contact lenses are treated as an illustrative alternative.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Practical head-worn displays existed by 2004; the technology direction was right.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Contact-lens implementation" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2004, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N04", "N05" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2010, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The intake mixed 2010 and 2015. The retrospective treats “beginning of the next decade” flexibly. Neither a new exact 2015 deadline nor an automatic 2010 failure should be imported.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K015", "slug": "k015-glasses-and-contact-lens-displays-in-the-2010s", "title": "Glasses and contact-lens displays in the 2010s", "prediction_paraphrase": "Eyeglass and contact-lens displays deliver retinal imagery.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "contact lenses", "AR" ], "subcategory": "Retinal displays", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K015", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-016" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2005, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2010 in the author retrospective’s Singularity Is Near forecast grouping; wider prose says early 2010s.", "deadline_year": 2010, "precision": "EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR", "year_start": 2010, "year_end": 2010, "interpretation": "2010 in the author retrospective’s Singularity Is Near forecast grouping; wider prose says early 2010s." }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Both glasses and contact-lens display forms deliver the predicted retinal imagery.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard.", "at_review_rationale": "Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard. Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Singularity Is Near predictions for 2010, prediction 4, printed p. 131", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N04", "locator": "Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N05", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-016", "relation": "HOLD_DATE_AND_SCOPE" } ] }, "id": "K015", "familyId": "K015", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K015", "category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "contact lenses", "AR", "Retinal displays" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Eyeglass and contact-lens displays deliver retinal imagery.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Eyeglass and contact-lens displays deliver retinal imagery.", "successCriteria": "Both glasses and contact-lens display forms deliver the predicted retinal imagery.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 2005, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Singularity Is Near predictions for 2010, prediction 4, printed p. 131", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2010 in the author retrospective’s Singularity Is Near forecast grouping; wider prose says early 2010s.", "year": 2010, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N04", "id": "N04-0", "title": "Microvision: Nomad retinal display installed at Chevrolet dealership", "url": "https://www.theautochannel.com/news/2004/08/10/208323.html", "publishedAt": "2004-08-10", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption.. Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption." }, { "sourceId": "N05", "id": "N05-1", "title": "Qualcomm: Snapdragon platform powers shipping Oculus Quest", "url": "https://www.qualcomm.com/news/releases/2019/05/qualcomm-snapdragon-mobile-vr-platform-powers-oculus-quest", "publishedAt": "2019-05-20", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard. Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. The intake mixed 2010 and 2015. The retrospective treats “beginning of the next decade” flexibly. Neither a new exact 2015 deadline nor an automatic 2010 failure should be imported. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard. Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Both glasses and contact-lens display forms deliver the predicted retinal imagery.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard. Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N04\",\"N05\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2010,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Both glasses and contact-lens display forms deliver the predicted retinal imagery.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard. Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N04\",\"N05\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2010,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Head-worn retinal/near-eye displays; contact lenses are treated as an illustrative alternative.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Practical head-worn displays existed by 2004; the technology direction was right.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Contact-lens implementation\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2004,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N04\",\"N05\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2010,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The intake mixed 2010 and 2015. The retrospective treats “beginning of the next decade” flexibly. Neither a new exact 2015 deadline nor an automatic 2010 failure should be imported.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K015\",\"slug\":\"k015-glasses-and-contact-lens-displays-in-the-2010s\",\"title\":\"Glasses and contact-lens displays in the 2010s\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Eyeglass and contact-lens displays deliver retinal imagery.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Interfaces & virtual worlds\",\"tags\":[\"contact lenses\",\"AR\"],\"subcategory\":\"Retinal displays\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K015\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-016\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2005,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2010 in the author retrospective’s Singularity Is Near forecast grouping; wider prose says early 2010s.\",\"deadline_year\":2010,\"precision\":\"EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR\",\"year_start\":2010,\"year_end\":2010,\"interpretation\":\"2010 in the author retrospective’s Singularity Is Near forecast grouping; wider prose says early 2010s.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Both glasses and contact-lens display forms deliver the predicted retinal imagery.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Industrial retinal head-worn displays provided part of the capability by 2010; display contacts did not meet the same practical-use standard. Glasses/headsets remain the substantial realization, while the contact-lens half of the compound is not comparably established.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Singularity Is Near predictions for 2010, prediction 4, printed p. 131\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N04\",\"locator\":\"Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N05\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-016\",\"relation\":\"HOLD_DATE_AND_SCOPE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Small personal audio devices create a convincing spatial auditory environment.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete. Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2021, "at_deadline_rationale": "Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete.", "at_review_rationale": "Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "N57", "N06" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2010, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Tiny ultrasound/interference-based emitters physically project localized audible sound as the explanatory mechanism describes.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Spatial earbuds use conventional transducers and signal processing. They do not complete the specified physical projection mechanism.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "N57", "N06" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2010, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Small personal audio devices create a convincing spatial auditory environment.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete. Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2021, "at_deadline_rationale": "Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete.", "at_review_rationale": "Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "N57", "N06" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2010, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2021, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2021; after 2010, no later than 2021", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The earlier LRAD/bone-conduction examples were not evidence of the complete claimed device. Attribution is located but performance, form factor and deadline still need resolution.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K016", "slug": "k016-tiny-devices-project-auditory-environments", "title": "Tiny devices project auditory environments", "prediction_paraphrase": "Tiny devices project spatial auditory environments.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "auditory projection" ], "subcategory": "Spatial audio", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K016", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-017" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2005, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2010 in the retrospective’s grouped early-2010s forecasts.", "deadline_year": 2010, "precision": "EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR", "year_start": 2010, "year_end": 2010, "interpretation": "2010 in the retrospective’s grouped early-2010s forecasts." }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Small personal audio devices create a convincing spatial auditory environment.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete.", "at_review_rationale": "Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "LATE", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete. Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2021, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Singularity Is Near predictions for 2010, prediction 5, printed pp. 131–132", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N57", "locator": "Retail availability October 26, 2021; small earbuds with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio. Establishes a documented-by year, not the first such device.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N06", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Functional audio success is not a claim of ultrasound projection. 2021 is a documented-by date; no exact first commercial year is asserted.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-017", "relation": "REJECT_BAD_OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ] }, "id": "K016", "familyId": "K016", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K016", "category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "auditory projection", "Spatial audio" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Tiny devices project spatial auditory environments.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Tiny devices project spatial auditory environments.", "successCriteria": "Small personal audio devices create a convincing spatial auditory environment.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 2005, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Singularity Is Near predictions for 2010, prediction 5, printed pp. 131–132", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2010 in the retrospective’s grouped early-2010s forecasts.", "year": 2010, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P01", "id": "P01-0", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.. Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices." }, { "sourceId": "N57", "id": "N57-1", "title": "Apple: Third-generation AirPods spatial audio", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2021/10/introducing-the-next-generation-of-airpods/", "publishedAt": "2021-10-18", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Retail availability October 26, 2021; small earbuds with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio. Establishes a documented-by year, not the first such device.. Retail availability October 26, 2021; small earbuds with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio. Establishes a documented-by year, not the first such device." }, { "sourceId": "N06", "id": "N06-2", "title": "Apple: Spatial audio and head tracking on AirPods", "url": "https://support.apple.com/en-kz/guide/airpods/dev00eb7e0a3/web", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete. Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Functional audio success is not a claim of ultrasound projection. 2021 is a documented-by date; no exact first commercial year is asserted.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Functional audio success is not a claim of ultrasound projection. 2021 is a documented-by date; no exact first commercial year is asserted.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. The earlier LRAD/bone-conduction examples were not evidence of the complete claimed device. Attribution is located but performance, form factor and deadline still need resolution. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict LATE. Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete. Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Small personal audio devices create a convincing spatial auditory environment.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete. Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2021,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"N57\",\"N06\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2010,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Tiny ultrasound/interference-based emitters physically project localized audible sound as the explanatory mechanism describes.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Spatial earbuds use conventional transducers and signal processing. They do not complete the specified physical projection mechanism.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"N57\",\"N06\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2010,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Small personal audio devices create a convincing spatial auditory environment.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete. Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2021,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"N57\",\"N06\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2010,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2021,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2021; after 2010, no later than 2021\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The earlier LRAD/bone-conduction examples were not evidence of the complete claimed device. Attribution is located but performance, form factor and deadline still need resolution.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K016\",\"slug\":\"k016-tiny-devices-project-auditory-environments\",\"title\":\"Tiny devices project auditory environments\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Tiny devices project spatial auditory environments.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Interfaces & virtual worlds\",\"tags\":[\"auditory projection\"],\"subcategory\":\"Spatial audio\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K016\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-017\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2005,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2010 in the retrospective’s grouped early-2010s forecasts.\",\"deadline_year\":2010,\"precision\":\"EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR\",\"year_start\":2010,\"year_end\":2010,\"interpretation\":\"2010 in the retrospective’s grouped early-2010s forecasts.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Small personal audio devices create a convincing spatial auditory environment.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Audio spatialization and directed-sound hardware existed by 2010, but the tiny ordinary personal implementation was incomplete. Small AirPods with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio are documented by 2021. This meets the perceptual function, not the ultrasonic projection mechanism emphasized in the explanatory discussion.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2021,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Singularity Is Near predictions for 2010, prediction 5, printed pp. 131–132\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N57\",\"locator\":\"Retail availability October 26, 2021; small earbuds with dynamic head-tracked spatial audio. Establishes a documented-by year, not the first such device.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N06\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Functional audio success is not a claim of ultrasound projection. 2021 is a documented-by date; no exact first commercial year is asserted.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-017\",\"relation\":\"REJECT_BAD_OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Consumers can use immersive high-resolution visual-plus-audio VR on demand, without requiring a specialist installation.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010. The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010.", "at_review_rationale": "The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N05" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2010, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "The full experience is delivered through the forecast’s tiny glasses/contact display system at arbitrary times.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Standalone headsets fulfill the audiovisual experience but not the precise unobtrusive optical package.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N05" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2010, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Consumers can use immersive high-resolution visual-plus-audio VR on demand, without requiring a specialist installation.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010. The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010.", "at_review_rationale": "The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N05" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2010, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2019, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2019; after 2010, no later than 2019", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "An Oculus/HTC launch alone cannot settle every qualifier or an ambiguous deadline. Conversely, this audiovisual claim is not identical to the separate total-touch forecast.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K017", "slug": "k017-anytime-immersive-audiovisual-virtual-reality", "title": "Anytime immersive audiovisual virtual reality", "prediction_paraphrase": "High-resolution audiovisual virtual reality is available anytime.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "immersion" ], "subcategory": "Audiovisual VR", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K017", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-018" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2005, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2010 in the retrospective’s early-2010s grouping.", "deadline_year": 2010, "precision": "EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR", "year_start": 2010, "year_end": 2010, "interpretation": "2010 in the retrospective’s early-2010s grouping." }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Consumers can use immersive high-resolution visual-plus-audio VR on demand, without requiring a specialist installation.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010.", "at_review_rationale": "The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "LATE", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010. The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2019, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Singularity Is Near predictions for 2010, prediction 6, printed p. 132", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N05", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Spatial resolution is evaluated against usable consumer VR, not human retinal acuity, which this particular forecast does not specify.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-018", "relation": "HOLD_CRITERION" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-028", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-014", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" } ] }, "id": "K017", "familyId": "K017", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K017", "category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "immersion", "Audiovisual VR" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "High-resolution audiovisual virtual reality is available anytime.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "High-resolution audiovisual virtual reality is available anytime.", "successCriteria": "Consumers can use immersive high-resolution visual-plus-audio VR on demand, without requiring a specialist installation.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 2005, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Singularity Is Near predictions for 2010, prediction 6, printed p. 132", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2010 in the retrospective’s early-2010s grouping.", "year": 2010, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N05", "id": "N05-0", "title": "Qualcomm: Snapdragon platform powers shipping Oculus Quest", "url": "https://www.qualcomm.com/news/releases/2019/05/qualcomm-snapdragon-mobile-vr-platform-powers-oculus-quest", "publishedAt": "2019-05-20", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010. The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Spatial resolution is evaluated against usable consumer VR, not human retinal acuity, which this particular forecast does not specify.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Spatial resolution is evaluated against usable consumer VR, not human retinal acuity, which this particular forecast does not specify.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. An Oculus/HTC launch alone cannot settle every qualifier or an ambiguous deadline. Conversely, this audiovisual claim is not identical to the separate total-touch forecast. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict LATE. Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010. The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Consumers can use immersive high-resolution visual-plus-audio VR on demand, without requiring a specialist installation.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010. The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N05\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2010,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"The full experience is delivered through the forecast’s tiny glasses/contact display system at arbitrary times.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Standalone headsets fulfill the audiovisual experience but not the precise unobtrusive optical package.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N05\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2010,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Consumers can use immersive high-resolution visual-plus-audio VR on demand, without requiring a specialist installation.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010. The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N05\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2010,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2019; after 2010, no later than 2019\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"An Oculus/HTC launch alone cannot settle every qualifier or an ambiguous deadline. Conversely, this audiovisual claim is not identical to the separate total-touch forecast.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K017\",\"slug\":\"k017-anytime-immersive-audiovisual-virtual-reality\",\"title\":\"Anytime immersive audiovisual virtual reality\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"High-resolution audiovisual virtual reality is available anytime.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Interfaces & virtual worlds\",\"tags\":[\"immersion\"],\"subcategory\":\"Audiovisual VR\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K017\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-018\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2005,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2010 in the retrospective’s early-2010s grouping.\",\"deadline_year\":2010,\"precision\":\"EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR\",\"year_start\":2010,\"year_end\":2010,\"interpretation\":\"2010 in the retrospective’s early-2010s grouping.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Consumers can use immersive high-resolution visual-plus-audio VR on demand, without requiring a specialist installation.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Earlier VR systems existed, but ordinary portable on-demand immersive access was limited in 2010. The standalone Quest shipped in 2019 with tracked immersive visual/audio use. “Immersive” is not silently strengthened to indistinguishable reality or all senses.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2019,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Singularity Is Near predictions for 2010, prediction 6, printed p. 132\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N05\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Spatial resolution is evaluated against usable consumer VR, not human retinal acuity, which this particular forecast does not specify.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-018\",\"relation\":\"HOLD_CRITERION\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-028\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-014\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Digital instructions or information overlay the user’s view of the physical world.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010. The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2004, "at_deadline_rationale": "Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010.", "at_review_rationale": "The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N04" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2010, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Digital instructions or information overlay the user’s view of the physical world.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010. The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2004, "at_deadline_rationale": "Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010.", "at_review_rationale": "The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N04" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2010, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Digital instructions or information overlay the user’s view of the physical world.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010. The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2004, "at_deadline_rationale": "Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010.", "at_review_rationale": "The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N04" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2010, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2004, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2004", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The original scope does not justify treating Pokémon Go in 2016 as the first realization. Earlier AR systems require primary-source checking before assigning a date.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K018", "slug": "k018-augmented-reality-overlays", "title": "Augmented-reality overlays", "prediction_paraphrase": "Digital displays overlay guidance on the real world.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "visual overlays" ], "subcategory": "Augmented reality", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K018", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-019" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2005, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2010 in the author retrospective’s early-2010s grouping.", "deadline_year": 2010, "precision": "EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR", "year_start": 2010, "year_end": 2010, "interpretation": "2010 in the author retrospective’s early-2010s grouping." }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Digital instructions or information overlay the user’s view of the physical world.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010.", "at_review_rationale": "The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010. The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2004, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Singularity Is Near predictions for 2010, prediction 7, printed p. 132", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N04", "locator": "Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-019", "relation": "HOLD_FIRST_DATE" } ] }, "id": "K018", "familyId": "K018", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K018", "category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "visual overlays", "Augmented reality" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Digital displays overlay guidance on the real world.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Digital displays overlay guidance on the real world.", "successCriteria": "Digital instructions or information overlay the user’s view of the physical world.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 2005, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Singularity Is Near predictions for 2010, prediction 7, printed p. 132", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2010 in the author retrospective’s early-2010s grouping.", "year": 2010, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N04", "id": "N04-0", "title": "Microvision: Nomad retinal display installed at Chevrolet dealership", "url": "https://www.theautochannel.com/news/2004/08/10/208323.html", "publishedAt": "2004-08-10", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption.. Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010. The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. The original scope does not justify treating Pokémon Go in 2016 as the first realization. Earlier AR systems require primary-source checking before assigning a date. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010. The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Digital instructions or information overlay the user’s view of the physical world.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010. The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2004,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N04\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2010,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Digital instructions or information overlay the user’s view of the physical world.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010. The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2004,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N04\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2010,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Digital instructions or information overlay the user’s view of the physical world.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010. The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2004,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N04\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2010,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2004,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2004\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The original scope does not justify treating Pokémon Go in 2016 as the first realization. Earlier AR systems require primary-source checking before assigning a date.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K018\",\"slug\":\"k018-augmented-reality-overlays\",\"title\":\"Augmented-reality overlays\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Digital displays overlay guidance on the real world.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Interfaces & virtual worlds\",\"tags\":[\"visual overlays\"],\"subcategory\":\"Augmented reality\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K018\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-019\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2005,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2010 in the author retrospective’s early-2010s grouping.\",\"deadline_year\":2010,\"precision\":\"EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR\",\"year_start\":2010,\"year_end\":2010,\"interpretation\":\"2010 in the author retrospective’s early-2010s grouping.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Digital instructions or information overlay the user’s view of the physical world.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Nomad’s deployed see-through repair guidance already provided the functional overlay before 2010. The availability claim is met; we do not require everyone to wear AR glasses.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2004,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Singularity Is Near predictions for 2010, prediction 7, printed p. 132\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N04\",\"locator\":\"Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-019\",\"relation\":\"HOLD_FIRST_DATE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Warfare generally places human participants far from the physical fighting, not merely some pilots.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim. Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim.", "at_review_rationale": "Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O13", "N08" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Warfare generally places human participants far from the physical fighting, not merely some pilots.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim. Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim.", "at_review_rationale": "Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O13", "N08" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Remote systems allow a significant subset of combat missions to be conducted away from immediate danger.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Remote aviation and strike operations realize the narrower direction, not general human absence.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "General scope of human removal" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2025, "evidence_source_ids": [ "O13", "N08" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "WRONG_MISSED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The December 2009 US Afghanistan address describes ongoing human fighting and plans for a further 30,000 troops. That contemporaneous record is incompatible with using remote-weapon availability as proof that humans were generally removed from battle.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K019", "slug": "k019-people-largely-removed-from-the-battlefield", "title": "People largely removed from the battlefield", "prediction_paraphrase": "Humans are generally far from the battle scene.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Security & warfare", "tags": [ "human combatants", "adoption" ], "subcategory": "Remote warfare", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K019", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-020" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Warfare generally places human participants far from the physical fighting, not merely some pilots.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim.", "at_review_rationale": "Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim. Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "Warfare, prediction 2, printed p. 103", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O13", "locator": "Describes active human fighting and plans for 30,000 additional US troops in Afghanistan in early 2010. Do not date those additional deployments to 2009.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N08", "locator": "2025 civilian casualties and ongoing front-line fighting; not a global measure of military drone share.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-020", "relation": "CORRECT_SCOPE" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-006", "relation": "QUARANTINE_AND_SPLIT_REQUIRED" } ] }, "id": "K019", "familyId": "K019", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K019", "category": "Security & warfare", "tags": [ "human combatants", "adoption", "Remote warfare" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Humans are generally far from the battle scene.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Humans are generally far from the battle scene.", "successCriteria": "Warfare generally places human participants far from the physical fighting, not merely some pilots.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "Warfare, prediction 2, printed p. 103", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O13", "id": "O13-0", "title": "Excerpts of the President’s address to the nation", "url": "https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/excerpts-presidents-address-nation", "publishedAt": "2009-12-01", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Describes active human fighting and plans for 30,000 additional US troops in Afghanistan in early 2010. Do not date those additional deployments to 2009.. Describes active human fighting and plans for 30,000 additional US troops in Afghanistan in early 2010. Do not date those additional deployments to 2009." }, { "sourceId": "N08", "id": "N08-1", "title": "UN human-rights monitors: 2025 deadliest civilian year in Ukraine since 2022", "url": "https://ukraine.ohchr.org/en/2025-deadliest-year-for-civilians-in-Ukraine-since-2022-UN-human-rights-monitors-find", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "2025 civilian casualties and ongoing front-line fighting; not a global measure of military drone share.. 2025 civilian casualties and ongoing front-line fighting; not a global measure of military drone share." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim. Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: WRONG_MISSED. The December 2009 US Afghanistan address describes ongoing human fighting and plans for a further 30,000 troops. That contemporaneous record is incompatible with using remote-weapon availability as proof that humans were generally removed from battle. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim. Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Warfare generally places human participants far from the physical fighting, not merely some pilots.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim. Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O13\",\"N08\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Warfare generally places human participants far from the physical fighting, not merely some pilots.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim. Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O13\",\"N08\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Remote systems allow a significant subset of combat missions to be conducted away from immediate danger.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Remote aviation and strike operations realize the narrower direction, not general human absence.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"General scope of human removal\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2025,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O13\",\"N08\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG_MISSED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The December 2009 US Afghanistan address describes ongoing human fighting and plans for a further 30,000 troops. That contemporaneous record is incompatible with using remote-weapon availability as proof that humans were generally removed from battle.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K019\",\"slug\":\"k019-people-largely-removed-from-the-battlefield\",\"title\":\"People largely removed from the battlefield\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Humans are generally far from the battle scene.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Security & warfare\",\"tags\":[\"human combatants\",\"adoption\"],\"subcategory\":\"Remote warfare\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K019\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-020\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Warfare generally places human participants far from the physical fighting, not merely some pilots.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Large troop deployments and ground combat in 2009 contradict the general-removal claim. Ongoing front-line fighting and 2025 casualties in Ukraine contradict general removal today. Drones reduce some exposure without removing humans from war.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"Warfare, prediction 2, printed p. 103\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O13\",\"locator\":\"Describes active human fighting and plans for 30,000 additional US troops in Afghanistan in early 2010. Do not date those additional deployments to 2009.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N08\",\"locator\":\"2025 civilian casualties and ongoing front-line fighting; not a global measure of military drone share.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-020\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_SCOPE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-006\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_AND_SPLIT_REQUIRED\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Unmanned intelligent aircraft are the dominant mode of warfare rather than an important additional weapon.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced. They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced.", "at_review_rationale": "They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O13", "N08" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Unmanned intelligent aircraft are the dominant mode of warfare rather than an important additional weapon.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced. They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced.", "at_review_rationale": "They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O13", "N08" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Drones become a major or leading operational weapon in important conflicts.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "This is well established in modern combat, but it relaxes worldwide warfare dominance.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Dominance across warfare rather than selected theaters" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2025, "evidence_source_ids": [ "O13", "N08" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "UNSCORABLE", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "Drones existed, but existence is not dominance. No denominator or consistent measure is specified. The earlier favorable assessment selected examples without establishing the general claim.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K020", "slug": "k020-unmanned-aircraft-dominate-warfare", "title": "Unmanned aircraft dominate warfare", "prediction_paraphrase": "Unmanned intelligent aircraft dominate warfare.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Security & warfare", "tags": [ "dominance", "adoption" ], "subcategory": "Military drones", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K020", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-021" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Unmanned intelligent aircraft are the dominant mode of warfare rather than an important additional weapon.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced.", "at_review_rationale": "They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced. They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "Warfare, prediction 3, printed p. 103", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O13", "locator": "Describes active human fighting and plans for 30,000 additional US troops in Afghanistan in early 2010. Do not date those additional deployments to 2009.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N08", "locator": "2025 civilian casualties and ongoing front-line fighting; not a global measure of military drone share.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Civilian casualty shares are not used as a precise military weapons-share metric. Current assessment is qualitative across conflict types.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-021", "relation": "RESTORE_THRESHOLD" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-006", "relation": "QUARANTINE_AND_SPLIT_REQUIRED" } ] }, "id": "K020", "familyId": "K020", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K020", "category": "Security & warfare", "tags": [ "dominance", "adoption", "Military drones" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Unmanned intelligent aircraft dominate warfare.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Unmanned intelligent aircraft dominate warfare.", "successCriteria": "Unmanned intelligent aircraft are the dominant mode of warfare rather than an important additional weapon.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "Warfare, prediction 3, printed p. 103", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O13", "id": "O13-0", "title": "Excerpts of the President’s address to the nation", "url": "https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/excerpts-presidents-address-nation", "publishedAt": "2009-12-01", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Describes active human fighting and plans for 30,000 additional US troops in Afghanistan in early 2010. Do not date those additional deployments to 2009.. Describes active human fighting and plans for 30,000 additional US troops in Afghanistan in early 2010. Do not date those additional deployments to 2009." }, { "sourceId": "N08", "id": "N08-1", "title": "UN human-rights monitors: 2025 deadliest civilian year in Ukraine since 2022", "url": "https://ukraine.ohchr.org/en/2025-deadliest-year-for-civilians-in-Ukraine-since-2022-UN-human-rights-monitors-find", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "2025 civilian casualties and ongoing front-line fighting; not a global measure of military drone share.. 2025 civilian casualties and ongoing front-line fighting; not a global measure of military drone share." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced. They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Civilian casualty shares are not used as a precise military weapons-share metric. Current assessment is qualitative across conflict types.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Civilian casualty shares are not used as a precise military weapons-share metric. Current assessment is qualitative across conflict types.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNSCORABLE. Drones existed, but existence is not dominance. No denominator or consistent measure is specified. The earlier favorable assessment selected examples without establishing the general claim. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced. They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Unmanned intelligent aircraft are the dominant mode of warfare rather than an important additional weapon.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced. They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O13\",\"N08\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Unmanned intelligent aircraft are the dominant mode of warfare rather than an important additional weapon.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced. They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O13\",\"N08\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Drones become a major or leading operational weapon in important conflicts.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"This is well established in modern combat, but it relaxes worldwide warfare dominance.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Dominance across warfare rather than selected theaters\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2025,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O13\",\"N08\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"UNSCORABLE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"Drones existed, but existence is not dominance. No denominator or consistent measure is specified. The earlier favorable assessment selected examples without establishing the general claim.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K020\",\"slug\":\"k020-unmanned-aircraft-dominate-warfare\",\"title\":\"Unmanned aircraft dominate warfare\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Unmanned intelligent aircraft dominate warfare.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Security & warfare\",\"tags\":[\"dominance\",\"adoption\"],\"subcategory\":\"Military drones\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K020\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-021\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Unmanned intelligent aircraft are the dominant mode of warfare rather than an important additional weapon.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Drones were important in 2009, but conventional ground and air warfare were not displaced. They are now central in particular theaters, especially Ukraine. The worldwide, cross-domain dominance claim remains only partly fulfilled.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"Warfare, prediction 3, printed p. 103\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O13\",\"locator\":\"Describes active human fighting and plans for 30,000 additional US troops in Afghanistan in early 2010. Do not date those additional deployments to 2009.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N08\",\"locator\":\"2025 civilian casualties and ongoing front-line fighting; not a global measure of military drone share.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Civilian casualty shares are not used as a precise military weapons-share metric. Current assessment is qualitative across conflict types.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-021\",\"relation\":\"RESTORE_THRESHOLD\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-006\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_AND_SPLIT_REQUIRED\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Solar energy actually supplies global energy demand, not merely enough theoretical sunshine or nameplate power.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2028 deadline remains in the future. IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2028 deadline remains in the future.", "at_review_rationale": "IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N59" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2028, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Solar energy actually supplies global energy demand, not merely enough theoretical sunshine or nameplate power.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2028 deadline remains in the future. IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2028 deadline remains in the future.", "at_review_rationale": "IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N59" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2028, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Solar energy actually supplies global energy demand, not merely enough theoretical sunshine or nameplate power.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2028 deadline remains in the future. IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2028 deadline remains in the future.", "at_review_rationale": "IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N59" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2028, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The deadline is still ahead. Falling solar costs or more installed capacity are progress indicators, not full fulfillment.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K021", "slug": "k021-solar-meets-worldwide-energy-demand", "title": "Solar meets worldwide energy demand", "prediction_paraphrase": "Solar supplies all global energy.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Energy & environment", "tags": [ "energy supply" ], "subcategory": "Solar deployment", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K021", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-022" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2008, "year_basis": "SOURCE_PUBLICATION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "REPORTED_EVENT_YEAR" }, "target": { "text": "2028", "deadline_year": 2028, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2028, "year_end": 2028, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "REPORTED_ATTRIBUTION_ORIGINAL_TRANSCRIPT_NOT_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": false }, "success_criteria": "Solar energy actually supplies global energy demand, not merely enough theoretical sunshine or nameplate power.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2028 deadline remains in the future.", "at_review_rationale": "IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The 2028 deadline remains in the future. IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P07", "locator": "Archived report of February 2008 remarks", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N59", "locator": "2025 solar PV generation nearly 2,700 TWh, over 8% of electricity. Growth contribution does not mean share of all energy.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Keep energy versus electricity, delivered output versus capacity, and growth contribution versus total share separate.", "open_questions": [], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-022", "relation": "CANONICALIZE_REPORTED_ATTRIBUTION" } ] }, "id": "K021", "familyId": "K021", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K021", "category": "Energy & environment", "tags": [ "energy supply", "Solar deployment" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Solar supplies all global energy.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Solar supplies all global energy.", "successCriteria": "Solar energy actually supplies global energy demand, not merely enough theoretical sunshine or nameplate power.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P07", "title": "Solar power to rule in 20 years, futurists say", "publicationYear": 2008, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.pressandappearances.com/solar-power-to-rule-in-20-years-futurists-say-2", "locator": "Archived report of February 2008 remarks", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2028", "year": 2028, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N59", "id": "N59-0", "title": "IEA: Global Energy Review 2026, global trends", "url": "https://www.iea.org/reports/global-energy-review-2026/global-trends", "publishedAt": "2026-04-20", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "2025 solar PV generation nearly 2,700 TWh, over 8% of electricity. Growth contribution does not mean share of all energy.. 2025 solar PV generation nearly 2,700 TWh, over 8% of electricity. Growth contribution does not mean share of all energy." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The 2028 deadline remains in the future. IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "Keep energy versus electricity, delivered output versus capacity, and growth contribution versus total share separate.", "unresolvedQuestions": [], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. The deadline is still ahead. Falling solar costs or more installed capacity are progress indicators, not full fulfillment. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. The 2028 deadline remains in the future. IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Solar energy actually supplies global energy demand, not merely enough theoretical sunshine or nameplate power.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2028 deadline remains in the future. IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2028 deadline remains in the future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N59\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2028,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Solar energy actually supplies global energy demand, not merely enough theoretical sunshine or nameplate power.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2028 deadline remains in the future. IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2028 deadline remains in the future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N59\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2028,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Solar energy actually supplies global energy demand, not merely enough theoretical sunshine or nameplate power.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2028 deadline remains in the future. IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2028 deadline remains in the future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N59\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2028,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The deadline is still ahead. Falling solar costs or more installed capacity are progress indicators, not full fulfillment.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K021\",\"slug\":\"k021-solar-meets-worldwide-energy-demand\",\"title\":\"Solar meets worldwide energy demand\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Solar supplies all global energy.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Energy & environment\",\"tags\":[\"energy supply\"],\"subcategory\":\"Solar deployment\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K021\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-022\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2008,\"year_basis\":\"SOURCE_PUBLICATION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"REPORTED_EVENT_YEAR\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2028\",\"deadline_year\":2028,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2028,\"year_end\":2028,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"REPORTED_ATTRIBUTION_ORIGINAL_TRANSCRIPT_NOT_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":false},\"success_criteria\":\"Solar energy actually supplies global energy demand, not merely enough theoretical sunshine or nameplate power.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2028 deadline remains in the future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The 2028 deadline remains in the future. IEA reports solar supplied over 8% of global electricity in 2025—substantial growth, but electricity is only part of energy and far from all energy.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P07\",\"locator\":\"Archived report of February 2008 remarks\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N59\",\"locator\":\"2025 solar PV generation nearly 2,700 TWh, over 8% of electricity. Growth contribution does not mean share of all energy.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Keep energy versus electricity, delivered output versus capacity, and growth contribution versus total share separate.\",\"open_questions\":[],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-022\",\"relation\":\"CANONICALIZE_REPORTED_ATTRIBUTION\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Nonbiological intelligence and human-machine integration reach the extraordinary scale asserted for the 2045 singularity.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2045 forecast is not yet due. AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2045 forecast is not yet due.", "at_review_rationale": "AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O21", "P04" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2045, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Nonbiological intelligence and human-machine integration reach the extraordinary scale asserted for the 2045 singularity.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2045 forecast is not yet due. AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2045 forecast is not yet due.", "at_review_rationale": "AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O21", "P04" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2045, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Nonbiological intelligence and human-machine integration reach the extraordinary scale asserted for the 2045 singularity.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2045 forecast is not yet due. AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2045 forecast is not yet due.", "at_review_rationale": "AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O21", "P04" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2045, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The dated proposition is attributable, but there is no agreed operational intelligence unit. The future label does not assert that the prediction is on track.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K022", "slug": "k022-the-singularity-and-billionfold-intelligence-expansion", "title": "The Singularity and billionfold intelligence expansion", "prediction_paraphrase": "Nonbiological intelligence vastly exceeds humanity’s combined intelligence.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "intelligence measurement" ], "subcategory": "Singularity", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K022", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-023", "EXE-028" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2005, "year_basis": "DATED_DIALOGUE_IN_LATER_REPOST", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2045", "deadline_year": 2045, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2045, "year_end": 2045, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Nonbiological intelligence and human-machine integration reach the extraordinary scale asserted for the 2045 singularity.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2045 forecast is not yet due.", "at_review_rationale": "AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The 2045 forecast is not yet due. AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P04", "locator": "Question 3", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O21", "locator": "Five-minute experimental protocol. GPT-4.5 with a humanlike persona was judged human in 73% of the reported comparisons. Not the two-hour Long Bets protocol.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "P04", "locator": "Page identifies the dialogue as 2005. Store dialogue year 2005 separately from archive publication date 2011. Not a checked scan of the 2005 book.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "The label is forward-looking and partly conceptual. Current partial progress does not settle the future aggregate threshold.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-023", "relation": "CORRECT_AND_LINK_VERSION" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-028", "relation": "CORRECT_AND_LINK_VERSION" } ] }, "id": "K022", "familyId": "K022", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K022", "category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "intelligence measurement", "Singularity" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Nonbiological intelligence vastly exceeds humanity’s combined intelligence.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Nonbiological intelligence vastly exceeds humanity’s combined intelligence.", "successCriteria": "Nonbiological intelligence and human-machine integration reach the extraordinary scale asserted for the 2045 singularity.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P04", "title": "So what is the singularity? — Ray Kurzweil Q&A", "publicationYear": 2005, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.writingsbyraykurzweil.com/so-what-is-the-singularity", "locator": "Question 3", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2045", "year": 2045, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O21", "id": "O21-0", "title": "Large Language Models Pass the Turing Test — Jones and Bergen", "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.23674", "publishedAt": "2025-03-31", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Five-minute experimental protocol. GPT-4.5 with a humanlike persona was judged human in 73% of the reported comparisons. Not the two-hour Long Bets protocol.. Five-minute experimental protocol. GPT-4.5 with a humanlike persona was judged human in 73% of the reported comparisons. Not the two-hour Long Bets protocol." }, { "sourceId": "P04", "id": "P04-1", "title": "So what is the singularity? — Ray Kurzweil Q&A", "url": "https://www.writingsbyraykurzweil.com/so-what-is-the-singularity", "publishedAt": "2011-01-01", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Page identifies the dialogue as 2005. Store dialogue year 2005 separately from archive publication date 2011. Not a checked scan of the 2005 book.. Page identifies the dialogue as 2005. Store dialogue year 2005 separately from archive publication date 2011. Not a checked scan of the 2005 book." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The 2045 forecast is not yet due. AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "The label is forward-looking and partly conceptual. Current partial progress does not settle the future aggregate threshold.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. The dated proposition is attributable, but there is no agreed operational intelligence unit. The future label does not assert that the prediction is on track. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. The 2045 forecast is not yet due. AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Nonbiological intelligence and human-machine integration reach the extraordinary scale asserted for the 2045 singularity.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2045 forecast is not yet due. AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2045 forecast is not yet due.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O21\",\"P04\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2045,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Nonbiological intelligence and human-machine integration reach the extraordinary scale asserted for the 2045 singularity.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2045 forecast is not yet due. AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2045 forecast is not yet due.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O21\",\"P04\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2045,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Nonbiological intelligence and human-machine integration reach the extraordinary scale asserted for the 2045 singularity.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2045 forecast is not yet due. AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2045 forecast is not yet due.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O21\",\"P04\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2045,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The dated proposition is attributable, but there is no agreed operational intelligence unit. The future label does not assert that the prediction is on track.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K022\",\"slug\":\"k022-the-singularity-and-billionfold-intelligence-expansion\",\"title\":\"The Singularity and billionfold intelligence expansion\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Nonbiological intelligence vastly exceeds humanity’s combined intelligence.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"AI & software\",\"tags\":[\"intelligence measurement\"],\"subcategory\":\"Singularity\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K022\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-023\",\"EXE-028\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2005,\"year_basis\":\"DATED_DIALOGUE_IN_LATER_REPOST\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2045\",\"deadline_year\":2045,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2045,\"year_end\":2045,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Nonbiological intelligence and human-machine integration reach the extraordinary scale asserted for the 2045 singularity.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2045 forecast is not yet due.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The 2045 forecast is not yet due. AI capabilities are substantial, but there is no established measurement showing fulfillment of the entire singularity claim.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P04\",\"locator\":\"Question 3\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O21\",\"locator\":\"Five-minute experimental protocol. GPT-4.5 with a humanlike persona was judged human in 73% of the reported comparisons. Not the two-hour Long Bets protocol.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"P04\",\"locator\":\"Page identifies the dialogue as 2005. Store dialogue year 2005 separately from archive publication date 2011. Not a checked scan of the 2005 book.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"The label is forward-looking and partly conceptual. Current partial progress does not settle the future aggregate threshold.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-023\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_AND_LINK_VERSION\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-028\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_AND_LINK_VERSION\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "A machine passes the specific two-hour, multi-judge protocol in the Kurzweil–Kapor wager.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead. The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead.", "at_review_rationale": "The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P03", "O21" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "A machine passes the specific two-hour, multi-judge protocol in the Kurzweil–Kapor wager.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead. The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead.", "at_review_rationale": "The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P03", "O21" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "A machine is judged human in a controlled short conversational imitation test.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2025 study supports this relaxed test. It does not settle the contract.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Two-hour interviews and contractual judging conditions" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2025, "evidence_source_ids": [ "P03", "O21" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The 2025 Jones/Bergen experiment used five-minute conversations. It is important evidence about conversational imitation but does not by itself settle this different contract.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K023", "slug": "k023-the-specific-kurzweil-kapor-turing-test-wager", "title": "The specific Kurzweil–Kapor Turing-test wager", "prediction_paraphrase": "A machine satisfies the agreed Long Bets Turing protocol.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "contract", "benchmark" ], "subcategory": "Turing test", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "F-TURING", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "ADDED_PRIMARY_SOURCE", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2002, "year_basis": "SOURCE_PUBLICATION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2029", "deadline_year": 2029, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2029, "year_end": 2029, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": false }, "success_criteria": "A machine passes the specific two-hour, multi-judge protocol in the Kurzweil–Kapor wager.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead.", "at_review_rationale": "The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead. The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P03", "locator": "Agreement and detailed Turing-test rules", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P03", "locator": "Kapor takes the NO side; Kurzweil takes the opposing side. Detailed test conditions belong to this contract, not to every generic use of “Turing test.”", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O21", "locator": "Five-minute experimental protocol. GPT-4.5 with a humanlike persona was judged human in 73% of the reported comparisons. Not the two-hour Long Bets protocol.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-024", "relation": "LINK_FAMILY_NOT_EXACT_DUPLICATE" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-027", "relation": "LINK_FAMILY_NOT_EXACT_DUPLICATE" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-020", "relation": "LINK_FAMILY_NOT_EXACT_DUPLICATE" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-011", "relation": "QUARANTINE_AND_SPLIT_REQUIRED" } ] }, "id": "K023", "familyId": "F-TURING", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K023", "category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "contract", "benchmark", "Turing test" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "A machine satisfies the agreed Long Bets Turing protocol.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "A machine satisfies the agreed Long Bets Turing protocol.", "successCriteria": "A machine passes the specific two-hour, multi-judge protocol in the Kurzweil–Kapor wager.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P03", "title": "Long Bets #1 — Kapor/Kurzweil Turing-test agreement", "publicationYear": 2002, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://longbets.org/1/", "locator": "Agreement and detailed Turing-test rules", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2029", "year": 2029, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P03", "id": "P03-0", "title": "Long Bets #1 — Kapor/Kurzweil Turing-test agreement", "url": "https://longbets.org/1/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Kapor takes the NO side; Kurzweil takes the opposing side. Detailed test conditions belong to this contract, not to every generic use of “Turing test.”. Kapor takes the NO side; Kurzweil takes the opposing side. Detailed test conditions belong to this contract, not to every generic use of “Turing test.”" }, { "sourceId": "O21", "id": "O21-1", "title": "Large Language Models Pass the Turing Test — Jones and Bergen", "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.23674", "publishedAt": "2025-03-31", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Five-minute experimental protocol. GPT-4.5 with a humanlike persona was judged human in 73% of the reported comparisons. Not the two-hour Long Bets protocol.. Five-minute experimental protocol. GPT-4.5 with a humanlike persona was judged human in 73% of the reported comparisons. Not the two-hour Long Bets protocol." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": true, "rationale": "The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead. The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. The 2025 Jones/Bergen experiment used five-minute conversations. It is important evidence about conversational imitation but does not by itself settle this different contract. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead. The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"A machine passes the specific two-hour, multi-judge protocol in the Kurzweil–Kapor wager.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead. The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P03\",\"O21\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"A machine passes the specific two-hour, multi-judge protocol in the Kurzweil–Kapor wager.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead. The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P03\",\"O21\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"A machine is judged human in a controlled short conversational imitation test.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2025 study supports this relaxed test. It does not settle the contract.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Two-hour interviews and contractual judging conditions\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2025,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P03\",\"O21\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The 2025 Jones/Bergen experiment used five-minute conversations. It is important evidence about conversational imitation but does not by itself settle this different contract.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K023\",\"slug\":\"k023-the-specific-kurzweil-kapor-turing-test-wager\",\"title\":\"The specific Kurzweil–Kapor Turing-test wager\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"A machine satisfies the agreed Long Bets Turing protocol.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"AI & software\",\"tags\":[\"contract\",\"benchmark\"],\"subcategory\":\"Turing test\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"F-TURING\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"ADDED_PRIMARY_SOURCE\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2002,\"year_basis\":\"SOURCE_PUBLICATION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2029\",\"deadline_year\":2029,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2029,\"year_end\":2029,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":false},\"success_criteria\":\"A machine passes the specific two-hour, multi-judge protocol in the Kurzweil–Kapor wager.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The 2029 wager deadline is still ahead. The located evidence does not document a completed pass under that contract. Five-minute conversational studies are a different protocol.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P03\",\"locator\":\"Agreement and detailed Turing-test rules\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P03\",\"locator\":\"Kapor takes the NO side; Kurzweil takes the opposing side. Detailed test conditions belong to this contract, not to every generic use of “Turing test.”\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O21\",\"locator\":\"Five-minute experimental protocol. GPT-4.5 with a humanlike persona was judged human in 73% of the reported comparisons. Not the two-hour Long Bets protocol.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-024\",\"relation\":\"LINK_FAMILY_NOT_EXACT_DUPLICATE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-027\",\"relation\":\"LINK_FAMILY_NOT_EXACT_DUPLICATE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-020\",\"relation\":\"LINK_FAMILY_NOT_EXACT_DUPLICATE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-011\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_AND_SPLIT_REQUIRED\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Deployed in-body nanorobots scout the bloodstream and carry out limited repair, beyond passive drug nanoparticles.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending. Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending.", "at_review_rationale": "Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N29" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Deployed in-body nanorobots scout the bloodstream and carry out limited repair, beyond passive drug nanoparticles.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending. Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending.", "at_review_rationale": "Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N29" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Deployed in-body nanorobots scout the bloodstream and carry out limited repair, beyond passive drug nanoparticles.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending. Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending.", "at_review_rationale": "Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N29" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "This checked article places the claim in 2029. The unlocated 2019 versions in the intake remain unresolved separately; this later version must not erase a genuinely earlier forecast should it be found.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K024", "slug": "k024-bloodstream-nanobots-for-scouting-and-limited-repair", "title": "Bloodstream nanobots for scouting and limited repair", "prediction_paraphrase": "Bloodstream nanobots perform scouting and limited repairs.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Biology & medicine", "tags": [ "nanorobots", "clinical deployment" ], "subcategory": "Nanomedicine", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "F-NANOBOTS", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "CONFIRMED_RELATED_VERSION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2029", "deadline_year": 2029, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2029, "year_end": 2029, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Deployed in-body nanorobots scout the bloodstream and carry out limited repair, beyond passive drug nanoparticles.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending.", "at_review_rationale": "Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending. Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Health care in 2029", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N29", "locator": "Clinical translation, safety and manufacturing challenges; nanoparticles are not autonomous bloodstream repair robots.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "The disputed 2019 legacy attribution is not silently changed into this 2029 claim; its reconciliation history remains available.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-025", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-015", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-024", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" } ] }, "id": "K024", "familyId": "F-NANOBOTS", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K024", "category": "Biology & medicine", "tags": [ "nanorobots", "clinical deployment", "Nanomedicine" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Bloodstream nanobots perform scouting and limited repairs.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Bloodstream nanobots perform scouting and limited repairs.", "successCriteria": "Deployed in-body nanorobots scout the bloodstream and carry out limited repair, beyond passive drug nanoparticles.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Health care in 2029", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2029", "year": 2029, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N29", "id": "N29-0", "title": "Medical microrobots: clinical translation review", "url": "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/smb2.70030", "publishedAt": "2026-03-07", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Clinical translation, safety and manufacturing challenges; nanoparticles are not autonomous bloodstream repair robots.. Clinical translation, safety and manufacturing challenges; nanoparticles are not autonomous bloodstream repair robots." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending. Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "The disputed 2019 legacy attribution is not silently changed into this 2029 claim; its reconciliation history remains available.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. This checked article places the claim in 2029. The unlocated 2019 versions in the intake remain unresolved separately; this later version must not erase a genuinely earlier forecast should it be found. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending. Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Deployed in-body nanorobots scout the bloodstream and carry out limited repair, beyond passive drug nanoparticles.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending. Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N29\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Deployed in-body nanorobots scout the bloodstream and carry out limited repair, beyond passive drug nanoparticles.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending. Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N29\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Deployed in-body nanorobots scout the bloodstream and carry out limited repair, beyond passive drug nanoparticles.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending. Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N29\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"This checked article places the claim in 2029. The unlocated 2019 versions in the intake remain unresolved separately; this later version must not erase a genuinely earlier forecast should it be found.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K024\",\"slug\":\"k024-bloodstream-nanobots-for-scouting-and-limited-repair\",\"title\":\"Bloodstream nanobots for scouting and limited repair\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Bloodstream nanobots perform scouting and limited repairs.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Biology & medicine\",\"tags\":[\"nanorobots\",\"clinical deployment\"],\"subcategory\":\"Nanomedicine\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"F-NANOBOTS\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"CONFIRMED_RELATED_VERSION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2029\",\"deadline_year\":2029,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2029,\"year_end\":2029,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Deployed in-body nanorobots scout the bloodstream and carry out limited repair, beyond passive drug nanoparticles.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The verified adaptation puts this version in 2029, so it is pending. Medical microrobotics has genuine experimental progress but clinical translation and in-body autonomy remain material gaps.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Health care in 2029\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N29\",\"locator\":\"Clinical translation, safety and manufacturing challenges; nanoparticles are not autonomous bloodstream repair robots.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"The disputed 2019 legacy attribution is not silently changed into this 2029 claim; its reconciliation history remains available.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-025\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-015\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-024\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "About $1,000 purchases the forecast’s roughly 10^16 calculations/second brain-hardware budget, using an explicit arithmetic proxy.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC. The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC.", "at_review_rationale": "The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P04", "N09", "N10", "N11" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2020, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "About $1,000 purchases the forecast’s roughly 10^16 calculations/second brain-hardware budget, using an explicit arithmetic proxy.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC. The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC.", "at_review_rationale": "The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P04", "N09", "N10", "N11" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2020, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "A $1,000-class machine provides useful human-like AI tasks rather than matching a numeric brain-compute estimate.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Useful AI does not establish whole-brain throughput or general human intelligence; this task-capability reading is only partially realized.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Numeric throughput threshold and hardware-only comparison" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "P04", "N09", "N10", "N11" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2020, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "UNSCORABLE", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The Q&A provides a numerical modeling estimate, not a scientifically settled conversion between brain function and GPU operations. Promotional low-precision accelerator throughput cannot establish full human-brain emulation.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K025", "slug": "k025-a-thousand-dollar-brain-capacity-computer-in-2020", "title": "A thousand-dollar brain-capacity computer in 2020", "prediction_paraphrase": "$1,000 purchases human-brain computational capacity.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "brain equivalence", "operations per second" ], "subcategory": "Price/performance", "claim_type": "PERFORMANCE_COST", "family_id": "F-BRAIN-COMPUTE", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-026", "EXE-018" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2005, "year_basis": "DATED_DIALOGUE_IN_LATER_REPOST", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2020", "deadline_year": 2020, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2020, "year_end": 2020, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "About $1,000 purchases the forecast’s roughly 10^16 calculations/second brain-hardware budget, using an explicit arithmetic proxy.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC.", "at_review_rationale": "The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC. The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P04", "locator": "Question 6", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P04", "locator": "Page identifies the dialogue as 2005. Store dialogue year 2005 separately from archive publication date 2011. Not a checked scan of the 2005 book.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N09", "locator": "RTX 3080 launch price $699 and roughly 30 FP32 shader TFLOPS. Tensor, ray-tracing and shader operations are not interchangeable.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N10", "locator": "10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N11", "locator": "RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "FP32 is an explicit editorial comparison, not a biological unit. Low-precision/sparse TOPS, CPU instructions and brain synaptic operations cannot be equated without a model.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-026", "relation": "MERGE_SAME_SCOPE" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-018", "relation": "MERGE_SAME_SCOPE" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-017", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" } ] }, "id": "K025", "familyId": "F-BRAIN-COMPUTE", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K025", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "brain equivalence", "operations per second", "Price/performance" ], "claimType": "PERFORMANCE_COST", "importedClaim": "$1,000 purchases human-brain computational capacity.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "$1,000 purchases human-brain computational capacity.", "successCriteria": "About $1,000 purchases the forecast’s roughly 10^16 calculations/second brain-hardware budget, using an explicit arithmetic proxy.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P04", "title": "So what is the singularity? — Ray Kurzweil Q&A", "publicationYear": 2005, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.writingsbyraykurzweil.com/so-what-is-the-singularity", "locator": "Question 6", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2020", "year": 2020, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P04", "id": "P04-0", "title": "So what is the singularity? — Ray Kurzweil Q&A", "url": "https://www.writingsbyraykurzweil.com/so-what-is-the-singularity", "publishedAt": "2011-01-01", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Page identifies the dialogue as 2005. Store dialogue year 2005 separately from archive publication date 2011. Not a checked scan of the 2005 book.. Page identifies the dialogue as 2005. Store dialogue year 2005 separately from archive publication date 2011. Not a checked scan of the 2005 book." }, { "sourceId": "N09", "id": "N09-1", "title": "NVIDIA: RTX 30-series launch specifications and pricing", "url": "https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/geforce/news/introducing-rtx-30-series-graphics-cards/", "publishedAt": "2020-09-01", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "RTX 3080 launch price $699 and roughly 30 FP32 shader TFLOPS. Tensor, ray-tracing and shader operations are not interchangeable.. RTX 3080 launch price $699 and roughly 30 FP32 shader TFLOPS. Tensor, ray-tracing and shader operations are not interchangeable." }, { "sourceId": "N10", "id": "N10-2", "title": "NVIDIA: RTX 5080 specifications", "url": "https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/geforce/graphics-cards/50-series/rtx-5080/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence.. 10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence." }, { "sourceId": "N11", "id": "N11-3", "title": "NVIDIA: Blackwell GeForce RTX 50-series launch", "url": "https://investor.nvidia.com/news/press-release-details/2025/NVIDIA-Blackwell-GeForce-RTX-50-Series-Opens-New-World-of-AI-Computer-Graphics/default.aspx", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC.. RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": true, "rationale": "A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC. The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.", "alternativeInterpretation": "FP32 is an explicit editorial comparison, not a biological unit. Low-precision/sparse TOPS, CPU instructions and brain synaptic operations cannot be equated without a model.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "FP32 is an explicit editorial comparison, not a biological unit. Low-precision/sparse TOPS, CPU instructions and brain synaptic operations cannot be equated without a model.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNSCORABLE. The Q&A provides a numerical modeling estimate, not a scientifically settled conversion between brain function and GPU operations. Promotional low-precision accelerator throughput cannot establish full human-brain emulation. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC. The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"About $1,000 purchases the forecast’s roughly 10^16 calculations/second brain-hardware budget, using an explicit arithmetic proxy.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC. The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P04\",\"N09\",\"N10\",\"N11\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2020,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"About $1,000 purchases the forecast’s roughly 10^16 calculations/second brain-hardware budget, using an explicit arithmetic proxy.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC. The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P04\",\"N09\",\"N10\",\"N11\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2020,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"A $1,000-class machine provides useful human-like AI tasks rather than matching a numeric brain-compute estimate.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Useful AI does not establish whole-brain throughput or general human intelligence; this task-capability reading is only partially realized.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Numeric throughput threshold and hardware-only comparison\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P04\",\"N09\",\"N10\",\"N11\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2020,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"UNSCORABLE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The Q&A provides a numerical modeling estimate, not a scientifically settled conversion between brain function and GPU operations. Promotional low-precision accelerator throughput cannot establish full human-brain emulation.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K025\",\"slug\":\"k025-a-thousand-dollar-brain-capacity-computer-in-2020\",\"title\":\"A thousand-dollar brain-capacity computer in 2020\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"$1,000 purchases human-brain computational capacity.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[\"brain equivalence\",\"operations per second\"],\"subcategory\":\"Price/performance\",\"claim_type\":\"PERFORMANCE_COST\",\"family_id\":\"F-BRAIN-COMPUTE\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-026\",\"EXE-018\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2005,\"year_basis\":\"DATED_DIALOGUE_IN_LATER_REPOST\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2020\",\"deadline_year\":2020,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2020,\"year_end\":2020,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"About $1,000 purchases the forecast’s roughly 10^16 calculations/second brain-hardware budget, using an explicit arithmetic proxy.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"A 2020 RTX 3080 delivered roughly 3×10^13 FP32 operations/second, well below 10^16 even before the rest of the PC. The checked $999-launch RTX 5080 class remains below 10^16 even using the much less comparable low-precision AI figure. The constant-dollar adjustment does not bridge the large FP32 gap.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P04\",\"locator\":\"Question 6\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P04\",\"locator\":\"Page identifies the dialogue as 2005. Store dialogue year 2005 separately from archive publication date 2011. Not a checked scan of the 2005 book.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N09\",\"locator\":\"RTX 3080 launch price $699 and roughly 30 FP32 shader TFLOPS. Tensor, ray-tracing and shader operations are not interchangeable.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N10\",\"locator\":\"10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N11\",\"locator\":\"RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"FP32 is an explicit editorial comparison, not a biological unit. Low-precision/sparse TOPS, CPU instructions and brain synaptic operations cannot be equated without a model.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-026\",\"relation\":\"MERGE_SAME_SCOPE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-018\",\"relation\":\"MERGE_SAME_SCOPE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-017\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Ordinary intelligent highways accept a vehicle into automatic road-control infrastructure while local roads remain conventional.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009. Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O15", "N07", "O14" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Ordinary intelligent highways accept a vehicle into automatic road-control infrastructure while local roads remain conventional.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009. Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O15", "N07", "O14" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Driverless travel is offered on public roads, regardless of whether intelligence is onboard or in the road.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Public fully driverless Waymo service establishes this functional result in 2020.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Infrastructure mechanism and highway-specific form" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2020, "evidence_source_ids": [ "O15", "N07", "O14" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "WRONG_MISSED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The retrospective acknowledges the prediction was wrong at the deadline. A closed-course DARPA challenge was not public highway deployment. Later onboard-autonomy robotaxis are not automatically the same infrastructure mechanism.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K026", "slug": "k026-automated-intelligent-highways", "title": "Automated intelligent highways", "prediction_paraphrase": "Cars lock into automated highway control systems.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Robotics & transportation", "tags": [ "infrastructure control" ], "subcategory": "Intelligent highways", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "F-AUTOMATED-DRIVING", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "DEC-014" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Ordinary intelligent highways accept a vehicle into automatic road-control infrastructure while local roads remain conventional.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009. Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "Business and Economics, prediction 18, printed p. 82", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O15", "locator": "Closed-course research challenge, not everyday automated public-highway infrastructure.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N07", "locator": "Geofenced Phoenix service, not all roads, universal ownership, or road-embedded guidance infrastructure.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O14", "locator": "Live guidance checked for this review. Describes limited operating areas for automated fleets and driver-attention requirements of consumer vehicles; not a historical 2009 market census.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-028", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-022", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-009", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-014", "relation": "CORRECT_SCOPE" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-004", "relation": "QUARANTINE_AND_SPLIT_REQUIRED" } ] }, "id": "K026", "familyId": "F-AUTOMATED-DRIVING", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K026", "category": "Robotics & transportation", "tags": [ "infrastructure control", "Intelligent highways" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Cars lock into automated highway control systems.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Cars lock into automated highway control systems.", "successCriteria": "Ordinary intelligent highways accept a vehicle into automatic road-control infrastructure while local roads remain conventional.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "Business and Economics, prediction 18, printed p. 82", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O15", "id": "O15-0", "title": "Cornell meets DARPA Urban Challenge", "url": "https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2007/11/cornell-meets-darpa-urban-challenge", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Closed-course research challenge, not everyday automated public-highway infrastructure.. Closed-course research challenge, not everyday automated public-highway infrastructure." }, { "sourceId": "N07", "id": "N07-1", "title": "Waymo opens its fully driverless service to the public", "url": "https://waymo.com/blog/2020/10/waymo-is-opening-its-fully-driverless-service-in-phoenix/", "publishedAt": "2020-10-08", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Geofenced Phoenix service, not all roads, universal ownership, or road-embedded guidance infrastructure.. Geofenced Phoenix service, not all roads, universal ownership, or road-embedded guidance infrastructure." }, { "sourceId": "O14", "id": "O14-2", "title": "Automated Vehicle Safety — NHTSA", "url": "https://www.nhtsa.gov/vehicle-safety/automated-vehicle-safety", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Live guidance checked for this review. Describes limited operating areas for automated fleets and driver-attention requirements of consumer vehicles; not a historical 2009 market census.. Live guidance checked for this review. Describes limited operating areas for automated fleets and driver-attention requirements of consumer vehicles; not a historical 2009 market census." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009. Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: WRONG_MISSED. The retrospective acknowledges the prediction was wrong at the deadline. A closed-course DARPA challenge was not public highway deployment. Later onboard-autonomy robotaxis are not automatically the same infrastructure mechanism. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009. Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Ordinary intelligent highways accept a vehicle into automatic road-control infrastructure while local roads remain conventional.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009. Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O15\",\"N07\",\"O14\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Ordinary intelligent highways accept a vehicle into automatic road-control infrastructure while local roads remain conventional.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009. Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O15\",\"N07\",\"O14\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Driverless travel is offered on public roads, regardless of whether intelligence is onboard or in the road.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Public fully driverless Waymo service establishes this functional result in 2020.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Infrastructure mechanism and highway-specific form\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2020,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O15\",\"N07\",\"O14\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG_MISSED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The retrospective acknowledges the prediction was wrong at the deadline. A closed-course DARPA challenge was not public highway deployment. Later onboard-autonomy robotaxis are not automatically the same infrastructure mechanism.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K026\",\"slug\":\"k026-automated-intelligent-highways\",\"title\":\"Automated intelligent highways\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Cars lock into automated highway control systems.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Robotics & transportation\",\"tags\":[\"infrastructure control\"],\"subcategory\":\"Intelligent highways\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"F-AUTOMATED-DRIVING\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"DEC-014\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Ordinary intelligent highways accept a vehicle into automatic road-control infrastructure while local roads remain conventional.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Demonstrations of autonomy did not create the forecast’s functioning highway-control network in 2009. Automated vehicle capability has advanced substantially, but Waymo’s onboard autonomy is not the forecast’s road-embedded highway architecture.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"Business and Economics, prediction 18, printed p. 82\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O15\",\"locator\":\"Closed-course research challenge, not everyday automated public-highway infrastructure.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N07\",\"locator\":\"Geofenced Phoenix service, not all roads, universal ownership, or road-embedded guidance infrastructure.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O14\",\"locator\":\"Live guidance checked for this review. Describes limited operating areas for automated fleets and driver-attention requirements of consumer vehicles; not a historical 2009 market census.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-028\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-022\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-009\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-014\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_SCOPE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-004\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_AND_SPLIT_REQUIRED\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Ordinary population life expectancy/expected lifespan exceeds 100 years, not a few individuals living past 100.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100. CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100.", "at_review_rationale": "CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O16", "O17" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Ordinary population life expectancy/expected lifespan exceeds 100 years, not a few individuals living past 100.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100. CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100.", "at_review_rationale": "CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O16", "O17" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Ordinary population life expectancy/expected lifespan exceeds 100 years, not a few individuals living past 100.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100. CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100.", "at_review_rationale": "CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O16", "O17" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "WRONG_MISSED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Final US life expectancy was 78.8 in 2019 and 79.0 in 2024. Even this high-income-country example does not support the general claim. The judgment is explicitly under the conventional period-life-expectancy reading.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K027", "slug": "k027-life-expectancy-over-100", "title": "Life expectancy over 100", "prediction_paraphrase": "Expected human lifespan exceeds 100 years.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Longevity", "tags": [ "period versus cohort" ], "subcategory": "Population life expectancy", "claim_type": "SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME", "family_id": "F-LIFE-EXPECTANCY", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "EXE-013" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Ordinary population life expectancy/expected lifespan exceeds 100 years, not a few individuals living past 100.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100.", "at_review_rationale": "CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100. CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Health care in 2019", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O16", "locator": "Final US period life expectancy for 2019: 78.8 years. A national period measure, not a prediction of a newborn cohort’s eventual lifespan.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O17", "locator": "Final US period life expectancy for 2024: 79.0 years. Do not call this a 2026 observation.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Period life expectancy is the reference measurable interpretation. A forecast about an unspecified future cohort would need its own model; it is not evidence of present achievement.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "EXE-013", "relation": "SPLIT_AND_QUARANTINE_UNLOCATED_CLAUSE" } ] }, "id": "K027", "familyId": "F-LIFE-EXPECTANCY", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K027", "category": "Longevity", "tags": [ "period versus cohort", "Population life expectancy" ], "claimType": "SOCIAL_INSTITUTIONAL", "importedClaim": "Expected human lifespan exceeds 100 years.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Expected human lifespan exceeds 100 years.", "successCriteria": "Ordinary population life expectancy/expected lifespan exceeds 100 years, not a few individuals living past 100.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Health care in 2019", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O16", "id": "O16-0", "title": "Mortality in the United States, 2019 — CDC Data Brief 395", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db395.htm", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Final US period life expectancy for 2019: 78.8 years. A national period measure, not a prediction of a newborn cohort’s eventual lifespan.. Final US period life expectancy for 2019: 78.8 years. A national period measure, not a prediction of a newborn cohort’s eventual lifespan." }, { "sourceId": "O17", "id": "O17-1", "title": "Mortality in the United States, 2024 — CDC Data Brief 548", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db548.htm", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Final US period life expectancy for 2024: 79.0 years. Do not call this a 2026 observation.. Final US period life expectancy for 2024: 79.0 years. Do not call this a 2026 observation." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100. CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Period life expectancy is the reference measurable interpretation. A forecast about an unspecified future cohort would need its own model; it is not evidence of present achievement.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: WRONG_MISSED. Final US life expectancy was 78.8 in 2019 and 79.0 in 2024. Even this high-income-country example does not support the general claim. The judgment is explicitly under the conventional period-life-expectancy reading. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100. CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Ordinary population life expectancy/expected lifespan exceeds 100 years, not a few individuals living past 100.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100. CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O16\",\"O17\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Ordinary population life expectancy/expected lifespan exceeds 100 years, not a few individuals living past 100.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100. CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O16\",\"O17\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Ordinary population life expectancy/expected lifespan exceeds 100 years, not a few individuals living past 100.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100. CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O16\",\"O17\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG_MISSED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Final US life expectancy was 78.8 in 2019 and 79.0 in 2024. Even this high-income-country example does not support the general claim. The judgment is explicitly under the conventional period-life-expectancy reading.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K027\",\"slug\":\"k027-life-expectancy-over-100\",\"title\":\"Life expectancy over 100\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Expected human lifespan exceeds 100 years.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Longevity\",\"tags\":[\"period versus cohort\"],\"subcategory\":\"Population life expectancy\",\"claim_type\":\"SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME\",\"family_id\":\"F-LIFE-EXPECTANCY\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"EXE-013\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Ordinary population life expectancy/expected lifespan exceeds 100 years, not a few individuals living past 100.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Observed 2019 US life expectancy was 78.8 years, far below 100. CDC’s 2024 estimate is 79.0 years. Cohort hopes or exceptional centenarians do not establish ordinary life expectancy over 100.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Health care in 2019\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O16\",\"locator\":\"Final US period life expectancy for 2019: 78.8 years. A national period measure, not a prediction of a newborn cohort’s eventual lifespan.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O17\",\"locator\":\"Final US period life expectancy for 2024: 79.0 years. Do not call this a 2026 observation.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Period life expectancy is the reference measurable interpretation. A forecast about an unspecified future cohort would need its own model; it is not evidence of present achievement.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-013\",\"relation\":\"SPLIT_AND_QUARANTINE_UNLOCATED_CLAUSE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Population life expectancy reaches 120 years.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early. Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early.", "at_review_rationale": "Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O17" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Population life expectancy reaches 120 years.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early. Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early.", "at_review_rationale": "Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O17" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Population life expectancy reaches 120 years.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early. Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early.", "at_review_rationale": "Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O17" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The deadline has not passed. The available statistics provide a baseline, not a reason to call a 2029 forecast wrong in 2026.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K028", "slug": "k028-life-expectancy-reaches-120", "title": "Life expectancy reaches 120", "prediction_paraphrase": "Human life expectancy reaches 120 years.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Longevity", "tags": [ "period versus cohort" ], "subcategory": "Population life expectancy", "claim_type": "SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME", "family_id": "F-LIFE-EXPECTANCY", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "EXE-013" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2029", "deadline_year": 2029, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2029, "year_end": 2029, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Population life expectancy reaches 120 years.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early.", "at_review_rationale": "Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early. Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Health care in 2029", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O17", "locator": "Final US period life expectancy for 2024: 79.0 years. Do not call this a 2026 observation.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "EXE-013", "relation": "SPLIT_AND_QUARANTINE_UNLOCATED_CLAUSE" } ] }, "id": "K028", "familyId": "F-LIFE-EXPECTANCY", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K028", "category": "Longevity", "tags": [ "period versus cohort", "Population life expectancy" ], "claimType": "SOCIAL_INSTITUTIONAL", "importedClaim": "Human life expectancy reaches 120 years.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Human life expectancy reaches 120 years.", "successCriteria": "Population life expectancy reaches 120 years.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Health care in 2029", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2029", "year": 2029, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O17", "id": "O17-0", "title": "Mortality in the United States, 2024 — CDC Data Brief 548", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db548.htm", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Final US period life expectancy for 2024: 79.0 years. Do not call this a 2026 observation.. Final US period life expectancy for 2024: 79.0 years. Do not call this a 2026 observation." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early. Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. The deadline has not passed. The available statistics provide a baseline, not a reason to call a 2029 forecast wrong in 2026. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early. Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Population life expectancy reaches 120 years.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early. Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O17\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Population life expectancy reaches 120 years.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early. Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O17\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Population life expectancy reaches 120 years.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early. Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O17\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The deadline has not passed. The available statistics provide a baseline, not a reason to call a 2029 forecast wrong in 2026.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K028\",\"slug\":\"k028-life-expectancy-reaches-120\",\"title\":\"Life expectancy reaches 120\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Human life expectancy reaches 120 years.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Longevity\",\"tags\":[\"period versus cohort\"],\"subcategory\":\"Population life expectancy\",\"claim_type\":\"SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME\",\"family_id\":\"F-LIFE-EXPECTANCY\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"EXE-013\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2029\",\"deadline_year\":2029,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2029,\"year_end\":2029,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Population life expectancy reaches 120 years.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The target is 2029; no deadline failure is assigned early. Observed life expectancy remains far below 120, despite specific medical improvements.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Health care in 2029\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O17\",\"locator\":\"Final US period life expectancy for 2024: 79.0 years. Do not call this a 2026 observation.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-013\",\"relation\":\"SPLIT_AND_QUARANTINE_UNLOCATED_CLAUSE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Gestures and natural spoken interaction predominate and keyboards become rare, retaining the substantive keyboard-rarity clause.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal. Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal.", "at_review_rationale": "Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O10", "N53", "N46" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Gestures and natural spoken interaction predominate and keyboards become rare, retaining the substantive keyboard-rarity clause.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal. Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal.", "at_review_rationale": "Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O10", "N53", "N46" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Natural speech and gestures become ordinary major ways to interact, without keyboard disappearance.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Phones and voice assistants realize this less demanding interaction claim by 2019.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Keyboard rarity and dominance threshold" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "evidence_source_ids": [ "O10", "N53", "N46" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "Siri/Alexa existence is insufficient. A representative usage denominator and the meaning of gesture versus touch typing still need to be established.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K029", "slug": "k029-gesture-and-spoken-language-become-dominant-input", "title": "Gesture and spoken language become dominant input", "prediction_paraphrase": "Most computer interaction uses gestures and natural speech.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "gestures", "speech", "adoption" ], "subcategory": "Human-computer interaction", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K029", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "DEC-019" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Gestures and natural spoken interaction predominate and keyboards become rare, retaining the substantive keyboard-rarity clause.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal.", "at_review_rationale": "Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal. Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2019: keyboards and interaction", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O10", "locator": "Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N53", "locator": "968 million smartphones; Android plus iOS dominated. Inferring physical-keyboard-free portable computing requires a population definition, not simply counting all feature phones.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N46", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "DEC-019", "relation": "RESTORE_ADOPTION_THRESHOLD" } ] }, "id": "K029", "familyId": "K029", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K029", "category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "gestures", "speech", "adoption", "Human-computer interaction" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Most computer interaction uses gestures and natural speech.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Most computer interaction uses gestures and natural speech.", "successCriteria": "Gestures and natural spoken interaction predominate and keyboards become rare, retaining the substantive keyboard-rarity clause.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2019: keyboards and interaction", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O10", "id": "O10-0", "title": "Apple launches iPhone 4S, iOS 5 and iCloud", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2011/10/04Apple-Launches-iPhone-4S-iOS-5-iCloud/", "publishedAt": "2011-10-04", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release.. Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release." }, { "sourceId": "N53", "id": "N53-1", "title": "Gartner: Worldwide smartphone sales in 2013", "url": "https://www.pressebox.com/pressrelease/gartner-uk-ltd/Gartner-Says-Annual-Smartphone-Sales-Surpassed-Sales-of-Feature-Phones-for-the-First-Time-in-2013/boxid/658123", "publishedAt": "2014-02-13", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "968 million smartphones; Android plus iOS dominated. Inferring physical-keyboard-free portable computing requires a population definition, not simply counting all feature phones.. 968 million smartphones; Android plus iOS dominated. Inferring physical-keyboard-free portable computing requires a population definition, not simply counting all feature phones." }, { "sourceId": "N46", "id": "N46-2", "title": "Microsoft Teams reaches 13 million daily active users", "url": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/blog/2019/07/11/microsoft-teams-reaches-13-million-daily-active-users-introduces-4-new-ways-for-teams-to-work-better-together/", "publishedAt": "2019-07-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal. Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. Siri/Alexa existence is insufficient. A representative usage denominator and the meaning of gesture versus touch typing still need to be established. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal. Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Gestures and natural spoken interaction predominate and keyboards become rare, retaining the substantive keyboard-rarity clause.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal. Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O10\",\"N53\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Gestures and natural spoken interaction predominate and keyboards become rare, retaining the substantive keyboard-rarity clause.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal. Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O10\",\"N53\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Natural speech and gestures become ordinary major ways to interact, without keyboard disappearance.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Phones and voice assistants realize this less demanding interaction claim by 2019.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Keyboard rarity and dominance threshold\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O10\",\"N53\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"Siri/Alexa existence is insufficient. A representative usage denominator and the meaning of gesture versus touch typing still need to be established.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K029\",\"slug\":\"k029-gesture-and-spoken-language-become-dominant-input\",\"title\":\"Gesture and spoken language become dominant input\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Most computer interaction uses gestures and natural speech.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"AI & software\",\"tags\":[\"gestures\",\"speech\",\"adoption\"],\"subcategory\":\"Human-computer interaction\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K029\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"DEC-019\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Gestures and natural spoken interaction predominate and keyboards become rare, retaining the substantive keyboard-rarity clause.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Touchscreens and assistants were widespread by 2019, but keyboards remained normal. Multimodal AI expands the predicted interface, yet physical and on-screen keyboards are not rare. The compound remains partial.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Computers and communications in 2019: keyboards and interaction\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O10\",\"locator\":\"Announcement; retail availability October 14. This is NOT the first-ever voice assistant, nor the first standalone Siri release.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N53\",\"locator\":\"968 million smartphones; Android plus iOS dominated. Inferring physical-keyboard-free portable computing requires a population definition, not simply counting all feature phones.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N46\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-019\",\"relation\":\"RESTORE_ADOPTION_THRESHOLD\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Retinal glasses/contacts with the specified exceptional resolution are routinely worn, not just demonstrated.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not. Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not.", "at_review_rationale": "Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N04", "N05" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Retinal glasses/contacts with the specified exceptional resolution are routinely worn, not just demonstrated.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not. Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not.", "at_review_rationale": "Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N04", "N05" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Practical consumer immersive/AR near-eye displays are available.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Quest and other head-worn systems satisfy availability by 2019.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Routine broad wearing", "Retinal implementation and above-human acuity" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N04", "N05" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The source is located; the earlier “Google Glass exists” comparison did not test the required mechanism, acuity or adoption. A defensible device/adoption evidence set is still needed.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K030", "slug": "k030-routine-high-acuity-retinal-displays", "title": "Routine high-acuity retinal displays", "prediction_paraphrase": "Retinal glasses or contacts are routinely used.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "visual acuity", "adoption" ], "subcategory": "Retinal displays", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K030", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "EXE-009" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Retinal glasses/contacts with the specified exceptional resolution are routinely worn, not just demonstrated.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not.", "at_review_rationale": "Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not. Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2019: direct-eye displays", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N04", "locator": "Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N05", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "EXE-009", "relation": "SPLIT_DISTINCT_CAPABILITIES" } ] }, "id": "K030", "familyId": "K030", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K030", "category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "visual acuity", "adoption", "Retinal displays" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Retinal glasses or contacts are routinely used.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Retinal glasses or contacts are routinely used.", "successCriteria": "Retinal glasses/contacts with the specified exceptional resolution are routinely worn, not just demonstrated.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2019: direct-eye displays", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N04", "id": "N04-0", "title": "Microvision: Nomad retinal display installed at Chevrolet dealership", "url": "https://www.theautochannel.com/news/2004/08/10/208323.html", "publishedAt": "2004-08-10", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption.. Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption." }, { "sourceId": "N05", "id": "N05-1", "title": "Qualcomm: Snapdragon platform powers shipping Oculus Quest", "url": "https://www.qualcomm.com/news/releases/2019/05/qualcomm-snapdragon-mobile-vr-platform-powers-oculus-quest", "publishedAt": "2019-05-20", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not. Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. The source is located; the earlier “Google Glass exists” comparison did not test the required mechanism, acuity or adoption. A defensible device/adoption evidence set is still needed. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not. Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Retinal glasses/contacts with the specified exceptional resolution are routinely worn, not just demonstrated.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not. Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N04\",\"N05\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Retinal glasses/contacts with the specified exceptional resolution are routinely worn, not just demonstrated.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not. Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N04\",\"N05\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Practical consumer immersive/AR near-eye displays are available.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Quest and other head-worn systems satisfy availability by 2019.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Routine broad wearing\",\"Retinal implementation and above-human acuity\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N04\",\"N05\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The source is located; the earlier “Google Glass exists” comparison did not test the required mechanism, acuity or adoption. A defensible device/adoption evidence set is still needed.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K030\",\"slug\":\"k030-routine-high-acuity-retinal-displays\",\"title\":\"Routine high-acuity retinal displays\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Retinal glasses or contacts are routinely used.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Interfaces & virtual worlds\",\"tags\":[\"visual acuity\",\"adoption\"],\"subcategory\":\"Retinal displays\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K030\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"EXE-009\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Retinal glasses/contacts with the specified exceptional resolution are routinely worn, not just demonstrated.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Near-eye displays existed in 2019, but mainstream routine use at the asserted acuity did not. Practical headsets/AR prove part of the direction, not routine retinal contacts or acuity above human vision.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Computers and communications in 2019: direct-eye displays\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N04\",\"locator\":\"Microvision-issued release hosted by The Auto Channel: actual industrial deployment. Head-worn see-through retinal display; not ordinary prescription-glasses styling or mass consumer adoption.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N05\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-009\",\"relation\":\"SPLIT_DISTINCT_CAPABILITIES\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "A widely available booth convincingly reproduces whole-body pressure, temperature, texture and wetness.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019. Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N28" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "A widely available booth convincingly reproduces whole-body pressure, temperature, texture and wetness.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019. Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N28" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "VR systems provide useful partial haptic feedback.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Haptic feedback is real, but treating any vibration as the full prediction would discard its central specification.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Whole-body and all-sensation fidelity" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N28" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "Audiovisual headsets are not evidence of this all-body tactile outcome. The imported broad “VR indistinguishable” wording hid the actual test. No verified full-achievement date is supplied.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K031", "slug": "k031-convincing-full-body-tactile-virtual-reality", "title": "Convincing full-body tactile virtual reality", "prediction_paraphrase": "Widely available booths reproduce the full tactile experience.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "full-body sensation", "VR" ], "subcategory": "Haptics", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K031", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "DEC-017" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "A widely available booth convincingly reproduces whole-body pressure, temperature, texture and wetness.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019. Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Personal relationships in 2019: total-touch environment", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N28", "locator": "Local finger-scale multimodal haptics; not whole-body, all-sensation realism. Preprint status retained.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "A substantial gap in a central all-enveloping capability earns MISSED, not automatic partial credit for a related component.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "DEC-017", "relation": "RESTORE_MODALITY" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-028", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" } ] }, "id": "K031", "familyId": "K031", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K031", "category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [ "full-body sensation", "VR", "Haptics" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Widely available booths reproduce the full tactile experience.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Widely available booths reproduce the full tactile experience.", "successCriteria": "A widely available booth convincingly reproduces whole-body pressure, temperature, texture and wetness.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Personal relationships in 2019: total-touch environment", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N28", "id": "N28-0", "title": "Research prototype for thermal and pressure haptics", "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.20831", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Local finger-scale multimodal haptics; not whole-body, all-sensation realism. Preprint status retained.. Local finger-scale multimodal haptics; not whole-body, all-sensation realism. Preprint status retained." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019. Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.", "alternativeInterpretation": "A substantial gap in a central all-enveloping capability earns MISSED, not automatic partial credit for a related component.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "A substantial gap in a central all-enveloping capability earns MISSED, not automatic partial credit for a related component.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. Audiovisual headsets are not evidence of this all-body tactile outcome. The imported broad “VR indistinguishable” wording hid the actual test. No verified full-achievement date is supplied. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019. Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"A widely available booth convincingly reproduces whole-body pressure, temperature, texture and wetness.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019. Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N28\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"A widely available booth convincingly reproduces whole-body pressure, temperature, texture and wetness.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019. Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N28\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"VR systems provide useful partial haptic feedback.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Haptic feedback is real, but treating any vibration as the full prediction would discard its central specification.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Whole-body and all-sensation fidelity\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N28\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"Audiovisual headsets are not evidence of this all-body tactile outcome. The imported broad “VR indistinguishable” wording hid the actual test. No verified full-achievement date is supplied.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K031\",\"slug\":\"k031-convincing-full-body-tactile-virtual-reality\",\"title\":\"Convincing full-body tactile virtual reality\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Widely available booths reproduce the full tactile experience.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Interfaces & virtual worlds\",\"tags\":[\"full-body sensation\",\"VR\"],\"subcategory\":\"Haptics\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K031\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"DEC-017\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"A widely available booth convincingly reproduces whole-body pressure, temperature, texture and wetness.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Limited vibration/force feedback did not constitute the specified full tactile environment in 2019. Recent finger-scale thermal/pressure research remains materially short of an all-enveloping, all-facet consumer booth.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Personal relationships in 2019: total-touch environment\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N28\",\"locator\":\"Local finger-scale multimodal haptics; not whole-body, all-sensation realism. Preprint status retained.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"A substantial gap in a central all-enveloping capability earns MISSED, not automatic partial credit for a related component.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-017\",\"relation\":\"RESTORE_MODALITY\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-028\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "High-bandwidth neural links materially replace or augment specialized brain-region functions.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 deadline is future. Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 deadline is future.", "at_review_rationale": "Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O23", "N15", "N16" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "High-bandwidth neural links materially replace or augment specialized brain-region functions.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 deadline is future. Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 deadline is future.", "at_review_rationale": "Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O23", "N15", "N16" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "High-bandwidth neural links materially replace or augment specialized brain-region functions.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 deadline is future. Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 deadline is future.", "at_review_rationale": "Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O23", "N15", "N16" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The original functional requirements are materially stronger than demonstrating a human BCI trial. The deadline remains future.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K032", "slug": "k032-high-bandwidth-neural-interfaces-augment-brain-functions", "title": "High-bandwidth neural interfaces augment brain functions", "prediction_paraphrase": "Neural links augment or bypass specialized brain functions.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Neuroscience & human augmentation", "tags": [ "bandwidth", "cognitive functions" ], "subcategory": "Neural augmentation", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "F-BRAIN-INTERFACE", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "EXE-010" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2029", "deadline_year": 2029, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2029, "year_end": 2029, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "High-bandwidth neural links materially replace or augment specialized brain-region functions.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 deadline is future.", "at_review_rationale": "Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The 2029 deadline is future. Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2029: neural pathways", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O23", "locator": "Cochlear implants do not restore normal hearing. Used to correct a medical error in our intake, not to manufacture a Kurzweil forecast.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N15", "locator": "Mouse cell atlas, not a functional emulation of the entire human brain.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N16", "locator": "Adult fruit-fly connectome. Species, wiring map and functional cognitive model must not be conflated.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Therapeutic sensory restoration, connectivity maps and generalized cognition augmentation are different capabilities.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "DEC-029", "relation": "QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_OR_UNLOCATED" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-030", "relation": "QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_OR_UNLOCATED" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-030", "relation": "QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_OR_UNLOCATED" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-010", "relation": "CANONICALIZE" } ] }, "id": "K032", "familyId": "F-BRAIN-INTERFACE", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K032", "category": "Neuroscience & human augmentation", "tags": [ "bandwidth", "cognitive functions", "Neural augmentation" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Neural links augment or bypass specialized brain functions.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Neural links augment or bypass specialized brain functions.", "successCriteria": "High-bandwidth neural links materially replace or augment specialized brain-region functions.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2029: neural pathways", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2029", "year": 2029, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O23", "id": "O23-0", "title": "What educators need to know about cochlear implants — FDA", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/cochlear-implants/what-educators-need-know", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Cochlear implants do not restore normal hearing. Used to correct a medical error in our intake, not to manufacture a Kurzweil forecast.. Cochlear implants do not restore normal hearing. Used to correct a medical error in our intake, not to manufacture a Kurzweil forecast." }, { "sourceId": "N15", "id": "N15-1", "title": "NIH: Complete cell map of a whole mammalian brain", "url": "https://www.nimh.nih.gov/news/science-updates/2023/scientists-unveil-complete-cell-map-of-a-whole-mammalian-brain", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Mouse cell atlas, not a functional emulation of the entire human brain.. Mouse cell atlas, not a functional emulation of the entire human brain." }, { "sourceId": "N16", "id": "N16-2", "title": "Dorkenwald et al.: Neuronal wiring diagram of an adult brain", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07686-5", "publishedAt": "2024-10-02", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Adult fruit-fly connectome. Species, wiring map and functional cognitive model must not be conflated.. Adult fruit-fly connectome. Species, wiring map and functional cognitive model must not be conflated." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The 2029 deadline is future. Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "Therapeutic sensory restoration, connectivity maps and generalized cognition augmentation are different capabilities.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. The original functional requirements are materially stronger than demonstrating a human BCI trial. The deadline remains future. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. The 2029 deadline is future. Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"High-bandwidth neural links materially replace or augment specialized brain-region functions.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline is future. Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline is future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O23\",\"N15\",\"N16\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"High-bandwidth neural links materially replace or augment specialized brain-region functions.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline is future. Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline is future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O23\",\"N15\",\"N16\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"High-bandwidth neural links materially replace or augment specialized brain-region functions.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline is future. Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline is future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O23\",\"N15\",\"N16\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The original functional requirements are materially stronger than demonstrating a human BCI trial. The deadline remains future.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K032\",\"slug\":\"k032-high-bandwidth-neural-interfaces-augment-brain-functions\",\"title\":\"High-bandwidth neural interfaces augment brain functions\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Neural links augment or bypass specialized brain functions.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Neuroscience & human augmentation\",\"tags\":[\"bandwidth\",\"cognitive functions\"],\"subcategory\":\"Neural augmentation\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"F-BRAIN-INTERFACE\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"EXE-010\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2029\",\"deadline_year\":2029,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2029,\"year_end\":2029,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"High-bandwidth neural links materially replace or augment specialized brain-region functions.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline is future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline is future. Clinical sensory implants and neural-interface research support partial progress, not the broadly perfected high-bandwidth cognitive bypass described.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Computers and communications in 2029: neural pathways\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O23\",\"locator\":\"Cochlear implants do not restore normal hearing. Used to correct a medical error in our intake, not to manufacture a Kurzweil forecast.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N15\",\"locator\":\"Mouse cell atlas, not a functional emulation of the entire human brain.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N16\",\"locator\":\"Adult fruit-fly connectome. Species, wiring map and functional cognitive model must not be conflated.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Therapeutic sensory restoration, connectivity maps and generalized cognition augmentation are different capabilities.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-029\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_OR_UNLOCATED\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-030\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_OR_UNLOCATED\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-030\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_OR_UNLOCATED\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-010\",\"relation\":\"CANONICALIZE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "HIGH", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "A supercomputer sustains approximately 20 petaflops on a named numerical benchmark; this is the explicit hardware-throughput proxy.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target. Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2013, "at_deadline_rationale": "The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target.", "at_review_rationale": "Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O18", "O19", "O20" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "A supercomputer sustains approximately 20 petaflops on a named numerical benchmark; this is the explicit hardware-throughput proxy.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target. Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2013, "at_deadline_rationale": "The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target.", "at_review_rationale": "Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O18", "O19", "O20" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Use advertised peak arithmetic rather than sustained LINPACK.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Titan’s peak exceeded 20 petaflops in 2012, producing a three-year rather than four-year delay.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Sustained versus theoretical peak throughput" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2012, "evidence_source_ids": [ "O18", "O19", "O20" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": 2013, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "EXACT_EVENT", "label": "2013; +4 years", "drift_years": 4, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "LATE", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED_UNDER_STATED_HARDWARE_PROXY", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "November 2009’s leader was below the threshold. Listed peak performance exceeded it by 2012; publicly listed measured LINPACK performance exceeded it in 2013. This supports a qualified hardware timing miss, with a 3–4-year interval depending on the metric.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2013, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": [ 3, 4 ], "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Qualified hardware-proxy assessment; not a verified brain-capacity equivalence. Excluded from default strict aggregate." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K033", "slug": "k033-supercomputers-reach-20-quadrillion-calculations-per-second", "title": "Supercomputers reach 20 quadrillion calculations per second", "prediction_paraphrase": "Supercomputers reach approximately 2×10^16 calculations per second.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "operations per second", "FLOPS proxy", "timing interval" ], "subcategory": "Supercomputer performance", "claim_type": "PERFORMANCE_COST", "family_id": "F-BRAIN-COMPUTE", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "EXE-012" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "A supercomputer sustains approximately 20 petaflops on a named numerical benchmark; this is the explicit hardware-throughput proxy.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target.", "at_review_rationale": "Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "LATE", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target. Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.", "first_full_achievement_year": 2013, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": 4, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2009: numerical hardware estimate", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O18", "locator": "Jaguar Rmax 1.759 petaflops; Rpeak 2.331 petaflops. Rmax is measured LINPACK performance, not brain emulation.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O19", "locator": "Sequoia Rpeak 20.13266 petaflops and Rmax 16.32475; Titan Rpeak 27.11255 and Rmax 17.59. Peak and measured values must not be mixed.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O20", "locator": "Tianhe-2 recorded 33.86 petaflops Rmax. This establishes a public measured milestone, not a cognition milestone.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "This establishes numerical hardware capacity only. Neither 2012 nor 2013 is evidence of simulating a human mind.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "EXE-012", "relation": "SPLIT_AND_HOLD_PRICE_VARIANT" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-017", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" } ] }, "id": "K033", "familyId": "F-BRAIN-COMPUTE", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K033", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "operations per second", "FLOPS proxy", "timing interval", "Supercomputer performance" ], "claimType": "PERFORMANCE_COST", "importedClaim": "Supercomputers reach approximately 2×10^16 calculations per second.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Supercomputers reach approximately 2×10^16 calculations per second.", "successCriteria": "A supercomputer sustains approximately 20 petaflops on a named numerical benchmark; this is the explicit hardware-throughput proxy.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2009: numerical hardware estimate", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O18", "id": "O18-0", "title": "TOP500 — November 2009 list", "url": "https://www.top500.org/lists/top500/2009/11/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Jaguar Rmax 1.759 petaflops; Rpeak 2.331 petaflops. Rmax is measured LINPACK performance, not brain emulation.. Jaguar Rmax 1.759 petaflops; Rpeak 2.331 petaflops. Rmax is measured LINPACK performance, not brain emulation." }, { "sourceId": "O19", "id": "O19-1", "title": "TOP500 — November 2012 list", "url": "https://www.top500.org/lists/top500/2012/11/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Sequoia Rpeak 20.13266 petaflops and Rmax 16.32475; Titan Rpeak 27.11255 and Rmax 17.59. Peak and measured values must not be mixed.. Sequoia Rpeak 20.13266 petaflops and Rmax 16.32475; Titan Rpeak 27.11255 and Rmax 17.59. Peak and measured values must not be mixed." }, { "sourceId": "O20", "id": "O20-2", "title": "TOP500 — June 2013 highlights", "url": "https://www.top500.org/lists/top500/2013/06/highlights/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Tianhe-2 recorded 33.86 petaflops Rmax. This establishes a public measured milestone, not a cognition milestone.. Tianhe-2 recorded 33.86 petaflops Rmax. This establishes a public measured milestone, not a cognition milestone." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": 2013, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": true, "rationale": "The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target. Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.", "alternativeInterpretation": "This establishes numerical hardware capacity only. Neither 2012 nor 2013 is evidence of simulating a human mind.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "This establishes numerical hardware capacity only. Neither 2012 nor 2013 is evidence of simulating a human mind.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: LATE. November 2009’s leader was below the threshold. Listed peak performance exceeded it by 2012; publicly listed measured LINPACK performance exceeded it in 2013. This supports a qualified hardware timing miss, with a 3–4-year interval depending on the metric. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict LATE. The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target. Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"A supercomputer sustains approximately 20 petaflops on a named numerical benchmark; this is the explicit hardware-throughput proxy.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target. Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2013,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O18\",\"O19\",\"O20\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"A supercomputer sustains approximately 20 petaflops on a named numerical benchmark; this is the explicit hardware-throughput proxy.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target. Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2013,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O18\",\"O19\",\"O20\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Use advertised peak arithmetic rather than sustained LINPACK.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Titan’s peak exceeded 20 petaflops in 2012, producing a three-year rather than four-year delay.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Sustained versus theoretical peak throughput\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2012,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O18\",\"O19\",\"O20\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":2013,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"EXACT_EVENT\",\"label\":\"2013; +4 years\",\"drift_years\":4,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED_UNDER_STATED_HARDWARE_PROXY\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"November 2009’s leader was below the threshold. Listed peak performance exceeded it by 2012; publicly listed measured LINPACK performance exceeded it in 2013. This supports a qualified hardware timing miss, with a 3–4-year interval depending on the metric.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2013,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":[3,4],\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Qualified hardware-proxy assessment; not a verified brain-capacity equivalence. Excluded from default strict aggregate.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K033\",\"slug\":\"k033-supercomputers-reach-20-quadrillion-calculations-per-second\",\"title\":\"Supercomputers reach 20 quadrillion calculations per second\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Supercomputers reach approximately 2×10^16 calculations per second.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[\"operations per second\",\"FLOPS proxy\",\"timing interval\"],\"subcategory\":\"Supercomputer performance\",\"claim_type\":\"PERFORMANCE_COST\",\"family_id\":\"F-BRAIN-COMPUTE\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"EXE-012\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"A supercomputer sustains approximately 20 petaflops on a named numerical benchmark; this is the explicit hardware-throughput proxy.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The November 2009 TOP500 leader was under 2 petaflops on LINPACK, below the stated 20-petaflop target. Tianhe-2 exceeded 20 petaflops on LINPACK in June 2013. The numerical forecast was late, not unscorable merely because brain equivalence is debated.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":2013,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":4,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Computers and communications in 2009: numerical hardware estimate\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O18\",\"locator\":\"Jaguar Rmax 1.759 petaflops; Rpeak 2.331 petaflops. Rmax is measured LINPACK performance, not brain emulation.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O19\",\"locator\":\"Sequoia Rpeak 20.13266 petaflops and Rmax 16.32475; Titan Rpeak 27.11255 and Rmax 17.59. Peak and measured values must not be mixed.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O20\",\"locator\":\"Tianhe-2 recorded 33.86 petaflops Rmax. This establishes a public measured milestone, not a cognition milestone.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"This establishes numerical hardware capacity only. Neither 2012 nor 2013 is evidence of simulating a human mind.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-012\",\"relation\":\"SPLIT_AND_HOLD_PRICE_VARIANT\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-017\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "A circa-$1,000 consumer budget, inflation-adjusted from 1999, buys approximately 20 petaflops of ordinary arithmetic capacity.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput. Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput.", "at_review_rationale": "Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N09", "N10", "N11" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "A circa-$1,000 consumer budget, inflation-adjusted from 1999, buys approximately 20 petaflops of ordinary arithmetic capacity.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput. Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput.", "at_review_rationale": "Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N09", "N10", "N11" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "A circa-$1,000 consumer budget, inflation-adjusted from 1999, buys approximately 20 petaflops of ordinary arithmetic capacity.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput. Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput.", "at_review_rationale": "Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N09", "N10", "N11" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "UNSCORABLE", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The article specifies $1,000 in 1999 dollars. The intake’s alleged $4,000 book version is not confirmed here and cannot be silently overwritten. The brain-equivalence metric also remains undefined.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K034", "slug": "k034-the-2019-thousand-dollar-brain-compute-estimate", "title": "The 2019 thousand-dollar brain-compute estimate", "prediction_paraphrase": "$1,000 in 1999 dollars buys brain-scale computation.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "brain equivalence", "currency basis" ], "subcategory": "Price/performance", "claim_type": "PERFORMANCE_COST", "family_id": "F-BRAIN-COMPUTE", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "CONFIRMED_RELATED_VERSION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "A circa-$1,000 consumer budget, inflation-adjusted from 1999, buys approximately 20 petaflops of ordinary arithmetic capacity.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput.", "at_review_rationale": "Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput. Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2019: opening paragraph", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N09", "locator": "RTX 3080 launch price $699 and roughly 30 FP32 shader TFLOPS. Tensor, ray-tracing and shader operations are not interchangeable.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N10", "locator": "10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N11", "locator": "RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "A different precision or sparse-operation convention changes the number, not automatically the biological claim. Current consumer comparison is illustrative, not a full auction-price optimization.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "EXE-012", "relation": "SPLIT_AND_HOLD_PRICE_VARIANT" } ] }, "id": "K034", "familyId": "F-BRAIN-COMPUTE", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K034", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "brain equivalence", "currency basis", "Price/performance" ], "claimType": "PERFORMANCE_COST", "importedClaim": "$1,000 in 1999 dollars buys brain-scale computation.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "$1,000 in 1999 dollars buys brain-scale computation.", "successCriteria": "A circa-$1,000 consumer budget, inflation-adjusted from 1999, buys approximately 20 petaflops of ordinary arithmetic capacity.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2019: opening paragraph", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N09", "id": "N09-0", "title": "NVIDIA: RTX 30-series launch specifications and pricing", "url": "https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/geforce/news/introducing-rtx-30-series-graphics-cards/", "publishedAt": "2020-09-01", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "RTX 3080 launch price $699 and roughly 30 FP32 shader TFLOPS. Tensor, ray-tracing and shader operations are not interchangeable.. RTX 3080 launch price $699 and roughly 30 FP32 shader TFLOPS. Tensor, ray-tracing and shader operations are not interchangeable." }, { "sourceId": "N10", "id": "N10-1", "title": "NVIDIA: RTX 5080 specifications", "url": "https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/geforce/graphics-cards/50-series/rtx-5080/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence.. 10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence." }, { "sourceId": "N11", "id": "N11-2", "title": "NVIDIA: Blackwell GeForce RTX 50-series launch", "url": "https://investor.nvidia.com/news/press-release-details/2025/NVIDIA-Blackwell-GeForce-RTX-50-Series-Opens-New-World-of-AI-Computer-Graphics/default.aspx", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC.. RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput. Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "A different precision or sparse-operation convention changes the number, not automatically the biological claim. Current consumer comparison is illustrative, not a full auction-price optimization.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNSCORABLE. The article specifies $1,000 in 1999 dollars. The intake’s alleged $4,000 book version is not confirmed here and cannot be silently overwritten. The brain-equivalence metric also remains undefined. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput. Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"A circa-$1,000 consumer budget, inflation-adjusted from 1999, buys approximately 20 petaflops of ordinary arithmetic capacity.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput. Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N09\",\"N10\",\"N11\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"A circa-$1,000 consumer budget, inflation-adjusted from 1999, buys approximately 20 petaflops of ordinary arithmetic capacity.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput. Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N09\",\"N10\",\"N11\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"A circa-$1,000 consumer budget, inflation-adjusted from 1999, buys approximately 20 petaflops of ordinary arithmetic capacity.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput. Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N09\",\"N10\",\"N11\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"UNSCORABLE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The article specifies $1,000 in 1999 dollars. The intake’s alleged $4,000 book version is not confirmed here and cannot be silently overwritten. The brain-equivalence metric also remains undefined.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K034\",\"slug\":\"k034-the-2019-thousand-dollar-brain-compute-estimate\",\"title\":\"The 2019 thousand-dollar brain-compute estimate\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"$1,000 in 1999 dollars buys brain-scale computation.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[\"brain equivalence\",\"currency basis\"],\"subcategory\":\"Price/performance\",\"claim_type\":\"PERFORMANCE_COST\",\"family_id\":\"F-BRAIN-COMPUTE\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"CONFIRMED_RELATED_VERSION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"A circa-$1,000 consumer budget, inflation-adjusted from 1999, buys approximately 20 petaflops of ordinary arithmetic capacity.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Consumer hardware in 2019 was orders of magnitude below 20 petaflops in conventional FP32 throughput. Current checked consumer GPU specifications remain far short on that basis. Inflation adjustment and GPU-only accounting do not rescue the order-of-magnitude mismatch.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Computers and communications in 2019: opening paragraph\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N09\",\"locator\":\"RTX 3080 launch price $699 and roughly 30 FP32 shader TFLOPS. Tensor, ray-tracing and shader operations are not interchangeable.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N10\",\"locator\":\"10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N11\",\"locator\":\"RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"A different precision or sparse-operation convention changes the number, not automatically the biological claim. Current consumer comparison is illustrative, not a full auction-price optimization.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-012\",\"relation\":\"SPLIT_AND_HOLD_PRICE_VARIANT\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "A $1,000-in-1999-dollars unit supplies approximately 2×10^19 calculations/second.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 forecast has not matured. Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 forecast has not matured.", "at_review_rationale": "Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N10", "N11" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "A $1,000-in-1999-dollars unit supplies approximately 2×10^19 calculations/second.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 forecast has not matured. Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 forecast has not matured.", "at_review_rationale": "Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N10", "N11" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "A $1,000-in-1999-dollars unit supplies approximately 2×10^19 calculations/second.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 forecast has not matured. Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 forecast has not matured.", "at_review_rationale": "Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N10", "N11" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "A future numerical hardware forecast with an unresolved brain-equivalence interpretation. Do not use model marketing or a single low-precision accelerator specification to declare it already fulfilled.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K035", "slug": "k035-thousand-brain-computation-for-a-thousand-dollars", "title": "Thousand-brain computation for a thousand dollars", "prediction_paraphrase": "$1,000 buys approximately 1,000 brains of computation.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "brain equivalence", "operations per second" ], "subcategory": "Price/performance", "claim_type": "PERFORMANCE_COST", "family_id": "F-BRAIN-COMPUTE", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "EXE-012", "EXE-022" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2029", "deadline_year": 2029, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2029, "year_end": 2029, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "A $1,000-in-1999-dollars unit supplies approximately 2×10^19 calculations/second.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 forecast has not matured.", "at_review_rationale": "Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The 2029 forecast has not matured. Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2029: opening paragraph", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N10", "locator": "10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N11", "locator": "RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "EXE-012", "relation": "SPLIT_AND_HOLD_PRICE_VARIANT" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-022", "relation": "CANONICALIZE" } ] }, "id": "K035", "familyId": "F-BRAIN-COMPUTE", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K035", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "brain equivalence", "operations per second", "Price/performance" ], "claimType": "PERFORMANCE_COST", "importedClaim": "$1,000 buys approximately 1,000 brains of computation.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "$1,000 buys approximately 1,000 brains of computation.", "successCriteria": "A $1,000-in-1999-dollars unit supplies approximately 2×10^19 calculations/second.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2029: opening paragraph", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2029", "year": 2029, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N10", "id": "N10-0", "title": "NVIDIA: RTX 5080 specifications", "url": "https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/geforce/graphics-cards/50-series/rtx-5080/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence.. 10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence." }, { "sourceId": "N11", "id": "N11-1", "title": "NVIDIA: Blackwell GeForce RTX 50-series launch", "url": "https://investor.nvidia.com/news/press-release-details/2025/NVIDIA-Blackwell-GeForce-RTX-50-Series-Opens-New-World-of-AI-Computer-Graphics/default.aspx", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC.. RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The 2029 forecast has not matured. Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. A future numerical hardware forecast with an unresolved brain-equivalence interpretation. Do not use model marketing or a single low-precision accelerator specification to declare it already fulfilled. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. The 2029 forecast has not matured. Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"A $1,000-in-1999-dollars unit supplies approximately 2×10^19 calculations/second.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 forecast has not matured. Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 forecast has not matured.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N10\",\"N11\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"A $1,000-in-1999-dollars unit supplies approximately 2×10^19 calculations/second.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 forecast has not matured. Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 forecast has not matured.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N10\",\"N11\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"A $1,000-in-1999-dollars unit supplies approximately 2×10^19 calculations/second.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 forecast has not matured. Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 forecast has not matured.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N10\",\"N11\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"A future numerical hardware forecast with an unresolved brain-equivalence interpretation. Do not use model marketing or a single low-precision accelerator specification to declare it already fulfilled.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K035\",\"slug\":\"k035-thousand-brain-computation-for-a-thousand-dollars\",\"title\":\"Thousand-brain computation for a thousand dollars\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"$1,000 buys approximately 1,000 brains of computation.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[\"brain equivalence\",\"operations per second\"],\"subcategory\":\"Price/performance\",\"claim_type\":\"PERFORMANCE_COST\",\"family_id\":\"F-BRAIN-COMPUTE\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"EXE-012\",\"EXE-022\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2029\",\"deadline_year\":2029,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2029,\"year_end\":2029,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"A $1,000-in-1999-dollars unit supplies approximately 2×10^19 calculations/second.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 forecast has not matured.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The 2029 forecast has not matured. Checked consumer hardware does not currently reach the stated arithmetic scale. This is pending, not failed in 2026.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Computers and communications in 2029: opening paragraph\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N10\",\"locator\":\"10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N11\",\"locator\":\"RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-012\",\"relation\":\"SPLIT_AND_HOLD_PRICE_VARIANT\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-022\",\"relation\":\"CANONICALIZE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": true, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Effective functional models cover all major human brain regions and their integrated operation, not just a wiring atlas.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model. The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model.", "at_review_rationale": "The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N15", "N16", "N48" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2025, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Same functional criterion, but allow the entire mid-2020s window through December 2026.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "At the October 2026 review the latest plausible deadline has not closed; the current outcome is still partial.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "DEADLINE_WINDOW_SENSITIVITY", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N15", "N16", "N48" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2026, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Effective functional models cover all major human brain regions and their integrated operation, not just a wiring atlas.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model. The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model.", "at_review_rationale": "The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N15", "N16", "N48" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2025, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The intake converted a broad modeling claim into a stronger brain-emulation milestone. “Mid-2020s” is not automatically December 2025, particularly in an October 2026 audit. Scope and deadline policy must precede a verdict.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K036", "slug": "k036-effective-models-of-all-brain-regions", "title": "Effective models of all brain regions", "prediction_paraphrase": "Effective models cover the entire human brain.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Neuroscience & human augmentation", "tags": [ "reverse engineering", "scope" ], "subcategory": "Brain modeling", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K036", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "EXE-019" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2005, "year_basis": "DATED_DIALOGUE_IN_LATER_REPOST", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "Mid-2020s: reference 2025; sensitivity interval 2024–2026.", "deadline_year": 2025, "precision": "EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR", "year_start": 2025, "year_end": 2025, "interpretation": "Mid-2020s: reference 2025; sensitivity interval 2024–2026." }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Effective functional models cover all major human brain regions and their integrated operation, not just a wiring atlas.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model.", "at_review_rationale": "The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.", "verdict_qualifier": "REFERENCE_DATE_2025", "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model. The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P04", "locator": "Question 7", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N15", "locator": "Mouse cell atlas, not a functional emulation of the entire human brain.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N16", "locator": "Adult fruit-fly connectome. Species, wiring map and functional cognitive model must not be conflated.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N48", "locator": "180 cortical areas per hemisphere; direct evidence of improved regional brain understanding, not whole-brain functional reconstruction.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "The current partial result is robust; only deadline status changes under the generous 2026 endpoint. The reference-year choice is visibly editorial, not presented as an exact original year.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "EXE-019", "relation": "CORRECT_SCOPE_AND_HOLD_DATE" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-026", "relation": "QUARANTINE_GARBLED_COMPOUND" } ] }, "id": "K036", "familyId": "K036", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K036", "category": "Neuroscience & human augmentation", "tags": [ "reverse engineering", "scope", "Brain modeling" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Effective models cover the entire human brain.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Effective models cover the entire human brain.", "successCriteria": "Effective functional models cover all major human brain regions and their integrated operation, not just a wiring atlas.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P04", "title": "So what is the singularity? — Ray Kurzweil Q&A", "publicationYear": 2005, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.writingsbyraykurzweil.com/so-what-is-the-singularity", "locator": "Question 7", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "Mid-2020s: reference 2025; sensitivity interval 2024–2026.", "year": 2025, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N15", "id": "N15-0", "title": "NIH: Complete cell map of a whole mammalian brain", "url": "https://www.nimh.nih.gov/news/science-updates/2023/scientists-unveil-complete-cell-map-of-a-whole-mammalian-brain", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Mouse cell atlas, not a functional emulation of the entire human brain.. Mouse cell atlas, not a functional emulation of the entire human brain." }, { "sourceId": "N16", "id": "N16-1", "title": "Dorkenwald et al.: Neuronal wiring diagram of an adult brain", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07686-5", "publishedAt": "2024-10-02", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Adult fruit-fly connectome. Species, wiring map and functional cognitive model must not be conflated.. Adult fruit-fly connectome. Species, wiring map and functional cognitive model must not be conflated." }, { "sourceId": "N48", "id": "N48-2", "title": "Glasser et al.: A multi-modal parcellation of human cerebral cortex", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/nature18933", "publishedAt": "2016-07-20", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "180 cortical areas per hemisphere; direct evidence of improved regional brain understanding, not whole-brain functional reconstruction.. 180 cortical areas per hemisphere; direct evidence of improved regional brain understanding, not whole-brain functional reconstruction." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model. The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.", "alternativeInterpretation": "The current partial result is robust; only deadline status changes under the generous 2026 endpoint. The reference-year choice is visibly editorial, not presented as an exact original year.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "The current partial result is robust; only deadline status changes under the generous 2026 endpoint. The reference-year choice is visibly editorial, not presented as an exact original year.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. The intake converted a broad modeling claim into a stronger brain-emulation milestone. “Mid-2020s” is not automatically December 2025, particularly in an October 2026 audit. Scope and deadline policy must precede a verdict. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model. The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":true,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Effective functional models cover all major human brain regions and their integrated operation, not just a wiring atlas.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model. The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N15\",\"N16\",\"N48\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2025,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Same functional criterion, but allow the entire mid-2020s window through December 2026.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"At the October 2026 review the latest plausible deadline has not closed; the current outcome is still partial.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"DEADLINE_WINDOW_SENSITIVITY\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N15\",\"N16\",\"N48\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2026,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Effective functional models cover all major human brain regions and their integrated operation, not just a wiring atlas.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model. The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N15\",\"N16\",\"N48\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2025,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The intake converted a broad modeling claim into a stronger brain-emulation milestone. “Mid-2020s” is not automatically December 2025, particularly in an October 2026 audit. Scope and deadline policy must precede a verdict.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K036\",\"slug\":\"k036-effective-models-of-all-brain-regions\",\"title\":\"Effective models of all brain regions\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Effective models cover the entire human brain.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Neuroscience & human augmentation\",\"tags\":[\"reverse engineering\",\"scope\"],\"subcategory\":\"Brain modeling\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K036\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"EXE-019\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2005,\"year_basis\":\"DATED_DIALOGUE_IN_LATER_REPOST\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"Mid-2020s: reference 2025; sensitivity interval 2024–2026.\",\"deadline_year\":2025,\"precision\":\"EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR\",\"year_start\":2025,\"year_end\":2025,\"interpretation\":\"Mid-2020s: reference 2025; sensitivity interval 2024–2026.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Effective functional models cover all major human brain regions and their integrated operation, not just a wiring atlas.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":\"REFERENCE_DATE_2025\",\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Using 2025 as the explicit midpoint of “mid-2020s,” major regional/animal mapping existed but not this complete human functional model. The human cortical parcellation, mouse atlas and fly connectome are genuine partial achievements. They do not establish complete human emulation.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P04\",\"locator\":\"Question 7\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N15\",\"locator\":\"Mouse cell atlas, not a functional emulation of the entire human brain.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N16\",\"locator\":\"Adult fruit-fly connectome. Species, wiring map and functional cognitive model must not be conflated.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N48\",\"locator\":\"180 cortical areas per hemisphere; direct evidence of improved regional brain understanding, not whole-brain functional reconstruction.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"The current partial result is robust; only deadline status changes under the generous 2026 endpoint. The reference-year choice is visibly editorial, not presented as an exact original year.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-019\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_SCOPE_AND_HOLD_DATE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-026\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_GARBLED_COMPOUND\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Unconditional basic income operates generally across developed economies, not just a local trial.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint. Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint.", "at_review_rationale": "Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P06" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2033, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Unconditional basic income operates generally across developed economies, not just a local trial.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint. Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint.", "at_review_rationale": "Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P06" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2033, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Unconditional basic income operates generally across developed economies, not just a local trial.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint. Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint.", "at_review_rationale": "Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P06" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2033, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Future; primary transcript still needed.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K037", "slug": "k037-developed-world-universal-basic-income", "title": "Developed-world universal basic income", "prediction_paraphrase": "UBI across developed economies.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Economy & society", "tags": [ "developed economies" ], "subcategory": "Universal basic income", "claim_type": "SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME", "family_id": "F-UBI", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "DEC-031", "EXE-023" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2018, "year_basis": "SOURCE_PUBLICATION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "REPORTED_EVENT_YEAR" }, "target": { "text": "Early 2030s; reference endpoint 2033, not a newly asserted exact quote.", "deadline_year": 2033, "precision": "EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR", "year_start": 2033, "year_end": 2033, "interpretation": "Early 2030s; reference endpoint 2033, not a newly asserted exact quote." }, "source_verification": { "state": "REPORTED_ATTRIBUTION_ORIGINAL_TRANSCRIPT_NOT_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": false }, "success_criteria": "Unconditional basic income operates generally across developed economies, not just a local trial.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint.", "at_review_rationale": "Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint. Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P06", "locator": "Report of TED remarks", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P06", "locator": "Secondary, contemporaneous attribution of a TED appearance. Original event transcript was not obtained; lower attribution confidence. Not used as technical outcome evidence.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Current policy-progress judgment has medium confidence; no precise global program count or fiscal prediction is asserted.", "open_questions": [], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "DEC-031", "relation": "SPLIT_INDEPENDENT_DEADLINES" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-023", "relation": "SPLIT_INDEPENDENT_DEADLINES" } ] }, "id": "K037", "familyId": "F-UBI", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K037", "category": "Economy & society", "tags": [ "developed economies", "Universal basic income" ], "claimType": "SOCIAL_INSTITUTIONAL", "importedClaim": "UBI across developed economies.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "UBI across developed economies.", "successCriteria": "Unconditional basic income operates generally across developed economies, not just a local trial.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P06", "title": "Ray Kurzweil: Universal basic income will arrive in the 2030s", "publicationYear": 2018, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.axios.com/2018/04/13/ray-kurzweil-universal-basic-income-will-arrive-in-the-2030s-1523655832", "locator": "Report of TED remarks", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "Early 2030s; reference endpoint 2033, not a newly asserted exact quote.", "year": 2033, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P06", "id": "P06-0", "title": "Ray Kurzweil: Universal basic income will arrive in the 2030s", "url": "https://www.axios.com/2018/04/13/ray-kurzweil-universal-basic-income-will-arrive-in-the-2030s-1523655832", "publishedAt": "2018-04-13", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Secondary, contemporaneous attribution of a TED appearance. Original event transcript was not obtained; lower attribution confidence. Not used as technical outcome evidence.. Secondary, contemporaneous attribution of a TED appearance. Original event transcript was not obtained; lower attribution confidence. Not used as technical outcome evidence." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint. Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "Current policy-progress judgment has medium confidence; no precise global program count or fiscal prediction is asserted.", "unresolvedQuestions": [], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. Future; primary transcript still needed. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint. Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Unconditional basic income operates generally across developed economies, not just a local trial.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint. Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P06\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2033,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Unconditional basic income operates generally across developed economies, not just a local trial.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint. Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P06\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2033,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Unconditional basic income operates generally across developed economies, not just a local trial.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint. Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P06\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2033,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Future; primary transcript still needed.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K037\",\"slug\":\"k037-developed-world-universal-basic-income\",\"title\":\"Developed-world universal basic income\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"UBI across developed economies.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Economy & society\",\"tags\":[\"developed economies\"],\"subcategory\":\"Universal basic income\",\"claim_type\":\"SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME\",\"family_id\":\"F-UBI\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"DEC-031\",\"EXE-023\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2018,\"year_basis\":\"SOURCE_PUBLICATION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"REPORTED_EVENT_YEAR\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"Early 2030s; reference endpoint 2033, not a newly asserted exact quote.\",\"deadline_year\":2033,\"precision\":\"EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR\",\"year_start\":2033,\"year_end\":2033,\"interpretation\":\"Early 2030s; reference endpoint 2033, not a newly asserted exact quote.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"REPORTED_ATTRIBUTION_ORIGINAL_TRANSCRIPT_NOT_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":false},\"success_criteria\":\"Unconditional basic income operates generally across developed economies, not just a local trial.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"Early 2030s remains future; use 2033 as an explicit reference endpoint. Pilots and limited programs do not constitute the cross-economy rollout. Attribution rests on contemporaneous reporting rather than a located full primary transcript.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P06\",\"locator\":\"Report of TED remarks\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P06\",\"locator\":\"Secondary, contemporaneous attribution of a TED appearance. Original event transcript was not obtained; lower attribution confidence. Not used as technical outcome evidence.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Current policy-progress judgment has medium confidence; no precise global program count or fiscal prediction is asserted.\",\"open_questions\":[],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-031\",\"relation\":\"SPLIT_INDEPENDENT_DEADLINES\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-023\",\"relation\":\"SPLIT_INDEPENDENT_DEADLINES\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Basic income is implemented worldwide, not merely discussed or piloted.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending. The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending.", "at_review_rationale": "The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P06" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2039, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Basic income is implemented worldwide, not merely discussed or piloted.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending. The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending.", "at_review_rationale": "The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P06" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2039, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Basic income is implemented worldwide, not merely discussed or piloted.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending. The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending.", "at_review_rationale": "The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P06" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2039, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Future; primary transcript still needed.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K038", "slug": "k038-worldwide-universal-basic-income", "title": "Worldwide universal basic income", "prediction_paraphrase": "Worldwide UBI.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Economy & society", "tags": [ "global adoption" ], "subcategory": "Universal basic income", "claim_type": "SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME", "family_id": "F-UBI", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "DEC-031", "EXE-023" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2018, "year_basis": "SOURCE_PUBLICATION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "REPORTED_EVENT_YEAR" }, "target": { "text": "2039", "deadline_year": 2039, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2039, "year_end": 2039, "interpretation": "End of the 2030s interpreted as calendar 2039; source says end of decade." }, "source_verification": { "state": "REPORTED_ATTRIBUTION_ORIGINAL_TRANSCRIPT_NOT_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": false }, "success_criteria": "Basic income is implemented worldwide, not merely discussed or piloted.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending.", "at_review_rationale": "The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending. The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P06", "locator": "Report of TED remarks", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P06", "locator": "Secondary, contemporaneous attribution of a TED appearance. Original event transcript was not obtained; lower attribution confidence. Not used as technical outcome evidence.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "A published forecast sourced through contemporaneous reporting. This is not a financial recommendation or an assertion of universal benefit coverage.", "open_questions": [], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "DEC-031", "relation": "SPLIT_INDEPENDENT_DEADLINES" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-023", "relation": "SPLIT_INDEPENDENT_DEADLINES" } ] }, "id": "K038", "familyId": "F-UBI", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K038", "category": "Economy & society", "tags": [ "global adoption", "Universal basic income" ], "claimType": "SOCIAL_INSTITUTIONAL", "importedClaim": "Worldwide UBI.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Worldwide UBI.", "successCriteria": "Basic income is implemented worldwide, not merely discussed or piloted.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P06", "title": "Ray Kurzweil: Universal basic income will arrive in the 2030s", "publicationYear": 2018, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.axios.com/2018/04/13/ray-kurzweil-universal-basic-income-will-arrive-in-the-2030s-1523655832", "locator": "Report of TED remarks", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2039", "year": 2039, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P06", "id": "P06-0", "title": "Ray Kurzweil: Universal basic income will arrive in the 2030s", "url": "https://www.axios.com/2018/04/13/ray-kurzweil-universal-basic-income-will-arrive-in-the-2030s-1523655832", "publishedAt": "2018-04-13", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Secondary, contemporaneous attribution of a TED appearance. Original event transcript was not obtained; lower attribution confidence. Not used as technical outcome evidence.. Secondary, contemporaneous attribution of a TED appearance. Original event transcript was not obtained; lower attribution confidence. Not used as technical outcome evidence." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending. The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "A published forecast sourced through contemporaneous reporting. This is not a financial recommendation or an assertion of universal benefit coverage.", "unresolvedQuestions": [], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. Future; primary transcript still needed. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending. The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Basic income is implemented worldwide, not merely discussed or piloted.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending. The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P06\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2039,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Basic income is implemented worldwide, not merely discussed or piloted.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending. The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P06\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2039,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Basic income is implemented worldwide, not merely discussed or piloted.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending. The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P06\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2039,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Future; primary transcript still needed.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K038\",\"slug\":\"k038-worldwide-universal-basic-income\",\"title\":\"Worldwide universal basic income\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Worldwide UBI.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Economy & society\",\"tags\":[\"global adoption\"],\"subcategory\":\"Universal basic income\",\"claim_type\":\"SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME\",\"family_id\":\"F-UBI\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"DEC-031\",\"EXE-023\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2018,\"year_basis\":\"SOURCE_PUBLICATION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"REPORTED_EVENT_YEAR\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2039\",\"deadline_year\":2039,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2039,\"year_end\":2039,\"interpretation\":\"End of the 2030s interpreted as calendar 2039; source says end of decade.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"REPORTED_ATTRIBUTION_ORIGINAL_TRANSCRIPT_NOT_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":false},\"success_criteria\":\"Basic income is implemented worldwide, not merely discussed or piloted.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The late-2030s/worldwide forecast is pending. The present evidence supports experimentation, not a worldwide income floor.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P06\",\"locator\":\"Report of TED remarks\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P06\",\"locator\":\"Secondary, contemporaneous attribution of a TED appearance. Original event transcript was not obtained; lower attribution confidence. Not used as technical outcome evidence.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"A published forecast sourced through contemporaneous reporting. This is not a financial recommendation or an assertion of universal benefit coverage.\",\"open_questions\":[],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-031\",\"relation\":\"SPLIT_INDEPENDENT_DEADLINES\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-023\",\"relation\":\"SPLIT_INDEPENDENT_DEADLINES\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Electronic documents support routine nonlinear navigation, linking and interaction.", "at_deadline": "UNDATED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate. The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 1993, "at_deadline_rationale": "No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate.", "at_review_rationale": "The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N36" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": null, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Electronic documents support routine nonlinear navigation, linking and interaction.", "at_deadline": "UNDATED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate. The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 1993, "at_deadline_rationale": "No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate.", "at_review_rationale": "The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N36" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": null, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Electronic documents support routine nonlinear navigation, linking and interaction.", "at_deadline": "UNDATED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate. The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 1993, "at_deadline_rationale": "No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate.", "at_review_rationale": "The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N36" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": null, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 1993, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 1993", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "UNSCORABLE", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The located passage supports the general concept, not the intake’s exact 2000s deadline. An obvious eventual development does not validate an invented forecast date.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K039", "slug": "k039-nonlinear-electronic-documents", "title": "Nonlinear electronic documents", "prediction_paraphrase": "Electronic documents become interactive and nonlinear.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [ "hypertext" ], "subcategory": "Electronic documents", "claim_type": "SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME", "family_id": "K039", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "EXE-005" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1990, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "next century", "deadline_year": null, "precision": "NO_TESTABLE_DEADLINE", "year_start": null, "year_end": null, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Electronic documents support routine nonlinear navigation, linking and interaction.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate.", "at_review_rationale": "The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.", "verdict_qualifier": "UNDATED", "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "UNDATED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate. The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 1993, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "No resolvable deadline; outcome nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Age of Intelligent Machines excerpts, printed pp. 124–126; original-book pp. 428–430", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N36", "locator": "Web invention in 1989 and subsequent 1990s development. Realization is established; this does not prove it was wholly novel to a 1990 forecaster.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Undated does not mean outcome-unassessable. A successful directional forecast can still lack timing credit or novelty.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "EXE-005", "relation": "REMOVE_INVENTED_DEADLINE" } ] }, "id": "K039", "familyId": "K039", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K039", "category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [ "hypertext", "Electronic documents" ], "claimType": "SOCIAL_INSTITUTIONAL", "importedClaim": "Electronic documents become interactive and nonlinear.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Electronic documents become interactive and nonlinear.", "successCriteria": "Electronic documents support routine nonlinear navigation, linking and interaction.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1990, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Age of Intelligent Machines excerpts, printed pp. 124–126; original-book pp. 428–430", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "next century", "year": null, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "UNCONFIRMED" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N36", "id": "N36-0", "title": "CERN: The birth of the Web", "url": "https://home.cern/science/computing/the-birth-of-the-web/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Web invention in 1989 and subsequent 1990s development. Realization is established; this does not prove it was wholly novel to a 1990 forecaster.. Web invention in 1989 and subsequent 1990s development. Realization is established; this does not prove it was wholly novel to a 1990 forecaster." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "UNREVIEWED", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate. The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "No resolvable deadline; outcome nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "Undated does not mean outcome-unassessable. A successful directional forecast can still lack timing credit or novelty.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNSCORABLE. The located passage supports the general concept, not the intake’s exact 2000s deadline. An obvious eventual development does not validate an invented forecast date. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate. The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Electronic documents support routine nonlinear navigation, linking and interaction.\",\"at_deadline\":\"UNDATED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate. The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":1993,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N36\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":null,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Electronic documents support routine nonlinear navigation, linking and interaction.\",\"at_deadline\":\"UNDATED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate. The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":1993,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N36\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":null,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Electronic documents support routine nonlinear navigation, linking and interaction.\",\"at_deadline\":\"UNDATED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate. The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":1993,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N36\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":null,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":1993,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 1993\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"UNSCORABLE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The located passage supports the general concept, not the intake’s exact 2000s deadline. An obvious eventual development does not validate an invented forecast date.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K039\",\"slug\":\"k039-nonlinear-electronic-documents\",\"title\":\"Nonlinear electronic documents\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Electronic documents become interactive and nonlinear.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Media, education & culture\",\"tags\":[\"hypertext\"],\"subcategory\":\"Electronic documents\",\"claim_type\":\"SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME\",\"family_id\":\"K039\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"EXE-005\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1990,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"next century\",\"deadline_year\":null,\"precision\":\"NO_TESTABLE_DEADLINE\",\"year_start\":null,\"year_end\":null,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Electronic documents support routine nonlinear navigation, linking and interaction.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":\"UNDATED\",\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"UNDATED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"No precise deadline is established for this version; do not manufacture an on-time rate. The Web plainly fulfills the functional claim. CERN’s history establishes the 1990s realization; attribution novelty is distinct from whether the outcome occurred.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":1993,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"No resolvable deadline; outcome nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Age of Intelligent Machines excerpts, printed pp. 124–126; original-book pp. 428–430\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N36\",\"locator\":\"Web invention in 1989 and subsequent 1990s development. Realization is established; this does not prove it was wholly novel to a 1990 forecaster.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Undated does not mean outcome-unassessable. A successful directional forecast can still lack timing credit or novelty.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-005\",\"relation\":\"REMOVE_INVENTED_DEADLINE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Information technology makes authoritarian information control harder while also enabling governments to respond.", "at_deadline": "UNDATED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used. Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used.", "at_review_rationale": "Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N37" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": null, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Information technology makes authoritarian information control harder while also enabling governments to respond.", "at_deadline": "UNDATED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used. Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used.", "at_review_rationale": "Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N37" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": null, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Information technology makes authoritarian information control harder while also enabling governments to respond.", "at_deadline": "UNDATED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used. Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used.", "at_review_rationale": "Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N37" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": null, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Undated forecast; current outcome assessed without timing credit", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "UNSCORABLE", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The located passage discusses competing consequences, including stronger state control. The intake turned this into an unconditional historical-event forecast and awarded an easy 1991 hit. That transformation is not supported.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K040", "slug": "k040-information-technology-pressures-authoritarian-control", "title": "Information technology pressures authoritarian control", "prediction_paraphrase": "Information technology creates a dilemma for authoritarian control.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Economy & society", "tags": [ "authoritarian control", "conditional claim" ], "subcategory": "Political institutions", "claim_type": "SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME", "family_id": "K040", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-003", "DEC-002" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1990, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "conditional / no fixed deadline", "deadline_year": null, "precision": "CONDITIONAL", "year_start": null, "year_end": null, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Information technology makes authoritarian information control harder while also enabling governments to respond.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used.", "at_review_rationale": "Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.", "verdict_qualifier": "UNDATED", "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "UNDATED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used. Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "No resolvable deadline; outcome nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Age of Intelligent Machines excerpts, printed pp. 127–128; original-book pp. 445–447", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N37", "locator": "Original research on freedom online; supports a mixed information-access/control story, not a causal attribution of the Soviet collapse.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Mixed outcome, not a claim that technology caused the Soviet collapse. Causal attribution is weaker than the observed access/control tension.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-003", "relation": "CORRECT_SCOPE" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-002", "relation": "CORRECT_SCOPE" } ] }, "id": "K040", "familyId": "K040", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K040", "category": "Economy & society", "tags": [ "authoritarian control", "conditional claim", "Political institutions" ], "claimType": "SOCIAL_INSTITUTIONAL", "importedClaim": "Information technology creates a dilemma for authoritarian control.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Information technology creates a dilemma for authoritarian control.", "successCriteria": "Information technology makes authoritarian information control harder while also enabling governments to respond.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1990, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Age of Intelligent Machines excerpts, printed pp. 127–128; original-book pp. 445–447", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "conditional / no fixed deadline", "year": null, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "UNCONFIRMED" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N37", "id": "N37-0", "title": "Freedom House: Freedom on the Net 2025", "url": "https://freedomhouse.org/article/new-report-persistent-authoritarian-repression-and-backsliding-democracies-drive-15th", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Original research on freedom online; supports a mixed information-access/control story, not a causal attribution of the Soviet collapse.. Original research on freedom online; supports a mixed information-access/control story, not a causal attribution of the Soviet collapse." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "UNREVIEWED", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": false, "rationale": "This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used. Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "No resolvable deadline; outcome nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "Mixed outcome, not a claim that technology caused the Soviet collapse. Causal attribution is weaker than the observed access/control tension.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNSCORABLE. The located passage discusses competing consequences, including stronger state control. The intake turned this into an unconditional historical-event forecast and awarded an easy 1991 hit. That transformation is not supported. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used. Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Information technology makes authoritarian information control harder while also enabling governments to respond.\",\"at_deadline\":\"UNDATED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used. Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N37\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":null,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Information technology makes authoritarian information control harder while also enabling governments to respond.\",\"at_deadline\":\"UNDATED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used. Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N37\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":null,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Information technology makes authoritarian information control harder while also enabling governments to respond.\",\"at_deadline\":\"UNDATED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used. Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N37\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":null,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Undated forecast; current outcome assessed without timing credit\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"UNSCORABLE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The located passage discusses competing consequences, including stronger state control. The intake turned this into an unconditional historical-event forecast and awarded an easy 1991 hit. That transformation is not supported.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K040\",\"slug\":\"k040-information-technology-pressures-authoritarian-control\",\"title\":\"Information technology pressures authoritarian control\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Information technology creates a dilemma for authoritarian control.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Economy & society\",\"tags\":[\"authoritarian control\",\"conditional claim\"],\"subcategory\":\"Political institutions\",\"claim_type\":\"SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME\",\"family_id\":\"K040\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-003\",\"DEC-002\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1990,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"conditional / no fixed deadline\",\"deadline_year\":null,\"precision\":\"CONDITIONAL\",\"year_start\":null,\"year_end\":null,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Information technology makes authoritarian information control harder while also enabling governments to respond.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":\"UNDATED\",\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"UNDATED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"This is a conditional, undated societal forecast; no invented 1991 deadline is used. Global information access creates real pressures, but digital repression and persistent authoritarian control prevent a simple democracy-caused-by-technology verdict.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"No resolvable deadline; outcome nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Age of Intelligent Machines excerpts, printed pp. 127–128; original-book pp. 445–447\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N37\",\"locator\":\"Original research on freedom online; supports a mixed information-access/control story, not a causal attribution of the Soviet collapse.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Mixed outcome, not a claim that technology caused the Soviet collapse. Causal attribution is weaker than the observed access/control tension.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-003\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_SCOPE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-002\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_SCOPE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Common wearable monitors identify selected acute and chronic problems and trigger useful advice or intervention pathways.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption. Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption.", "at_review_rationale": "Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O22", "N25", "N01" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Common wearable monitors identify selected acute and chronic problems and trigger useful advice or intervention pathways.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption. Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "SAME_AS_REFERENCE", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption.", "at_review_rationale": "Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O22", "N25", "N01" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Common wearable monitors identify selected acute and chronic problems and trigger useful advice or intervention pathways.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption. Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption.", "at_review_rationale": "Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O22", "N25", "N01" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "non_scoring_comparators": [ { "criterion": "Wearables independently make definitive clinical diagnoses across acute/chronic conditions and directly administer treatment.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "rationale": "Risk flags and emergency escalation are not equivalent to broad standalone diagnosis plus treatment. The stronger clinical reading remains partial.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "same_as_reference": false, "evidence_source_ids": [ "O22", "N25", "N01" ], "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "eligible_for_author_accuracy": false, "comparator_warning": "Stronger than the located wording; not an obligation of the original forecast and excluded from accuracy calculations." } ], "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2019, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2019", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "PARTIAL", "at_review": "FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Apple released wrist ECG and irregular-rhythm alerts in 2018. Its documentation lists important conditions those features cannot detect. This establishes a meaningful but limited part of the broad diagnostic/intervention claim.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K041", "slug": "k041-wearable-diagnosis-and-health-intervention", "title": "Wearable diagnosis and health intervention", "prediction_paraphrase": "Wearables commonly diagnose conditions and support intervention.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Biology & medicine", "tags": [ "wearables", "diagnosis", "intervention" ], "subcategory": "Digital health", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K041", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "CONFIRMED_RELATED_VERSION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Common wearable monitors identify selected acute and chronic problems and trigger useful advice or intervention pathways.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption.", "at_review_rationale": "Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption. Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2019, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Health care in 2019: computerized monitors", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O22", "locator": "AFib-related features are limited-purpose. The release expressly lists conditions they cannot detect; not general diagnosis or autonomous treatment.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N25", "locator": "ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; ECG deployment corroborated by December 2018 release O22. Not diagnosis of all diseases or autonomous treatment.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N01", "locator": "June 2019 US survey: 21% regularly wear one. Common does not mean majority, and US adult prevalence is not global prevalence.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "This is an audit, not medical advice. ECG classification is not universal diagnosis; false results and the need for clinical interpretation remain. “Intervention” includes automated emergency escalation.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-029", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" } ] }, "id": "K041", "familyId": "K041", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K041", "category": "Biology & medicine", "tags": [ "wearables", "diagnosis", "intervention", "Digital health" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Wearables commonly diagnose conditions and support intervention.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Wearables commonly diagnose conditions and support intervention.", "successCriteria": "Common wearable monitors identify selected acute and chronic problems and trigger useful advice or intervention pathways.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Health care in 2019: computerized monitors", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O22", "id": "O22-0", "title": "ECG app and irregular rhythm notification available on Apple Watch", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2018/12/ecg-app-and-irregular-heart-rhythm-notification-available-today-on-apple-watch/", "publishedAt": "2018-12-06", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "AFib-related features are limited-purpose. The release expressly lists conditions they cannot detect; not general diagnosis or autonomous treatment.. AFib-related features are limited-purpose. The release expressly lists conditions they cannot detect; not general diagnosis or autonomous treatment." }, { "sourceId": "N25", "id": "N25-1", "title": "Apple: Watch Series 4 health, ECG and fall detection", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2018/09/redesigned-apple-watch-series-4-revolutionizes-communication-fitness-and-health/", "publishedAt": "2018-09-12", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; ECG deployment corroborated by December 2018 release O22. Not diagnosis of all diseases or autonomous treatment.. ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; ECG deployment corroborated by December 2018 release O22. Not diagnosis of all diseases or autonomous treatment." }, { "sourceId": "N01", "id": "N01-2", "title": "Pew: About one-in-five Americans use a smartwatch or fitness tracker", "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2020/01/09/about-one-in-five-americans-use-a-smart-watch-or-fitness-tracker/", "publishedAt": "2020-01-09", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "June 2019 US survey: 21% regularly wear one. Common does not mean majority, and US adult prevalence is not global prevalence.. June 2019 US survey: 21% regularly wear one. Common does not mean majority, and US adult prevalence is not global prevalence." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption. Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.", "alternativeInterpretation": "This is an audit, not medical advice. ECG classification is not universal diagnosis; false results and the need for clinical interpretation remain. “Intervention” includes automated emergency escalation.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "This is an audit, not medical advice. ECG classification is not universal diagnosis; false results and the need for clinical interpretation remain. “Intervention” includes automated emergency escalation.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PARTIAL. Apple released wrist ECG and irregular-rhythm alerts in 2018. Its documentation lists important conditions those features cannot detect. This establishes a meaningful but limited part of the broad diagnostic/intervention claim. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption. Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Common wearable monitors identify selected acute and chronic problems and trigger useful advice or intervention pathways.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption. Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O22\",\"N25\",\"N01\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Common wearable monitors identify selected acute and chronic problems and trigger useful advice or intervention pathways.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption. Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"SAME_AS_REFERENCE\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O22\",\"N25\",\"N01\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Common wearable monitors identify selected acute and chronic problems and trigger useful advice or intervention pathways.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption. Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O22\",\"N25\",\"N01\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"non_scoring_comparators\":[{\"criterion\":\"Wearables independently make definitive clinical diagnoses across acute/chronic conditions and directly administer treatment.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"rationale\":\"Risk flags and emergency escalation are not equivalent to broad standalone diagnosis plus treatment. The stronger clinical reading remains partial.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"same_as_reference\":false,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O22\",\"N25\",\"N01\"],\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"eligible_for_author_accuracy\":false,\"comparator_warning\":\"Stronger than the located wording; not an obligation of the original forecast and excluded from accuracy calculations.\"}],\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2019\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTIAL\",\"at_review\":\"FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Apple released wrist ECG and irregular-rhythm alerts in 2018. Its documentation lists important conditions those features cannot detect. This establishes a meaningful but limited part of the broad diagnostic/intervention claim.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K041\",\"slug\":\"k041-wearable-diagnosis-and-health-intervention\",\"title\":\"Wearable diagnosis and health intervention\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Wearables commonly diagnose conditions and support intervention.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Biology & medicine\",\"tags\":[\"wearables\",\"diagnosis\",\"intervention\"],\"subcategory\":\"Digital health\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K041\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"CONFIRMED_RELATED_VERSION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Common wearable monitors identify selected acute and chronic problems and trigger useful advice or intervention pathways.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"By late 2018 Apple Watch combined ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; the 2019 wearable survey supports common adoption. Those capabilities satisfy a reasonable targeted-condition reading. The forecast did not demand diagnosis of every disease or removal of physicians.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2019,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Health care in 2019: computerized monitors\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O22\",\"locator\":\"AFib-related features are limited-purpose. The release expressly lists conditions they cannot detect; not general diagnosis or autonomous treatment.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N25\",\"locator\":\"ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; ECG deployment corroborated by December 2018 release O22. Not diagnosis of all diseases or autonomous treatment.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N01\",\"locator\":\"June 2019 US survey: 21% regularly wear one. Common does not mean majority, and US adult prevalence is not global prevalence.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"This is an audit, not medical advice. ECG classification is not universal diagnosis; false results and the need for clinical interpretation remain. “Intervention” includes automated emergency escalation.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-029\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Medical progress adds at least one year of remaining healthy life per calendar year for the relevant people.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The stated 2029 date remains future. Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The stated 2029 date remains future.", "at_review_rationale": "Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P05", "O17", "N40" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Medical progress adds at least one year of remaining healthy life per calendar year for the relevant people.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The stated 2029 date remains future. Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The stated 2029 date remains future.", "at_review_rationale": "Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P05", "O17", "N40" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Medical progress adds at least one year of remaining healthy life per calendar year for the relevant people.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The stated 2029 date remains future. Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The stated 2029 date remains future.", "at_review_rationale": "Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P05", "O17", "N40" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The dated interview makes this a 2029 prediction. It does not imply a first 150-year-old or average lifespan of 150 in 2050.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K042", "slug": "k042-longevity-escape-velocity", "title": "Longevity escape velocity", "prediction_paraphrase": "Medical progress adds at least a year of remaining life annually.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Longevity", "tags": [ "remaining life expectancy" ], "subcategory": "Longevity escape velocity", "claim_type": "SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME", "family_id": "F-LONGEVITY-ESCAPE", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "ADDED_PRIMARY_SOURCE", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2024, "year_basis": "SOURCE_PUBLICATION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2029", "deadline_year": 2029, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2029, "year_end": 2029, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": false }, "success_criteria": "Medical progress adds at least one year of remaining healthy life per calendar year for the relevant people.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The stated 2029 date remains future.", "at_review_rationale": "Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The stated 2029 date remains future. Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P05", "locator": "36:56, Longevity escape velocity", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P05", "locator": "Bessemer hosts the interview and timestamped transcript. Do not attribute interviewer comments to Kurzweil. The Q&A section is explicitly summarized; cited passages below are in the main transcript.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O17", "locator": "Final US period life expectancy for 2024: 79.0 years. Do not call this a 2026 observation.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N40", "locator": "Expanded 12-hallmark framework. Shows progress and continued open mechanisms, not a complete model of human lifespan.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Period life-expectancy rebound after a pandemic is not a measurement of sustained escape velocity. Access and cohort definitions must be retained.", "open_questions": [], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "DEC-032", "relation": "QUARANTINE_UNSUPPORTED_INFERENCE" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-029", "relation": "QUARANTINE_UNSUPPORTED_INFERENCE" } ] }, "id": "K042", "familyId": "F-LONGEVITY-ESCAPE", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K042", "category": "Longevity", "tags": [ "remaining life expectancy", "Longevity escape velocity" ], "claimType": "SOCIAL_INSTITUTIONAL", "importedClaim": "Medical progress adds at least a year of remaining life annually.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Medical progress adds at least a year of remaining life annually.", "successCriteria": "Medical progress adds at least one year of remaining healthy life per calendar year for the relevant people.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P05", "title": "AI escape velocity: A conversation with Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 2024, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.bvp.com/atlas/ai-escape-velocity-a-conversation-with-ray-kurzweil", "locator": "36:56, Longevity escape velocity", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2029", "year": 2029, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P05", "id": "P05-0", "title": "AI escape velocity: A conversation with Ray Kurzweil", "url": "https://www.bvp.com/atlas/ai-escape-velocity-a-conversation-with-ray-kurzweil", "publishedAt": "2024-03-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Bessemer hosts the interview and timestamped transcript. Do not attribute interviewer comments to Kurzweil. The Q&A section is explicitly summarized; cited passages below are in the main transcript.. Bessemer hosts the interview and timestamped transcript. Do not attribute interviewer comments to Kurzweil. The Q&A section is explicitly summarized; cited passages below are in the main transcript." }, { "sourceId": "O17", "id": "O17-1", "title": "Mortality in the United States, 2024 — CDC Data Brief 548", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db548.htm", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Final US period life expectancy for 2024: 79.0 years. Do not call this a 2026 observation.. Final US period life expectancy for 2024: 79.0 years. Do not call this a 2026 observation." }, { "sourceId": "N40", "id": "N40-2", "title": "López-Otín et al.: Hallmarks of aging, an expanding universe", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36599349/", "publishedAt": "2023-01-19", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Expanded 12-hallmark framework. Shows progress and continued open mechanisms, not a complete model of human lifespan.. Expanded 12-hallmark framework. Shows progress and continued open mechanisms, not a complete model of human lifespan." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The stated 2029 date remains future. Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "Period life-expectancy rebound after a pandemic is not a measurement of sustained escape velocity. Access and cohort definitions must be retained.", "unresolvedQuestions": [], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. The dated interview makes this a 2029 prediction. It does not imply a first 150-year-old or average lifespan of 150 in 2050. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. The stated 2029 date remains future. Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Medical progress adds at least one year of remaining healthy life per calendar year for the relevant people.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The stated 2029 date remains future. Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The stated 2029 date remains future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P05\",\"O17\",\"N40\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Medical progress adds at least one year of remaining healthy life per calendar year for the relevant people.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The stated 2029 date remains future. Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The stated 2029 date remains future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P05\",\"O17\",\"N40\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Medical progress adds at least one year of remaining healthy life per calendar year for the relevant people.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The stated 2029 date remains future. Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The stated 2029 date remains future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P05\",\"O17\",\"N40\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The dated interview makes this a 2029 prediction. It does not imply a first 150-year-old or average lifespan of 150 in 2050.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K042\",\"slug\":\"k042-longevity-escape-velocity\",\"title\":\"Longevity escape velocity\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Medical progress adds at least a year of remaining life annually.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Longevity\",\"tags\":[\"remaining life expectancy\"],\"subcategory\":\"Longevity escape velocity\",\"claim_type\":\"SOCIAL_OR_POPULATION_OUTCOME\",\"family_id\":\"F-LONGEVITY-ESCAPE\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"ADDED_PRIMARY_SOURCE\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2024,\"year_basis\":\"SOURCE_PUBLICATION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2029\",\"deadline_year\":2029,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2029,\"year_end\":2029,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":false},\"success_criteria\":\"Medical progress adds at least one year of remaining healthy life per calendar year for the relevant people.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The stated 2029 date remains future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The stated 2029 date remains future. Medical gains and changing period life expectancy do not demonstrate sustained longevity escape velocity. Current progress is partial, not evidence that the threshold was crossed.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P05\",\"locator\":\"36:56, Longevity escape velocity\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P05\",\"locator\":\"Bessemer hosts the interview and timestamped transcript. Do not attribute interviewer comments to Kurzweil. The Q&A section is explicitly summarized; cited passages below are in the main transcript.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O17\",\"locator\":\"Final US period life expectancy for 2024: 79.0 years. Do not call this a 2026 observation.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N40\",\"locator\":\"Expanded 12-hallmark framework. Shows progress and continued open mechanisms, not a complete model of human lifespan.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Period life-expectancy rebound after a pandemic is not a measurement of sustained escape velocity. Access and cohort definitions must be retained.\",\"open_questions\":[],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-032\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_UNSUPPORTED_INFERENCE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-029\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_UNSUPPORTED_INFERENCE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "A high-bandwidth direct neural connection integrates a person’s neocortex with cloud AI.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033. Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033.", "at_review_rationale": "Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P05", "O23" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2033, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "A high-bandwidth direct neural connection integrates a person’s neocortex with cloud AI.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033. Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033.", "at_review_rationale": "Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P05", "O23" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2033, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "A high-bandwidth direct neural connection integrates a person’s neocortex with cloud AI.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033. Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033.", "at_review_rationale": "Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P05", "O23" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2033, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The interview provides a dated, attributable version. It must not be backdated to the intake’s alleged 2008 appearance or expanded into completed mind uploading.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K043", "slug": "k043-brain-to-cloud-cognitive-integration", "title": "Brain-to-cloud cognitive integration", "prediction_paraphrase": "High-bandwidth brain links connect cognition to cloud computation.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Neuroscience & human augmentation", "tags": [ "cognitive augmentation" ], "subcategory": "Brain/cloud integration", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "F-BRAIN-INTERFACE", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "CONFIRMED_RELATED_VERSION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2024, "year_basis": "SOURCE_PUBLICATION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "Early 2030s in March 2024 interview; reference endpoint 2033.", "deadline_year": 2033, "precision": "EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR", "year_start": 2033, "year_end": 2033, "interpretation": "Early 2030s in March 2024 interview; reference endpoint 2033." }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": false }, "success_criteria": "A high-bandwidth direct neural connection integrates a person’s neocortex with cloud AI.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033.", "at_review_rationale": "Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033. Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P05", "locator": "30:57, Humans merging with AI", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P05", "locator": "Bessemer hosts the interview and timestamped transcript. Do not attribute interviewer comments to Kurzweil. The Q&A section is explicitly summarized; cited passages below are in the main transcript.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O23", "locator": "Cochlear implants do not restore normal hearing. Used to correct a medical error in our intake, not to manufacture a Kurzweil forecast.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "The source expressly distinguishes therapeutic low-bandwidth interfaces from the proposed cognitive link.", "open_questions": [], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "DEC-029", "relation": "QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_OR_UNLOCATED" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-030", "relation": "QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_OR_UNLOCATED" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-030", "relation": "QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_OR_UNLOCATED" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-021", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" } ] }, "id": "K043", "familyId": "F-BRAIN-INTERFACE", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K043", "category": "Neuroscience & human augmentation", "tags": [ "cognitive augmentation", "Brain/cloud integration" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "High-bandwidth brain links connect cognition to cloud computation.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "High-bandwidth brain links connect cognition to cloud computation.", "successCriteria": "A high-bandwidth direct neural connection integrates a person’s neocortex with cloud AI.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P05", "title": "AI escape velocity: A conversation with Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 2024, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.bvp.com/atlas/ai-escape-velocity-a-conversation-with-ray-kurzweil", "locator": "30:57, Humans merging with AI", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "Early 2030s in March 2024 interview; reference endpoint 2033.", "year": 2033, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P05", "id": "P05-0", "title": "AI escape velocity: A conversation with Ray Kurzweil", "url": "https://www.bvp.com/atlas/ai-escape-velocity-a-conversation-with-ray-kurzweil", "publishedAt": "2024-03-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Bessemer hosts the interview and timestamped transcript. Do not attribute interviewer comments to Kurzweil. The Q&A section is explicitly summarized; cited passages below are in the main transcript.. Bessemer hosts the interview and timestamped transcript. Do not attribute interviewer comments to Kurzweil. The Q&A section is explicitly summarized; cited passages below are in the main transcript." }, { "sourceId": "O23", "id": "O23-1", "title": "What educators need to know about cochlear implants — FDA", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/cochlear-implants/what-educators-need-know", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Cochlear implants do not restore normal hearing. Used to correct a medical error in our intake, not to manufacture a Kurzweil forecast.. Cochlear implants do not restore normal hearing. Used to correct a medical error in our intake, not to manufacture a Kurzweil forecast." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033. Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "The source expressly distinguishes therapeutic low-bandwidth interfaces from the proposed cognitive link.", "unresolvedQuestions": [], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. The interview provides a dated, attributable version. It must not be backdated to the intake’s alleged 2008 appearance or expanded into completed mind uploading. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033. Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"A high-bandwidth direct neural connection integrates a person’s neocortex with cloud AI.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033. Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P05\",\"O23\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2033,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"A high-bandwidth direct neural connection integrates a person’s neocortex with cloud AI.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033. Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P05\",\"O23\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2033,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"A high-bandwidth direct neural connection integrates a person’s neocortex with cloud AI.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033. Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P05\",\"O23\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2033,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The interview provides a dated, attributable version. It must not be backdated to the intake’s alleged 2008 appearance or expanded into completed mind uploading.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K043\",\"slug\":\"k043-brain-to-cloud-cognitive-integration\",\"title\":\"Brain-to-cloud cognitive integration\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"High-bandwidth brain links connect cognition to cloud computation.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Neuroscience & human augmentation\",\"tags\":[\"cognitive augmentation\"],\"subcategory\":\"Brain/cloud integration\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"F-BRAIN-INTERFACE\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"CONFIRMED_RELATED_VERSION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2024,\"year_basis\":\"SOURCE_PUBLICATION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"Early 2030s in March 2024 interview; reference endpoint 2033.\",\"deadline_year\":2033,\"precision\":\"EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR\",\"year_start\":2033,\"year_end\":2033,\"interpretation\":\"Early 2030s in March 2024 interview; reference endpoint 2033.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":false},\"success_criteria\":\"A high-bandwidth direct neural connection integrates a person’s neocortex with cloud AI.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"Early 2030s is not due; the reference endpoint is 2033. Sensory-interface research is real, but phones and ordinary AI use do not satisfy a direct high-bandwidth neocortex-cloud connection.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P05\",\"locator\":\"30:57, Humans merging with AI\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P05\",\"locator\":\"Bessemer hosts the interview and timestamped transcript. Do not attribute interviewer comments to Kurzweil. The Q&A section is explicitly summarized; cited passages below are in the main transcript.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O23\",\"locator\":\"Cochlear implants do not restore normal hearing. Used to correct a medical error in our intake, not to manufacture a Kurzweil forecast.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"The source expressly distinguishes therapeutic low-bandwidth interfaces from the proposed cognitive link.\",\"open_questions\":[],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-029\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_OR_UNLOCATED\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-030\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_OR_UNLOCATED\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-030\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_OR_UNLOCATED\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-021\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Renewable generation supplies all global electricity demand within ten years of the 2024 interview.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending. IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending.", "at_review_rationale": "IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P05", "N58" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2034, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Renewable generation supplies all global electricity demand within ten years of the 2024 interview.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending. IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending.", "at_review_rationale": "IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P05", "N58" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2034, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Renewable generation supplies all global electricity demand within ten years of the 2024 interview.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending. IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending.", "at_review_rationale": "IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P05", "N58" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2034, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "A later, related projection is documented. Scope changes prevent treating it as a simple revised deadline for the 2008 all-energy solar forecast.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K044", "slug": "k044-renewable-electricity-reaches-the-full-demand-threshold", "title": "Renewable electricity reaches the full-demand threshold", "prediction_paraphrase": "Renewables cross the full electricity-demand threshold.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Energy & environment", "tags": [ "generation", "energy accounting" ], "subcategory": "Renewable electricity", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "F-RENEWABLE-ENERGY", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "ADDED_PRIMARY_SOURCE", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2024, "year_basis": "SOURCE_PUBLICATION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "Within ten years of March 2024: reference 2034.", "deadline_year": 2034, "precision": "EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR", "year_start": 2034, "year_end": 2034, "interpretation": "Within ten years of March 2024: reference 2034." }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": false }, "success_criteria": "Renewable generation supplies all global electricity demand within ten years of the 2024 interview.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending.", "at_review_rationale": "IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending. IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P05", "locator": "14:17, Dynamics of exponential growth", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P05", "locator": "Bessemer hosts the interview and timestamped transcript. Do not attribute interviewer comments to Kurzweil. The Q&A section is explicitly summarized; cited passages below are in the main transcript.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N58", "locator": "2025 generation: renewables 34%, coal 34%, natural gas 21%. Capacity and generation are not interchangeable.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "This is electricity, unlike the separate all-energy solar forecast. Do not replace delivered generation with installed capacity.", "open_questions": [], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K044", "familyId": "F-RENEWABLE-ENERGY", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K044", "category": "Energy & environment", "tags": [ "generation", "energy accounting", "Renewable electricity" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Renewables cross the full electricity-demand threshold.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Renewables cross the full electricity-demand threshold.", "successCriteria": "Renewable generation supplies all global electricity demand within ten years of the 2024 interview.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P05", "title": "AI escape velocity: A conversation with Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 2024, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.bvp.com/atlas/ai-escape-velocity-a-conversation-with-ray-kurzweil", "locator": "14:17, Dynamics of exponential growth", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "Within ten years of March 2024: reference 2034.", "year": 2034, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P05", "id": "P05-0", "title": "AI escape velocity: A conversation with Ray Kurzweil", "url": "https://www.bvp.com/atlas/ai-escape-velocity-a-conversation-with-ray-kurzweil", "publishedAt": "2024-03-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Bessemer hosts the interview and timestamped transcript. Do not attribute interviewer comments to Kurzweil. The Q&A section is explicitly summarized; cited passages below are in the main transcript.. Bessemer hosts the interview and timestamped transcript. Do not attribute interviewer comments to Kurzweil. The Q&A section is explicitly summarized; cited passages below are in the main transcript." }, { "sourceId": "N58", "id": "N58-1", "title": "IEA: Global Energy Review 2026, electricity supply", "url": "https://www.iea.org/reports/global-energy-review-2026/electricity-supply", "publishedAt": "2026-04-20", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "2025 generation: renewables 34%, coal 34%, natural gas 21%. Capacity and generation are not interchangeable.. 2025 generation: renewables 34%, coal 34%, natural gas 21%. Capacity and generation are not interchangeable." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending. IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "This is electricity, unlike the separate all-energy solar forecast. Do not replace delivered generation with installed capacity.", "unresolvedQuestions": [], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. A later, related projection is documented. Scope changes prevent treating it as a simple revised deadline for the 2008 all-energy solar forecast. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending. IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Renewable generation supplies all global electricity demand within ten years of the 2024 interview.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending. IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P05\",\"N58\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2034,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Renewable generation supplies all global electricity demand within ten years of the 2024 interview.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending. IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P05\",\"N58\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2034,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Renewable generation supplies all global electricity demand within ten years of the 2024 interview.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending. IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P05\",\"N58\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2034,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"A later, related projection is documented. Scope changes prevent treating it as a simple revised deadline for the 2008 all-energy solar forecast.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K044\",\"slug\":\"k044-renewable-electricity-reaches-the-full-demand-threshold\",\"title\":\"Renewable electricity reaches the full-demand threshold\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Renewables cross the full electricity-demand threshold.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Energy & environment\",\"tags\":[\"generation\",\"energy accounting\"],\"subcategory\":\"Renewable electricity\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"F-RENEWABLE-ENERGY\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"ADDED_PRIMARY_SOURCE\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2024,\"year_basis\":\"SOURCE_PUBLICATION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"Within ten years of March 2024: reference 2034.\",\"deadline_year\":2034,\"precision\":\"EDITORIAL_REFERENCE_YEAR\",\"year_start\":2034,\"year_end\":2034,\"interpretation\":\"Within ten years of March 2024: reference 2034.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":false},\"success_criteria\":\"Renewable generation supplies all global electricity demand within ten years of the 2024 interview.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The interview implies a 2034 deadline, still pending. IEA places renewables at 34% of 2025 world electricity generation. This is substantial progress but not 100%.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P05\",\"locator\":\"14:17, Dynamics of exponential growth\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P05\",\"locator\":\"Bessemer hosts the interview and timestamped transcript. Do not attribute interviewer comments to Kurzweil. The Q&A section is explicitly summarized; cited passages below are in the main transcript.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N58\",\"locator\":\"2025 generation: renewables 34%, coal 34%, natural gas 21%. Capacity and generation are not interchangeable.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"This is electricity, unlike the separate all-energy solar forecast. Do not replace delivered generation with installed capacity.\",\"open_questions\":[],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "AI achieves general human-level intellectual competence under an explicitly demanding broad-capability reading.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 target is pending. Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 target is pending.", "at_review_rationale": "Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P04", "O21" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "AI achieves general human-level intellectual competence under an explicitly demanding broad-capability reading.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 target is pending. Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 target is pending.", "at_review_rationale": "Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P04", "O21" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Human-like conversational performance on a controlled short Turing-style test.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2025 study supports early success on this narrower conversational definition.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "General competence narrowed to short conversational imitation" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2025, "evidence_source_ids": [ "P04", "O21" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "A dated author Q&A supports the general target. Experimental conversational imitation is relevant progress, not automatic proof of the full general-intelligence claim.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K045", "slug": "k045-human-level-ai-by-the-end-of-the-2020s", "title": "Human-level AI by the end of the 2020s", "prediction_paraphrase": "Hardware and software achieve human-level intelligence.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "Turing test", "human-level AI" ], "subcategory": "General intelligence", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "F-TURING", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "AUD-024", "DEC-027", "EXE-020" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 2005, "year_basis": "DATED_DIALOGUE_IN_LATER_REPOST", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2029", "deadline_year": 2029, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2029, "year_end": 2029, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "AI achieves general human-level intellectual competence under an explicitly demanding broad-capability reading.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 target is pending.", "at_review_rationale": "Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The 2029 target is pending. Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P04", "locator": "Question 20", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P04", "locator": "Page identifies the dialogue as 2005. Store dialogue year 2005 separately from archive publication date 2011. Not a checked scan of the 2005 book.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O21", "locator": "Five-minute experimental protocol. GPT-4.5 with a humanlike persona was judged human in 73% of the reported comparisons. Not the two-hour Long Bets protocol.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Keep this general forecast distinct from the exact Long Bets protocol. Broader conversational fulfillment is not labeled proof of AGI.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-024", "relation": "LINK_FAMILY_NOT_EXACT_DUPLICATE" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-027", "relation": "LINK_FAMILY_NOT_EXACT_DUPLICATE" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-020", "relation": "LINK_FAMILY_NOT_EXACT_DUPLICATE" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-011", "relation": "QUARANTINE_AND_SPLIT_REQUIRED" } ] }, "id": "K045", "familyId": "F-TURING", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K045", "category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "Turing test", "human-level AI", "General intelligence" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Hardware and software achieve human-level intelligence.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Hardware and software achieve human-level intelligence.", "successCriteria": "AI achieves general human-level intellectual competence under an explicitly demanding broad-capability reading.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P04", "title": "So what is the singularity? — Ray Kurzweil Q&A", "publicationYear": 2005, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.writingsbyraykurzweil.com/so-what-is-the-singularity", "locator": "Question 20", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2029", "year": 2029, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P04", "id": "P04-0", "title": "So what is the singularity? — Ray Kurzweil Q&A", "url": "https://www.writingsbyraykurzweil.com/so-what-is-the-singularity", "publishedAt": "2011-01-01", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Page identifies the dialogue as 2005. Store dialogue year 2005 separately from archive publication date 2011. Not a checked scan of the 2005 book.. Page identifies the dialogue as 2005. Store dialogue year 2005 separately from archive publication date 2011. Not a checked scan of the 2005 book." }, { "sourceId": "O21", "id": "O21-1", "title": "Large Language Models Pass the Turing Test — Jones and Bergen", "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.23674", "publishedAt": "2025-03-31", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Five-minute experimental protocol. GPT-4.5 with a humanlike persona was judged human in 73% of the reported comparisons. Not the two-hour Long Bets protocol.. Five-minute experimental protocol. GPT-4.5 with a humanlike persona was judged human in 73% of the reported comparisons. Not the two-hour Long Bets protocol." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "The 2029 target is pending. Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Keep this general forecast distinct from the exact Long Bets protocol. Broader conversational fulfillment is not labeled proof of AGI.", "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "Keep this general forecast distinct from the exact Long Bets protocol. Broader conversational fulfillment is not labeled proof of AGI.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. A dated author Q&A supports the general target. Experimental conversational imitation is relevant progress, not automatic proof of the full general-intelligence claim. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. The 2029 target is pending. Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"AI achieves general human-level intellectual competence under an explicitly demanding broad-capability reading.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 target is pending. Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 target is pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P04\",\"O21\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"AI achieves general human-level intellectual competence under an explicitly demanding broad-capability reading.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 target is pending. Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 target is pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P04\",\"O21\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Human-like conversational performance on a controlled short Turing-style test.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2025 study supports early success on this narrower conversational definition.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"General competence narrowed to short conversational imitation\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2025,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P04\",\"O21\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"A dated author Q&A supports the general target. Experimental conversational imitation is relevant progress, not automatic proof of the full general-intelligence claim.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K045\",\"slug\":\"k045-human-level-ai-by-the-end-of-the-2020s\",\"title\":\"Human-level AI by the end of the 2020s\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Hardware and software achieve human-level intelligence.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"AI & software\",\"tags\":[\"Turing test\",\"human-level AI\"],\"subcategory\":\"General intelligence\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"F-TURING\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"AUD-024\",\"DEC-027\",\"EXE-020\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":2005,\"year_basis\":\"DATED_DIALOGUE_IN_LATER_REPOST\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2029\",\"deadline_year\":2029,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2029,\"year_end\":2029,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"AI achieves general human-level intellectual competence under an explicitly demanding broad-capability reading.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 target is pending.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The 2029 target is pending. Strong language and benchmark performance provides major partial progress; a short imitation game does not establish the complete general-intelligence claim.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P04\",\"locator\":\"Question 20\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P04\",\"locator\":\"Page identifies the dialogue as 2005. Store dialogue year 2005 separately from archive publication date 2011. Not a checked scan of the 2005 book.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O21\",\"locator\":\"Five-minute experimental protocol. GPT-4.5 with a humanlike persona was judged human in 73% of the reported comparisons. Not the two-hour Long Bets protocol.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Keep this general forecast distinct from the exact Long Bets protocol. Broader conversational fulfillment is not labeled proof of AGI.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-024\",\"relation\":\"LINK_FAMILY_NOT_EXACT_DUPLICATE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-027\",\"relation\":\"LINK_FAMILY_NOT_EXACT_DUPLICATE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-020\",\"relation\":\"LINK_FAMILY_NOT_EXACT_DUPLICATE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-011\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_AND_SPLIT_REQUIRED\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Computers are sold in a wide range of small personal forms, including tiny accessories and thin book-sized devices.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors. Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors.", "at_review_rationale": "Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N03", "O03", "O05", "O07" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Computers are sold in a wide range of small personal forms, including tiny accessories and thin book-sized devices.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors. Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors.", "at_review_rationale": "Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N03", "O03", "O05", "O07" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Computers are sold in a wide range of small personal forms, including tiny accessories and thin book-sized devices.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors. Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors.", "at_review_rationale": "Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N03", "O03", "O05", "O07" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2009, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2009", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The intake turned a multi-form-factor claim into a tablet success. A source-confirmed scope correction is supplied, without assuming every miniature form had the required usability.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K046", "slug": "k046-portable-computers-in-many-tiny-form-factors", "title": "Portable computers in many tiny form factors", "prediction_paraphrase": "Computers span tiny accessories through thin book-sized devices.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "high-resolution interfaces", "wearables" ], "subcategory": "Form factors", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K046", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "EXE-008" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Computers are sold in a wide range of small personal forms, including tiny accessories and thin book-sized devices.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors.", "at_review_rationale": "Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors. Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2009, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 4, printed pp. 13–14", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N03", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O03", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O05", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O07", "locator": "", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "EXE-008", "relation": "RESTORE_FORM_FACTOR_SCOPE" } ] }, "id": "K046", "familyId": "K046", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K046", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "high-resolution interfaces", "wearables", "Form factors" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Computers span tiny accessories through thin book-sized devices.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Computers span tiny accessories through thin book-sized devices.", "successCriteria": "Computers are sold in a wide range of small personal forms, including tiny accessories and thin book-sized devices.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "The Computer Itself, prediction 4, printed pp. 13–14", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N03", "id": "N03-0", "title": "Apple: Small clip-on iPod shuffle", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2009/03/11Apple-Announces-Incredible-New-iPod-shuffle/", "publishedAt": "2009-03-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." }, { "sourceId": "O03", "id": "O03-1", "title": "Apple introduces MacBook Air", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2008/01/15Apple-Introduces-MacBook-Air-The-Worlds-Thinnest-Notebook/", "publishedAt": "2008-01-15", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Opening notebook description and hardware/features paragraphs. The announcement documents an unusually thin notebook and built-in wireless features. Evidence limits: It is one full-sized notebook, not evidence for the full range of tiny computing form factors." }, { "sourceId": "O05", "id": "O05-2", "title": "Introducing Amazon Kindle", "url": "https://press.aboutamazon.com/2007/11/introducing-amazon-kindle", "publishedAt": "2007-11-19", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Opening product description and Holds Hundreds of Books in 10.3 Ounces section. The 2007 Kindle is a small electronic-reading form factor with wireless access and local storage. Evidence limits: Its listed functions and size do not make it a general-purpose keyboard-free computer." }, { "sourceId": "O07", "id": "O07-3", "title": "iPhone App Store downloads top 10 million", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2008/07/14iPhone-App-Store-Downloads-Top-10-Million-in-First-Weekend/", "publishedAt": "2008-07-14", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Opening iPhone/iPod touch description and native-application availability paragraph. The release documents a programmable mobile-device application ecosystem before 2009. Evidence limits: This citation establishes available applications, not physical dimensions or every proposed form factor." }, { "sourceId": "SUP001", "id": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18-SUP001", "title": "Apple introduces iPod shuffle (2005)", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2005/01/11Apple-Introduces-iPod-shuffle/", "publishedAt": "2005-01-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Opening wearable-device description and USB flash-drive paragraph. The shipping player demonstrates a small wearable digital device with flash storage and computer connectivity. Evidence limits: A music player is not a substitute for every general-purpose-computer form factor in the forecast." }, { "sourceId": "SUP002", "id": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18-SUP002", "title": "Apple reinvents the phone with iPhone", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2007/01/09Apple-Reinvents-the-Phone-with-iPhone/", "publishedAt": "2007-01-09", "accessedAt": "2026-10-18", "stance": "SUPPORTS", "note": "Opening product description and Pricing & Availability section. The 2007 announcement describes a small handheld combining phone, media player and Internet functions. Evidence limits: The source documents a planned product and functions, not universality or the success of every miniature form factor." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors. Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. The intake turned a multi-form-factor claim into a tablet success. A source-confirmed scope correction is supplied, without assuming every miniature form had the required usability. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors. Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed." }, { "date": "2026-10-18", "note": "citation-supplement-2026-10-18: 5 primary citation checks/additions. Primary citation locators, source-specific support limits and additional corroborating references; no changes to verdicts, eligibility or timing judgments." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Computers are sold in a wide range of small personal forms, including tiny accessories and thin book-sized devices.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors. Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N03\",\"O03\",\"O05\",\"O07\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Computers are sold in a wide range of small personal forms, including tiny accessories and thin book-sized devices.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors. Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N03\",\"O03\",\"O05\",\"O07\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Computers are sold in a wide range of small personal forms, including tiny accessories and thin book-sized devices.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors. Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N03\",\"O03\",\"O05\",\"O07\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2009\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The intake turned a multi-form-factor claim into a tablet success. A source-confirmed scope correction is supplied, without assuming every miniature form had the required usability.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K046\",\"slug\":\"k046-portable-computers-in-many-tiny-form-factors\",\"title\":\"Portable computers in many tiny form factors\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Computers span tiny accessories through thin book-sized devices.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[\"high-resolution interfaces\",\"wearables\"],\"subcategory\":\"Form factors\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K046\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"EXE-008\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Computers are sold in a wide range of small personal forms, including tiny accessories and thin book-sized devices.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Clip-on shuffle, smartphones, Kindle and thin laptops are concrete pre-deadline form factors. Illustrative rings/earrings need not all become equally popular for the varied-miniaturization claim to succeed.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2009,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"The Computer Itself, prediction 4, printed pp. 13–14\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N03\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O03\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O05\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O07\",\"locator\":\"\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-008\",\"relation\":\"RESTORE_FORM_FACTOR_SCOPE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Automation removes more than half of human driving, retaining the forecast’s “most” threshold.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers. Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers.", "at_review_rationale": "Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O14", "N07", "N24" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Automation removes more than half of human driving, retaining the forecast’s “most” threshold.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers. Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers.", "at_review_rationale": "Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O14", "N07", "N24" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Fully driverless travel becomes a real commercial service in some cities.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Public Waymo service realizes this weaker capability in 2020, without meeting the original majority threshold.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Most driving", "Smart-road architecture" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2020, "evidence_source_ids": [ "O14", "N07", "N24" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "WRONG_MISSED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Even NHTSA’s current guidance describes limited automated operating areas and driver-attention requirements for consumer vehicles. Waymo’s 2026 expansion confirms real driverless service, but not displacement of most human driving. These later records strongly contradict treating the 2019 majority claim as achieved.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K047", "slug": "k047-automated-systems-eliminate-most-human-driving", "title": "Automated systems eliminate most human driving", "prediction_paraphrase": "Smart roads and automation eliminate most human driving.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Robotics & transportation", "tags": [ "majority displacement" ], "subcategory": "Driving automation", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "F-AUTOMATED-DRIVING", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "ADDED_PRIMARY_SOURCE", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Automation removes more than half of human driving, retaining the forecast’s “most” threshold.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers.", "at_review_rationale": "Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers. Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Business in 2019: smart roads", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O14", "locator": "Live guidance checked for this review. Describes limited operating areas for automated fleets and driver-attention requirements of consumer vehicles; not a historical 2009 market census.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N07", "locator": "Geofenced Phoenix service, not all roads, universal ownership, or road-embedded guidance infrastructure.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N24", "locator": "2021 global annual road deaths 1.19 million; about 5% below 2010. These are observed-year figures, not invented 2026 counts.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-028", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-022", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" } ] }, "id": "K047", "familyId": "F-AUTOMATED-DRIVING", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K047", "category": "Robotics & transportation", "tags": [ "majority displacement", "Driving automation" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Smart roads and automation eliminate most human driving.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Smart roads and automation eliminate most human driving.", "successCriteria": "Automation removes more than half of human driving, retaining the forecast’s “most” threshold.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Business in 2019: smart roads", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O14", "id": "O14-0", "title": "Automated Vehicle Safety — NHTSA", "url": "https://www.nhtsa.gov/vehicle-safety/automated-vehicle-safety", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Live guidance checked for this review. Describes limited operating areas for automated fleets and driver-attention requirements of consumer vehicles; not a historical 2009 market census.. Live guidance checked for this review. Describes limited operating areas for automated fleets and driver-attention requirements of consumer vehicles; not a historical 2009 market census." }, { "sourceId": "N07", "id": "N07-1", "title": "Waymo opens its fully driverless service to the public", "url": "https://waymo.com/blog/2020/10/waymo-is-opening-its-fully-driverless-service-in-phoenix/", "publishedAt": "2020-10-08", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Geofenced Phoenix service, not all roads, universal ownership, or road-embedded guidance infrastructure.. Geofenced Phoenix service, not all roads, universal ownership, or road-embedded guidance infrastructure." }, { "sourceId": "N24", "id": "N24-2", "title": "WHO: Global road safety progress remains insufficient", "url": "https://www.who.int/news/item/13-12-2023-despite-notable-progress-road-safety-remains-urgent-global-issue", "publishedAt": "2023-12-13", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "2021 global annual road deaths 1.19 million; about 5% below 2010. These are observed-year figures, not invented 2026 counts.. 2021 global annual road deaths 1.19 million; about 5% below 2010. These are observed-year figures, not invented 2026 counts." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": true, "rationale": "2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers. Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: WRONG_MISSED. Even NHTSA’s current guidance describes limited automated operating areas and driver-attention requirements for consumer vehicles. Waymo’s 2026 expansion confirms real driverless service, but not displacement of most human driving. These later records strongly contradict treating the 2019 majority claim as achieved. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. 2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers. Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Automation removes more than half of human driving, retaining the forecast’s “most” threshold.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers. Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O14\",\"N07\",\"N24\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Automation removes more than half of human driving, retaining the forecast’s “most” threshold.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers. Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O14\",\"N07\",\"N24\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Fully driverless travel becomes a real commercial service in some cities.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Public Waymo service realizes this weaker capability in 2020, without meeting the original majority threshold.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Most driving\",\"Smart-road architecture\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2020,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O14\",\"N07\",\"N24\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG_MISSED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Even NHTSA’s current guidance describes limited automated operating areas and driver-attention requirements for consumer vehicles. Waymo’s 2026 expansion confirms real driverless service, but not displacement of most human driving. These later records strongly contradict treating the 2019 majority claim as achieved.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K047\",\"slug\":\"k047-automated-systems-eliminate-most-human-driving\",\"title\":\"Automated systems eliminate most human driving\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Smart roads and automation eliminate most human driving.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Robotics & transportation\",\"tags\":[\"majority displacement\"],\"subcategory\":\"Driving automation\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"F-AUTOMATED-DRIVING\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"ADDED_PRIMARY_SOURCE\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Automation removes more than half of human driving, retaining the forecast’s “most” threshold.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"2019 road transport still relied predominantly on human drivers. Public driverless services are a real advance, but do not establish that most driving has been eliminated across the road system.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Business in 2019: smart roads\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O14\",\"locator\":\"Live guidance checked for this review. Describes limited operating areas for automated fleets and driver-attention requirements of consumer vehicles; not a historical 2009 market census.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N07\",\"locator\":\"Geofenced Phoenix service, not all roads, universal ownership, or road-embedded guidance infrastructure.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N24\",\"locator\":\"2021 global annual road deaths 1.19 million; about 5% below 2010. These are observed-year figures, not invented 2026 counts.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-028\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-022\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Ordinary users have practical two-way spoken translation for many language pairs; no perfect all-language requirement.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service. Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2015, "at_deadline_rationale": "Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service.", "at_review_rationale": "Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O11", "O12", "N20" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Speech-to-speech translation is integrated into live telephone calls for many ordinary language pairs, without requiring all languages or flawless human equivalence.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2009 product evidence was narrower. Apple documents spoken in-call translation shipping in September 2025, and its current guide lists multiple common languages. This satisfies practical telephone integration; perfect translation was not required.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "LITERAL_TELEPHONE_INTEGRATION", "documented_by_year": 2025, "evidence_source_ids": [ "O11", "O12", "N71", "N72" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Ordinary users have practical two-way spoken translation for many language pairs; no perfect all-language requirement.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service. Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2015, "at_deadline_rationale": "Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service.", "at_review_rationale": "Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O11", "O12", "N20" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "non_scoring_comparators": [ { "criterion": "Perfect human-quality interpretation for arbitrary calls and all languages.", "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "eligible_for_author_accuracy": false, "warning": "Not demanded by the source; do not score this as a strict forecast." } ], "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2015, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2015; after 2009, no later than 2015", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "PARTIAL", "at_review": "FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "CMU documented an English–Spanish iPhone speech translator in 2009. Google expanded conversation mode to 14 languages in 2011. That is meaningful capability progress, but neither proves common many-pair use by 2009.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K048", "slug": "k048-common-many-language-speech-to-speech-translation", "title": "Common many-language speech-to-speech translation", "prediction_paraphrase": "Many-pair translating telephones are commonly used.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "speech-to-speech", "adoption" ], "subcategory": "Machine translation", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "F-SPEECH-TRANSLATION", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "CONFIRMED_RELATED_VERSION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Ordinary users have practical two-way spoken translation for many language pairs; no perfect all-language requirement.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service.", "at_review_rationale": "Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "LATE", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service. Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2015, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "Communication, prediction 1, printed p. 50", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O11", "locator": "Fall 2009 university account of English–Spanish speech translation on iPhone. Not evidence of common use across many language pairs.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O12", "locator": "Speech conversation mode expanded to 14 languages; still described as alpha. Not equivalent to translation quality or universal adoption.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N20", "locator": "Conversation and speech translation documented in product updates. Text-language counts must not be presented as speech-language counts; 44-language wearable speech support is separately identified.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N71", "locator": "Shipping real-time spoken translation in Phone for selected language pairs; five languages at initial launch. Not every language, country or device.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N72", "locator": "Current iOS 26 guide lists one-on-one spoken Phone translation across English, French, German, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish, Chinese, Japanese and Korean variants. Supports actual telephone integration, not perfect translation quality.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Do not reuse text-translation language totals as speech totals. The 2015 documented-by year is not asserted as the first possible many-pair translation product.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "AUD-027", "relation": "QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_UNLOCATED" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-008", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-002", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-004", "relation": "QUARANTINE_AND_SPLIT_REQUIRED" } ] }, "id": "K048", "familyId": "F-SPEECH-TRANSLATION", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K048", "category": "AI & software", "tags": [ "speech-to-speech", "adoption", "Machine translation" ], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Many-pair translating telephones are commonly used.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Many-pair translating telephones are commonly used.", "successCriteria": "Ordinary users have practical two-way spoken translation for many language pairs; no perfect all-language requirement.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "Communication, prediction 1, printed p. 50", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O11", "id": "O11-0", "title": "How do you say? — Carnegie Mellon on Jibbigo", "url": "https://www.cmu.edu/homepage/society/2009/fall/how-do-you-say.shtml", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Fall 2009 university account of English–Spanish speech translation on iPhone. Not evidence of common use across many language pairs.. Fall 2009 university account of English–Spanish speech translation on iPhone. Not evidence of common use across many language pairs." }, { "sourceId": "O12", "id": "O12-1", "title": "Start a conversation with Google", "url": "https://translate.googleblog.com/2011/10/start-conversation-with-google.html", "publishedAt": "2011-10-13", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Speech conversation mode expanded to 14 languages; still described as alpha. Not equivalent to translation quality or universal adoption.. Speech conversation mode expanded to 14 languages; still described as alpha. Not equivalent to translation quality or universal adoption." }, { "sourceId": "N20", "id": "N20-2", "title": "Google Translate: 2015 official product updates", "url": "https://translate.googleblog.com/2015/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Conversation and speech translation documented in product updates. Text-language counts must not be presented as speech-language counts; 44-language wearable speech support is separately identified.. Conversation and speech translation documented in product updates. Text-language counts must not be presented as speech-language counts; 44-language wearable speech support is separately identified." }, { "sourceId": "N71", "id": "N71-3", "title": "Apple: Live Translation shipping in iOS 26", "url": "https://www.apple.com/ci/newsroom/2025/09/new-apple-intelligence-features-are-available-today/", "publishedAt": "2025-09-15", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Shipping real-time spoken translation in Phone for selected language pairs; five languages at initial launch. Not every language, country or device.. Shipping real-time spoken translation in Phone for selected language pairs; five languages at initial launch. Not every language, country or device." }, { "sourceId": "N72", "id": "N72-4", "title": "Apple: Translate phone calls and conversations", "url": "https://support.apple.com/is-is/guide/iphone/iph22b72984d/26/ios/26", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Current iOS 26 guide lists one-on-one spoken Phone translation across English, French, German, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish, Chinese, Japanese and Korean variants. Supports actual telephone integration, not perfect translation quality.. Current iOS 26 guide lists one-on-one spoken Phone translation across English, French, German, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish, Chinese, Japanese and Korean variants. Supports actual telephone integration, not perfect translation quality." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service. Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Do not reuse text-translation language totals as speech totals. The 2015 documented-by year is not asserted as the first possible many-pair translation product.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Do not reuse text-translation language totals as speech totals. The 2015 documented-by year is not asserted as the first possible many-pair translation product.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PARTIAL. CMU documented an English–Spanish iPhone speech translator in 2009. Google expanded conversation mode to 14 languages in 2011. That is meaningful capability progress, but neither proves common many-pair use by 2009. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict LATE. Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service. Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Ordinary users have practical two-way spoken translation for many language pairs; no perfect all-language requirement.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service. Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O11\",\"O12\",\"N20\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Speech-to-speech translation is integrated into live telephone calls for many ordinary language pairs, without requiring all languages or flawless human equivalence.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2009 product evidence was narrower. Apple documents spoken in-call translation shipping in September 2025, and its current guide lists multiple common languages. This satisfies practical telephone integration; perfect translation was not required.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"LITERAL_TELEPHONE_INTEGRATION\",\"documented_by_year\":2025,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O11\",\"O12\",\"N71\",\"N72\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Ordinary users have practical two-way spoken translation for many language pairs; no perfect all-language requirement.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service. Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O11\",\"O12\",\"N20\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"non_scoring_comparators\":[{\"criterion\":\"Perfect human-quality interpretation for arbitrary calls and all languages.\",\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"eligible_for_author_accuracy\":false,\"warning\":\"Not demanded by the source; do not score this as a strict forecast.\"}],\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2015; after 2009, no later than 2015\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTIAL\",\"at_review\":\"FULL_FULFILLMENT_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"CMU documented an English–Spanish iPhone speech translator in 2009. Google expanded conversation mode to 14 languages in 2011. That is meaningful capability progress, but neither proves common many-pair use by 2009.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K048\",\"slug\":\"k048-common-many-language-speech-to-speech-translation\",\"title\":\"Common many-language speech-to-speech translation\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Many-pair translating telephones are commonly used.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"AI & software\",\"tags\":[\"speech-to-speech\",\"adoption\"],\"subcategory\":\"Machine translation\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"F-SPEECH-TRANSLATION\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"CONFIRMED_RELATED_VERSION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ARCHIVE_REPRINT\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"SUPPORTED_BY_LISTED_SOURCE\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Ordinary users have practical two-way spoken translation for many language pairs; no perfect all-language requirement.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Jibbigo provided a real but limited 2009 translating-phone capability. It was not yet a routine many-pair service. Google’s 2011 and 2015 conversation/speech products establish the broader consumer capability by 2015. Accents and mistakes do not negate ordinary practical use.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2015,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"Communication, prediction 1, printed p. 50\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O11\",\"locator\":\"Fall 2009 university account of English–Spanish speech translation on iPhone. Not evidence of common use across many language pairs.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O12\",\"locator\":\"Speech conversation mode expanded to 14 languages; still described as alpha. Not equivalent to translation quality or universal adoption.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N20\",\"locator\":\"Conversation and speech translation documented in product updates. Text-language counts must not be presented as speech-language counts; 44-language wearable speech support is separately identified.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N71\",\"locator\":\"Shipping real-time spoken translation in Phone for selected language pairs; five languages at initial launch. Not every language, country or device.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N72\",\"locator\":\"Current iOS 26 guide lists one-on-one spoken Phone translation across English, French, German, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish, Chinese, Japanese and Korean variants. Supports actual telephone integration, not perfect translation quality.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Do not reuse text-translation language totals as speech totals. The 2015 documented-by year is not asserted as the first possible many-pair translation product.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"AUD-027\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_COMPOUND_UNLOCATED\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-008\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-002\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-004\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_AND_SPLIT_REQUIRED\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Cochlear-style implants are widely used beyond hearing impairment as two-way interfaces to a computing network.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 deadline remains future. Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 deadline remains future.", "at_review_rationale": "Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O23" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Cochlear-style implants are widely used beyond hearing impairment as two-way interfaces to a computing network.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 deadline remains future. Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 deadline remains future.", "at_review_rationale": "Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O23" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Cochlear-style implants are widely used beyond hearing impairment as two-way interfaces to a computing network.", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2029 deadline remains future. Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 deadline remains future.", "at_review_rationale": "Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O23" ], "verdict": "PENDING", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "deadline_year": 2029, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Deadline not yet reached", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "ASSESSED", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "This is a located, future interface claim. It is not the intake’s invented 2009 proposition that implants cure deafness.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K049", "slug": "k049-ubiquitous-bidirectional-cochlear-network-interfaces", "title": "Ubiquitous bidirectional cochlear network interfaces", "prediction_paraphrase": "Cochlear implants become widespread two-way network interfaces.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Neuroscience & human augmentation", "tags": [ "cochlear implants", "two-way communication" ], "subcategory": "Auditory interfaces", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "F-COCHLEAR", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "CONFIRMED_RELATED_VERSION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2029", "deadline_year": 2029, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2029, "year_end": 2029, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Cochlear-style implants are widely used beyond hearing impairment as two-way interfaces to a computing network.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2029 deadline remains future.", "at_review_rationale": "Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PENDING", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_DUE", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The 2029 deadline remains future. Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2029: cochlear implants", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O23", "locator": "Cochlear implants do not restore normal hearing. Used to correct a medical error in our intake, not to manufacture a Kurzweil forecast.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Restoring hearing is distinct from bidirectional network communication and widespread elective implantation.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "DEC-018", "relation": "QUARANTINE_UNSUPPORTED_MEDICAL_PARAPHRASE" } ] }, "id": "K049", "familyId": "F-COCHLEAR", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K049", "category": "Neuroscience & human augmentation", "tags": [ "cochlear implants", "two-way communication", "Auditory interfaces" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Cochlear implants become widespread two-way network interfaces.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Cochlear implants become widespread two-way network interfaces.", "successCriteria": "Cochlear-style implants are widely used beyond hearing impairment as two-way interfaces to a computing network.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2029: cochlear implants", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2029", "year": 2029, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O23", "id": "O23-0", "title": "What educators need to know about cochlear implants — FDA", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/cochlear-implants/what-educators-need-know", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Cochlear implants do not restore normal hearing. Used to correct a medical error in our intake, not to manufacture a Kurzweil forecast.. Cochlear implants do not restore normal hearing. Used to correct a medical error in our intake, not to manufacture a Kurzweil forecast." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": false, "atDeadline": "NOT_DUE", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The 2029 deadline remains future. Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": "Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed." }, "research": { "notes": "Restoring hearing is distinct from bidirectional network communication and widespread elective implantation.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: PENDING. This is a located, future interface claim. It is not the intake’s invented 2009 proposition that implants cure deafness. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PENDING. The 2029 deadline remains future. Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Cochlear-style implants are widely used beyond hearing impairment as two-way interfaces to a computing network.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline remains future. Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline remains future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O23\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Cochlear-style implants are widely used beyond hearing impairment as two-way interfaces to a computing network.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline remains future. Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline remains future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O23\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Cochlear-style implants are widely used beyond hearing impairment as two-way interfaces to a computing network.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline remains future. Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline remains future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O23\"],\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"deadline_year\":2029,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Deadline not yet reached\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"ASSESSED\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"This is a located, future interface claim. It is not the intake’s invented 2009 proposition that implants cure deafness.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K049\",\"slug\":\"k049-ubiquitous-bidirectional-cochlear-network-interfaces\",\"title\":\"Ubiquitous bidirectional cochlear network interfaces\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Cochlear implants become widespread two-way network interfaces.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Neuroscience & human augmentation\",\"tags\":[\"cochlear implants\",\"two-way communication\"],\"subcategory\":\"Auditory interfaces\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"F-COCHLEAR\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"CONFIRMED_RELATED_VERSION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2029\",\"deadline_year\":2029,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2029,\"year_end\":2029,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Cochlear-style implants are widely used beyond hearing impairment as two-way interfaces to a computing network.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline remains future.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PENDING\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_DUE\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The 2029 deadline remains future. Therapeutic cochlear implants establish only a portion of the predicted technology and population. They are not yet a general network interface for ordinary users.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future deadline; current progress nevertheless assessed.\"},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Computers and communications in 2029: cochlear implants\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O23\",\"locator\":\"Cochlear implants do not restore normal hearing. Used to correct a medical error in our intake, not to manufacture a Kurzweil forecast.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Restoring hearing is distinct from bidirectional network communication and widespread elective implantation.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-018\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_UNSUPPORTED_MEDICAL_PARAPHRASE\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Computing is commonly embedded unobtrusively in everyday objects and systems, rather than confined to visibly separate PCs.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019. The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N21", "N25", "N52" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Every listed setting—walls, furniture, clothing, jewelry and bodies—has become a common computing location.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The product categories are unevenly realized, especially ordinary clothing and elective in-body computing. This full-list reading remains partial.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N21", "N25", "N52" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Computing is commonly embedded unobtrusively in everyday objects and systems, rather than confined to visibly separate PCs.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019. The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N21", "N25", "N52" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2019, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2019", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [ { "from_version": "0.2", "previous_assessment": { "review_state": "SOURCE_CONFIRMED", "verdict": "UNREVIEWED", "as_of": "2026-10-14", "at_deadline": "NOT_ASSESSED", "at_review": "NOT_ASSESSED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": false, "rationale": "The original sentence concerns embedded computing, not necessarily displays built into clothing. The intake merged that with the neighboring retinal-display claim. The two are now separated; outcome scoring is not completed.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "withheld_reason": "Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment." }, "change_reason": "Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." } ], "is_new_in_v03": false, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K050", "slug": "k050-invisible-computing-embedded-throughout-the-environment", "title": "Invisible computing embedded throughout the environment", "prediction_paraphrase": "Computing is largely invisible and embedded throughout surroundings.", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "ambient computing", "adoption" ], "subcategory": "Embedded computing", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K050", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [ "DEC-016", "EXE-009" ], "origin": "LEGACY_RECONCILIATION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": null }, "source_verification": { "state": "TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Computing is commonly embedded unobtrusively in everyday objects and systems, rather than confined to visibly separate PCs.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019. The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2019, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2019: embedded computers", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N21", "locator": "23.2 million consumer/domestic service robots sold in 2019, +34%. Annual sales are not household penetration or a count of robot-owning homes.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N25", "locator": "ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; ECG deployment corroborated by December 2018 release O22. Not diagnosis of all diseases or autonomous treatment.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N52", "locator": "January 2010 retrospective on robots launched in 2002 and already commercially established in the 2000s; do not shift the threshold by one year just because the tally was announced in January.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "The strength of the embedded trend is an editorial assessment from multiple product classes, not a complete census of every household object. Body implantation is not silently claimed fulfilled.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [ { "legacy_id": "DEC-016", "relation": "CORRECT_SCOPE" }, { "legacy_id": "DEC-021", "relation": "QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY" }, { "legacy_id": "EXE-009", "relation": "SPLIT_DISTINCT_CAPABILITIES" } ] }, "id": "K050", "familyId": "K050", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K050", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [ "ambient computing", "adoption", "Embedded computing" ], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Computing is largely invisible and embedded throughout surroundings.", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Computing is largely invisible and embedded throughout surroundings.", "successCriteria": "Computing is commonly embedded unobtrusively in everyday objects and systems, rather than confined to visibly separate PCs.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "Computers and communications in 2019: embedded computers", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N21", "id": "N21-0", "title": "IFR: Service robots record sales worldwide", "url": "https://ifr.org/ifr-press-releases/news/service-robots-record-sales-worldwide-up-32", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "23.2 million consumer/domestic service robots sold in 2019, +34%. Annual sales are not household penetration or a count of robot-owning homes.. 23.2 million consumer/domestic service robots sold in 2019, +34%. Annual sales are not household penetration or a count of robot-owning homes." }, { "sourceId": "N25", "id": "N25-1", "title": "Apple: Watch Series 4 health, ECG and fall detection", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2018/09/redesigned-apple-watch-series-4-revolutionizes-communication-fitness-and-health/", "publishedAt": "2018-09-12", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; ECG deployment corroborated by December 2018 release O22. Not diagnosis of all diseases or autonomous treatment.. ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; ECG deployment corroborated by December 2018 release O22. Not diagnosis of all diseases or autonomous treatment." }, { "sourceId": "N52", "id": "N52-2", "title": "iRobot: More than five million home robots sold", "url": "https://investor.irobot.com/news-releases/news-release-details/irobot-achieves-milestone-home-robot-market", "publishedAt": "2010-01-05", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "January 2010 retrospective on robots launched in 2002 and already commercially established in the 2000s; do not shift the threshold by one year just because the tally was announced in January.. January 2010 retrospective on robots launched in 2002 and already commercially established in the 2000s; do not shift the threshold by one year just because the tally was announced in January." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019. The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.", "alternativeInterpretation": "The strength of the embedded trend is an editorial assessment from multiple product classes, not a complete census of every household object. Body implantation is not silently claimed fulfilled.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "The strength of the embedded trend is an editorial assessment from multiple product classes, not a complete census of every household object. Body implantation is not silently claimed fulfilled.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-14", "note": "Evidence v0.2: UNREVIEWED. The original sentence concerns embedded computing, not necessarily displays built into clothing. The intake merged that with the neighboring retinal-display claim. The two are now separated; outcome scoring is not completed. Change: Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict." }, { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019. The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Computing is commonly embedded unobtrusively in everyday objects and systems, rather than confined to visibly separate PCs.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019. The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N21\",\"N25\",\"N52\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Every listed setting—walls, furniture, clothing, jewelry and bodies—has become a common computing location.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The product categories are unevenly realized, especially ordinary clothing and elective in-body computing. This full-list reading remains partial.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N21\",\"N25\",\"N52\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Computing is commonly embedded unobtrusively in everyday objects and systems, rather than confined to visibly separate PCs.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019. The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N21\",\"N25\",\"N52\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2019\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[{\"from_version\":\"0.2\",\"previous_assessment\":{\"review_state\":\"SOURCE_CONFIRMED\",\"verdict\":\"UNREVIEWED\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-14\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_ASSESSED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":false,\"rationale\":\"The original sentence concerns embedded computing, not necessarily displays built into clothing. The intake merged that with the neighboring retinal-display claim. The two are now separated; outcome scoring is not completed.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"withheld_reason\":\"Future, unresolved, intrinsically unscorable, or interpretation-dependent; see assessment.\"},\"change_reason\":\"Complete deadline/current outcome assessment under explicit scope; separate uncertainty from verdict.\"}],\"is_new_in_v03\":false,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K050\",\"slug\":\"k050-invisible-computing-embedded-throughout-the-environment\",\"title\":\"Invisible computing embedded throughout the environment\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Computing is largely invisible and embedded throughout surroundings.\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[\"ambient computing\",\"adoption\"],\"subcategory\":\"Embedded computing\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K050\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[\"DEC-016\",\"EXE-009\"],\"origin\":\"LEGACY_RECONCILIATION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"ARTICLE_ATTRIBUTION\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_ARTICLE_YEAR_NOT_ORIGINAL_BOOK_COLLATION\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":null},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"TEXT_CONFIRMED_IN_LISTED_SOURCE\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Computing is commonly embedded unobtrusively in everyday objects and systems, rather than confined to visibly separate PCs.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Wearables, household robots and networked systems show that embedded computing had become a normal part of surroundings by 2019. The reference treats “everywhere” as pervasive integration, not a requirement to implant computers in every chair, wall or person.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2019,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"Computers and communications in 2019: embedded computers\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N21\",\"locator\":\"23.2 million consumer/domestic service robots sold in 2019, +34%. Annual sales are not household penetration or a count of robot-owning homes.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N25\",\"locator\":\"ECG/AFib classification, hard-fall detection and emergency calling; ECG deployment corroborated by December 2018 release O22. Not diagnosis of all diseases or autonomous treatment.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N52\",\"locator\":\"January 2010 retrospective on robots launched in 2002 and already commercially established in the 2000s; do not shift the threshold by one year just because the tally was announced in January.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"The strength of the embedded trend is an editorial assessment from multiple product classes, not a complete census of every household object. Body implantation is not silently claimed fulfilled.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-016\",\"relation\":\"CORRECT_SCOPE\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"DEC-021\",\"relation\":\"QUARANTINE_RELATED_VERSION_ONLY\"},{\"legacy_id\":\"EXE-009\",\"relation\":\"SPLIT_DISTINCT_CAPABILITIES\"}]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Multilayer active circuitry moves from experiments into ordinary semiconductor products.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009. Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2015, "at_deadline_rationale": "Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "N12" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Multilayer active circuitry moves from experiments into ordinary semiconductor products.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009. Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2015, "at_deadline_rationale": "Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "N12" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Include stacked dies and specialized sensor/MEMS structures as 3D chips.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The author’s retrospective cites pre-2009 commercial examples under this expansive definition. On-time success is plausible on that reading; independent prevalence evidence is thinner.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Definition includes stacked/specialized chip structures" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "N12" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2015, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "EDITORIAL_ERA_BOUND", "label": "By the mid-2010s on the stated market reading; exact threshold year not established", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "bound_is_editorial": true }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K051", "slug": "k051-3d-integrated-circuits-become-common", "title": "3D integrated circuits become common", "prediction_paraphrase": "3D integrated circuits become common", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K051", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_RETROSPECTIVE_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Multilayer active circuitry moves from experiments into ordinary semiconductor products.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "LATE", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009. Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2015, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "P01 printed p.27, Computers #19; P02 2009 computing section", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N12", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "2015 is a conservative commercial-era bound, not a measured majority-market crossover. V-NAND is multilayer storage, not self-organizing molecular logic.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K051", "familyId": "K051", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K051", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "3D integrated circuits become common", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "3D integrated circuits become common", "successCriteria": "Multilayer active circuitry moves from experiments into ordinary semiconductor products.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "P01 printed p.27, Computers #19; P02 2009 computing section", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P01", "id": "P01-0", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.. Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices." }, { "sourceId": "N12", "id": "N12-1", "title": "Samsung begins mass production of 3D V-NAND", "url": "https://news.samsung.com/global/samsung-starts-mass-producing-industrys-first-3d-vertical-nand-flash", "publishedAt": "2013-08-06", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009. Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.", "alternativeInterpretation": "2015 is a conservative commercial-era bound, not a measured majority-market crossover. V-NAND is multilayer storage, not self-organizing molecular logic.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "2015 is a conservative commercial-era bound, not a measured majority-market crossover. V-NAND is multilayer storage, not self-organizing molecular logic.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict LATE. Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009. Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Multilayer active circuitry moves from experiments into ordinary semiconductor products.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009. Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"N12\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Multilayer active circuitry moves from experiments into ordinary semiconductor products.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009. Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"N12\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Include stacked dies and specialized sensor/MEMS structures as 3D chips.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The author’s retrospective cites pre-2009 commercial examples under this expansive definition. On-time success is plausible on that reading; independent prevalence evidence is thinner.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Definition includes stacked/specialized chip structures\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"N12\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"EDITORIAL_ERA_BOUND\",\"label\":\"By the mid-2010s on the stated market reading; exact threshold year not established\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"bound_is_editorial\":true},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K051\",\"slug\":\"k051-3d-integrated-circuits-become-common\",\"title\":\"3D integrated circuits become common\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"3D integrated circuits become common\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K051\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_RETROSPECTIVE_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Multilayer active circuitry moves from experiments into ordinary semiconductor products.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Early stacked/specialized devices made the direction real, but a broad transition to genuinely three-dimensional circuitry was only partial in 2009. Samsung’s mass-produced 3D V-NAND from 2013 establishes commercial multilayer circuits. The word “common” need not mean every processor has become 3D.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2015,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"P01 printed p.27, Computers #19; P02 2009 computing section\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N12\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"2015 is a conservative commercial-era bound, not a measured majority-market crossover. V-NAND is multilayer storage, not self-organizing molecular logic.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "A roughly $1,000 PC can supply about 10^12 peak single-precision operations per second, counting its graphics processor.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC. This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC.", "at_review_rationale": "This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N54", "N09" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "The entire PC sustains a teraflop on a specified general-purpose benchmark, rather than adding peak GPU arithmetic.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Peak board specifications do not establish the stricter 2009 system benchmark. Later consumer hardware has ample headroom, so the narrower practical-throughput reading is late.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Peak versus sustained general-purpose benchmark" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2020, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N54", "N09" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "A roughly $1,000 PC can supply about 10^12 peak single-precision operations per second, counting its graphics processor.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC. This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC.", "at_review_rationale": "This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N54", "N09" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2009, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2009", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K052", "slug": "k052-1-000-pcs-reach-one-teraflop", "title": "$1,000 PCs reach one teraflop", "prediction_paraphrase": "$1,000 PCs reach one teraflop", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K052", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_RETROSPECTIVE_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "A roughly $1,000 PC can supply about 10^12 peak single-precision operations per second, counting its graphics processor.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC.", "at_review_rationale": "This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC. This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2009, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "P01 printed p.29, Computers #21; P02 opening 2009 paragraph", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N54", "locator": "Italian reproduction of AMD June 25 release: HD 4850/4870 availability, FP32 peak and $199/$299 suggested prices. An editor-inferred sub-$1000 PC budget is not a measured whole-system benchmark.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N09", "locator": "RTX 3080 launch price $699 and roughly 30 FP32 shader TFLOPS. Tensor, ray-tracing and shader operations are not interchangeable.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Sub-$1,000 system feasibility is an explicit cost-budget inference, not a retrieved exact 2008 shopping receipt. Current benchmark reading has medium confidence; arithmetic precision is visible.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K052", "familyId": "K052", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K052", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "$1,000 PCs reach one teraflop", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "$1,000 PCs reach one teraflop", "successCriteria": "A roughly $1,000 PC can supply about 10^12 peak single-precision operations per second, counting its graphics processor.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "P01 printed p.29, Computers #21; P02 opening 2009 paragraph", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N54", "id": "N54-0", "title": "AMD: 2008 teraFLOPS graphics launch, issuer release reproduced", "url": "https://xtremehardware.com/news/1524-amd-introduce-il-primo-chip-grafico-al-mondo-di-classe-teraflops", "publishedAt": "2008-06-26", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Italian reproduction of AMD June 25 release: HD 4850/4870 availability, FP32 peak and $199/$299 suggested prices. An editor-inferred sub-$1000 PC budget is not a measured whole-system benchmark.. Italian reproduction of AMD June 25 release: HD 4850/4870 availability, FP32 peak and $199/$299 suggested prices. An editor-inferred sub-$1000 PC budget is not a measured whole-system benchmark." }, { "sourceId": "N09", "id": "N09-1", "title": "NVIDIA: RTX 30-series launch specifications and pricing", "url": "https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/geforce/news/introducing-rtx-30-series-graphics-cards/", "publishedAt": "2020-09-01", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "RTX 3080 launch price $699 and roughly 30 FP32 shader TFLOPS. Tensor, ray-tracing and shader operations are not interchangeable.. RTX 3080 launch price $699 and roughly 30 FP32 shader TFLOPS. Tensor, ray-tracing and shader operations are not interchangeable." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC. This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Sub-$1,000 system feasibility is an explicit cost-budget inference, not a retrieved exact 2008 shopping receipt. Current benchmark reading has medium confidence; arithmetic precision is visible.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Sub-$1,000 system feasibility is an explicit cost-budget inference, not a retrieved exact 2008 shopping receipt. Current benchmark reading has medium confidence; arithmetic precision is visible.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC. This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"A roughly $1,000 PC can supply about 10^12 peak single-precision operations per second, counting its graphics processor.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC. This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N54\",\"N09\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"The entire PC sustains a teraflop on a specified general-purpose benchmark, rather than adding peak GPU arithmetic.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Peak board specifications do not establish the stricter 2009 system benchmark. Later consumer hardware has ample headroom, so the narrower practical-throughput reading is late.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Peak versus sustained general-purpose benchmark\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2020,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N54\",\"N09\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"A roughly $1,000 PC can supply about 10^12 peak single-precision operations per second, counting its graphics processor.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC. This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N54\",\"N09\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2009\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K052\",\"slug\":\"k052-1-000-pcs-reach-one-teraflop\",\"title\":\"$1,000 PCs reach one teraflop\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"$1,000 PCs reach one teraflop\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K052\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_RETROSPECTIVE_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"A roughly $1,000 PC can supply about 10^12 peak single-precision operations per second, counting its graphics processor.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"AMD’s 2008 $199–$299 GPU generation supplied about 1–1.2 TFLOPS; the remaining budget could accommodate an ordinary host PC. This is a reasonable numerical hardware hit. It is not a claim that every program sustains a teraflop or that GPU and CPU work are interchangeable.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2009,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"P01 printed p.29, Computers #21; P02 opening 2009 paragraph\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N54\",\"locator\":\"Italian reproduction of AMD June 25 release: HD 4850/4870 availability, FP32 peak and $199/$299 suggested prices. An editor-inferred sub-$1000 PC budget is not a measured whole-system benchmark.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N09\",\"locator\":\"RTX 3080 launch price $699 and roughly 30 FP32 shader TFLOPS. Tensor, ray-tracing and shader operations are not interchangeable.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Sub-$1,000 system feasibility is an explicit cost-budget inference, not a retrieved exact 2008 shopping receipt. Current benchmark reading has medium confidence; arithmetic precision is visible.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Internet volunteers pool unused computation into virtual parallel systems reaching the stated approximately 20-petaflop scale.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target. Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2020, "at_deadline_rationale": "Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target.", "at_review_rationale": "Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "N32" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Internet volunteers pool unused computation into virtual parallel systems reaching the stated approximately 20-petaflop scale.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target. Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2020, "at_deadline_rationale": "Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target.", "at_review_rationale": "Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "N32" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Distributed volunteer computing is an established useful architecture without the brain-scale throughput threshold.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "This architectural direction was fulfilled before 2009.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "20-petaflop threshold" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "N32" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2020, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2020; after 2009, no later than 2020", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K053", "slug": "k053-idle-internet-pcs-form-virtual-supercomputers", "title": "Idle Internet PCs form virtual supercomputers", "prediction_paraphrase": "Idle Internet PCs form virtual supercomputers", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K053", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_RETROSPECTIVE_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Internet volunteers pool unused computation into virtual parallel systems reaching the stated approximately 20-petaflop scale.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target.", "at_review_rationale": "Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "LATE", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target. Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2020, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "P01 printed p.30, Computers #23", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N32", "locator": "Project retrospectively reports 2.4 exaFLOPS peak in 2020; aggregate application throughput, not one shared-memory brain emulator or LINPACK score.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K053", "familyId": "K053", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K053", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Idle Internet PCs form virtual supercomputers", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Idle Internet PCs form virtual supercomputers", "successCriteria": "Internet volunteers pool unused computation into virtual parallel systems reaching the stated approximately 20-petaflop scale.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "P01 printed p.30, Computers #23", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P01", "id": "P01-0", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.. Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices." }, { "sourceId": "N32", "id": "N32-1", "title": "Folding@home: Distributed computing and pandemic peak", "url": "https://foldingathome.org/science/folding", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Project retrospectively reports 2.4 exaFLOPS peak in 2020; aggregate application throughput, not one shared-memory brain emulator or LINPACK score.. Project retrospectively reports 2.4 exaFLOPS peak in 2020; aggregate application throughput, not one shared-memory brain emulator or LINPACK score." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target. Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict LATE. Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target. Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Internet volunteers pool unused computation into virtual parallel systems reaching the stated approximately 20-petaflop scale.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target. Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2020,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"N32\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Internet volunteers pool unused computation into virtual parallel systems reaching the stated approximately 20-petaflop scale.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target. Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2020,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"N32\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Distributed volunteer computing is an established useful architecture without the brain-scale throughput threshold.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"This architectural direction was fulfilled before 2009.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"20-petaflop threshold\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"N32\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2020,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2020; after 2009, no later than 2020\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K053\",\"slug\":\"k053-idle-internet-pcs-form-virtual-supercomputers\",\"title\":\"Idle Internet PCs form virtual supercomputers\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Idle Internet PCs form virtual supercomputers\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K053\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_RETROSPECTIVE_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Internet volunteers pool unused computation into virtual parallel systems reaching the stated approximately 20-petaflop scale.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Volunteer computing was already real, but the 2010 retrospective’s cited throughput was below the 20-petaflop target. Folding@home’s documented 2020 exascale aggregate easily exceeds that numerical threshold. It remains distributed task throughput, not a single brain emulator.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2020,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"P01 printed p.30, Computers #23\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N32\",\"locator\":\"Project retrospectively reports 2.4 exaFLOPS peak in 2020; aggregate application throughput, not one shared-memory brain emulator or LINPACK score.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Interest and practical work on neural/evolutionary methods increase while conventional computation remains important.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development. The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development.", "at_review_rationale": "The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N60", "N35" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Interest and practical work on neural/evolutionary methods increase while conventional computation remains important.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development. The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development.", "at_review_rationale": "The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N60", "N35" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Interest and practical work on neural/evolutionary methods increase while conventional computation remains important.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development. The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development.", "at_review_rationale": "The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N60", "N35" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2009, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2009", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K054", "slug": "k054-interest-in-neural-methods-grows", "title": "Interest in neural methods grows", "prediction_paraphrase": "Interest in neural methods grows", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "AI & software", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "TREND", "family_id": "K054", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_RETROSPECTIVE_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Interest and practical work on neural/evolutionary methods increase while conventional computation remains important.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development.", "at_review_rationale": "The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development. The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2009, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "P01 printed p.31, Computers #24", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N60", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N35", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "One paper alone is not a complete bibliometric series. This qualitative directional assessment does not independently quantify the genetic-algorithm component or the share of all instructions executed.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K054", "familyId": "K054", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K054", "category": "AI & software", "tags": [], "claimType": "TREND", "importedClaim": "Interest in neural methods grows", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Interest in neural methods grows", "successCriteria": "Interest and practical work on neural/evolutionary methods increase while conventional computation remains important.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P01", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "locator": "P01 printed p.31, Computers #24", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N60", "id": "N60-0", "title": "Hinton, Osindero and Teh: Fast learning for deep belief nets", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16764513/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." }, { "sourceId": "N35", "id": "N35-1", "title": "Krizhevsky et al.: ImageNet Classification with Deep Convolutional Neural Networks", "url": "https://papers.nips.cc/paper/4824-imagenet-classification-with-deep-convolutional-neural-networks", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development. The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "One paper alone is not a complete bibliometric series. This qualitative directional assessment does not independently quantify the genetic-algorithm component or the share of all instructions executed.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development. The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Interest and practical work on neural/evolutionary methods increase while conventional computation remains important.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development. The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N60\",\"N35\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Interest and practical work on neural/evolutionary methods increase while conventional computation remains important.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development. The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N60\",\"N35\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Interest and practical work on neural/evolutionary methods increase while conventional computation remains important.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development. The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N60\",\"N35\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2009\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K054\",\"slug\":\"k054-interest-in-neural-methods-grows\",\"title\":\"Interest in neural methods grows\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Interest in neural methods grows\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"AI & software\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"TREND\",\"family_id\":\"K054\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_RETROSPECTIVE_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Interest and practical work on neural/evolutionary methods increase while conventional computation remains important.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The 2006 deep-belief-net paper is a concrete pre-deadline advance consistent with renewed neural-method development. The 2012 ImageNet result and subsequent AI systems decisively reinforce the broad direction; no majority-of-all-computation threshold is imposed on this weaker claim.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2009,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"P01 printed p.31, Computers #24\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N60\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N35\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"One paper alone is not a complete bibliometric series. This qualitative directional assessment does not independently quantify the genetic-algorithm component or the share of all instructions executed.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Owner recognition by a built-in camera becomes a reliable routine consumer-computing function.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009. Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2017, "at_deadline_rationale": "Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "N44" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Owner recognition by a built-in camera becomes a reliable routine consumer-computing function.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009. Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2017, "at_deadline_rationale": "Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "N44" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Owner recognition by a built-in camera becomes a reliable routine consumer-computing function.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009. Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2017, "at_deadline_rationale": "Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "P01", "N44" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2017, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2017; after 2009, no later than 2017", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K055", "slug": "k055-computer-cameras-recognize-their-owners", "title": "Computer cameras recognize their owners", "prediction_paraphrase": "Computer cameras recognize their owners", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "AI & software", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K055", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Owner recognition by a built-in camera becomes a reliable routine consumer-computing function.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "LATE", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009. Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2017, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 2009 Computers and communications, camera paragraph", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N44", "locator": "Announced September, retail availability November 3, 2017. Documented secure everyday owner recognition; not first-ever face recognition.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "A stronger ordinary-use and security threshold than a lab recognizer is stated explicitly. Initial webcam availability was not the missing part.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K055", "familyId": "K055", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K055", "category": "AI & software", "tags": [], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Computer cameras recognize their owners", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Computer cameras recognize their owners", "successCriteria": "Owner recognition by a built-in camera becomes a reliable routine consumer-computing function.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 2009 Computers and communications, camera paragraph", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "P01", "id": "P01-0", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.. Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices." }, { "sourceId": "N44", "id": "N44-1", "title": "Apple: iPhone X and Face ID", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2017/09/the-future-is-here-iphone-x/", "publishedAt": "2017-09-12", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Announced September, retail availability November 3, 2017. Documented secure everyday owner recognition; not first-ever face recognition.. Announced September, retail availability November 3, 2017. Documented secure everyday owner recognition; not first-ever face recognition." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009. Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "A stronger ordinary-use and security threshold than a lab recognizer is stated explicitly. Initial webcam availability was not the missing part.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict LATE. Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009. Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Owner recognition by a built-in camera becomes a reliable routine consumer-computing function.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009. Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2017,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"N44\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Owner recognition by a built-in camera becomes a reliable routine consumer-computing function.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009. Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2017,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"N44\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Owner recognition by a built-in camera becomes a reliable routine consumer-computing function.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009. Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2017,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"P01\",\"N44\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2017,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2017; after 2009, no later than 2017\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K055\",\"slug\":\"k055-computer-cameras-recognize-their-owners\",\"title\":\"Computer cameras recognize their owners\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Computer cameras recognize their owners\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"AI & software\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K055\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Owner recognition by a built-in camera becomes a reliable routine consumer-computing function.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Webcams and face recognition existed, but reliable everyday authentication was not yet routine across ordinary personal devices in 2009. Face ID on the shipping 2017 iPhone X is a clear practical implementation. This establishes late realization without claiming that it was the first face-recognition computer.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2017,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 2009 Computers and communications, camera paragraph\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N44\",\"locator\":\"Announced September, retail availability November 3, 2017. Documented secure everyday owner recognition; not first-ever face recognition.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"A stronger ordinary-use and security threshold than a lab recognizer is stated explicitly. Initial webcam availability was not the missing part.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Students typically have their own thin, readable tablet computer weighing less than one pound.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form. NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form.", "at_review_rationale": "NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N33", "N45" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Students typically have their own thin, readable tablet computer weighing less than one pound.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form. NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form.", "at_review_rationale": "NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N33", "N45" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Students generally have access to a portable connected device for learning, regardless of ownership or weight.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "US schools’ broad device provision by 2021–22 fulfills this more functional access criterion.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Own device", "Tablet form and sub-pound weight", "Global scope limited to US school evidence" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2022, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N33", "N45" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K056", "slug": "k056-students-carry-personal-sub-pound-tablets", "title": "Students carry personal sub-pound tablets", "prediction_paraphrase": "Students carry personal sub-pound tablets", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K056", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Students typically have their own thin, readable tablet computer weighing less than one pound.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form.", "at_review_rationale": "NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form. NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Education in 2009, opening paragraph", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N33", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N45", "locator": "96% of public schools provided devices to students who needed them by 2021–22; 23% assigned take-home devices to all students before COVID. Not proof every student owned a sub-pound tablet.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "US school data are not a worldwide student census. “Students have devices when needed” and “every student owns a specified tablet” are kept separate.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K056", "familyId": "K056", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K056", "category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Students carry personal sub-pound tablets", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Students carry personal sub-pound tablets", "successCriteria": "Students typically have their own thin, readable tablet computer weighing less than one pound.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Education in 2009, opening paragraph", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N33", "id": "N33-0", "title": "NCES: Teachers’ use of educational technology in 2009", "url": "https://ies.ed.gov/use-work/resource-library/report/first-look-ed-tab/teachers-use-educational-technology-u-s-public-schools-2009", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." }, { "sourceId": "N45", "id": "N45-1", "title": "NCES: School technology support during COVID", "url": "https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/annualreports/topical-studies/covid/theme/elementary-and-secondary-education-technology-support/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "96% of public schools provided devices to students who needed them by 2021–22; 23% assigned take-home devices to all students before COVID. Not proof every student owned a sub-pound tablet.. 96% of public schools provided devices to students who needed them by 2021–22; 23% assigned take-home devices to all students before COVID. Not proof every student owned a sub-pound tablet." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form. NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.", "alternativeInterpretation": "US school data are not a worldwide student census. “Students have devices when needed” and “every student owns a specified tablet” are kept separate.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "US school data are not a worldwide student census. “Students have devices when needed” and “every student owns a specified tablet” are kept separate.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form. NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Students typically have their own thin, readable tablet computer weighing less than one pound.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form. NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N33\",\"N45\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Students typically have their own thin, readable tablet computer weighing less than one pound.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form. NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N33\",\"N45\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Students generally have access to a portable connected device for learning, regardless of ownership or weight.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"US schools’ broad device provision by 2021–22 fulfills this more functional access criterion.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Own device\",\"Tablet form and sub-pound weight\",\"Global scope limited to US school evidence\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2022,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N33\",\"N45\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K056\",\"slug\":\"k056-students-carry-personal-sub-pound-tablets\",\"title\":\"Students carry personal sub-pound tablets\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Students carry personal sub-pound tablets\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Media, education & culture\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K056\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Students typically have their own thin, readable tablet computer weighing less than one pound.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The 2009 school-technology picture does not support typical one-device-per-child ownership, much less the specified tablet weight/form. NCES documents extensive school device provision by 2021–22, but that includes loaned laptops and heavier devices; the complete form/ownership claim remains partial.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Education in 2009, opening paragraph\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N33\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N45\",\"locator\":\"96% of public schools provided devices to students who needed them by 2021–22; 23% assigned take-home devices to all students before COVID. Not proof every student owned a sub-pound tablet.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"US school data are not a worldwide student census. “Students have devices when needed” and “every student owns a specified tablet” are kept separate.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Learners can ordinarily obtain educational content through wireless Internet access.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route. This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route.", "at_review_rationale": "This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N43", "O09" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Learners can ordinarily obtain educational content through wireless Internet access.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route. This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route.", "at_review_rationale": "This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N43", "O09" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Learners can ordinarily obtain educational content through wireless Internet access.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route. This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route.", "at_review_rationale": "This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N43", "O09" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2009, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2009", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K057", "slug": "k057-learning-materials-arrive-wirelessly", "title": "Learning materials arrive wirelessly", "prediction_paraphrase": "Learning materials arrive wirelessly", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K057", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Learners can ordinarily obtain educational content through wireless Internet access.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route.", "at_review_rationale": "This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route. This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2009, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Education in 2009, learning-materials bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N43", "locator": "Free lectures and educational material from major universities; Wi-Fi-capable computers establish wireless access but not wireless prevalence at every school.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "O09", "locator": "US adult survey. Ever-used wireless access is not a majority-of-traffic measure and is not global coverage.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K057", "familyId": "K057", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K057", "category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Learning materials arrive wirelessly", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Learning materials arrive wirelessly", "successCriteria": "Learners can ordinarily obtain educational content through wireless Internet access.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Education in 2009, learning-materials bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N43", "id": "N43-0", "title": "Apple: iTunes U opens on the iTunes Store", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2007/05/30Apple-Announces-iTunes-U-on-the-iTunes-Store/", "publishedAt": "2007-05-30", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Free lectures and educational material from major universities; Wi-Fi-capable computers establish wireless access but not wireless prevalence at every school.. Free lectures and educational material from major universities; Wi-Fi-capable computers establish wireless access but not wireless prevalence at every school." }, { "sourceId": "O09", "id": "O09-1", "title": "Wireless Internet Use — Pew Research Center", "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2009/07/22/wireless-internet-use/", "publishedAt": "2009-07-22", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "US adult survey. Ever-used wireless access is not a majority-of-traffic measure and is not global coverage.. US adult survey. Ever-used wireless access is not a majority-of-traffic measure and is not global coverage." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route. This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route. This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Learners can ordinarily obtain educational content through wireless Internet access.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route. This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N43\",\"O09\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Learners can ordinarily obtain educational content through wireless Internet access.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route. This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N43\",\"O09\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Learners can ordinarily obtain educational content through wireless Internet access.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route. This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N43\",\"O09\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2009\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K057\",\"slug\":\"k057-learning-materials-arrive-wirelessly\",\"title\":\"Learning materials arrive wirelessly\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Learning materials arrive wirelessly\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Media, education & culture\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K057\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Learners can ordinarily obtain educational content through wireless Internet access.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"iTunes U distributed university material in 2007; contemporary wireless access and connected portable computers supplied the delivery route. This is an availability/distribution claim, not a claim that every course or school has discarded physical books.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2009,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Education in 2009, learning-materials bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N43\",\"locator\":\"Free lectures and educational material from major universities; Wi-Fi-capable computers establish wireless access but not wireless prevalence at every school.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"O09\",\"locator\":\"US adult survey. Ever-used wireless access is not a majority-of-traffic measure and is not global coverage.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Software supplies enough instruction that teachers primarily handle motivation, well-being and socialization.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009. Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N33", "N22", "N45" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Software supplies enough instruction that teachers primarily handle motivation, well-being and socialization.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009. Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N33", "N22", "N45" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Software supports instruction and lets teachers spend some more attention on mentoring.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The direction of classroom augmentation was already present by 2009.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Primarily mentoring rather than instructing" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N33", "N22", "N45" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K058", "slug": "k058-teachers-shift-mainly-to-mentoring", "title": "Teachers shift mainly to mentoring", "prediction_paraphrase": "Teachers shift mainly to mentoring", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K058", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Software supplies enough instruction that teachers primarily handle motivation, well-being and socialization.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009. Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Education in 2009, final bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N33", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N22", "locator": "Institutional context on continuing human teachers, shortages and AI assistance. Normative guidance is not a statistical census of all learning hours.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N45", "locator": "96% of public schools provided devices to students who needed them by 2021–22; 23% assigned take-home devices to all students before COVID. Not proof every student owned a sub-pound tablet.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Qualitative role judgment, not a measured global allocation of teacher minutes. UNESCO’s guidance is context, not by itself proof of adoption rates.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K058", "familyId": "K058", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K058", "category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Teachers shift mainly to mentoring", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Teachers shift mainly to mentoring", "successCriteria": "Software supplies enough instruction that teachers primarily handle motivation, well-being and socialization.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Education in 2009, final bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N33", "id": "N33-0", "title": "NCES: Teachers’ use of educational technology in 2009", "url": "https://ies.ed.gov/use-work/resource-library/report/first-look-ed-tab/teachers-use-educational-technology-u-s-public-schools-2009", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." }, { "sourceId": "N22", "id": "N22-1", "title": "UNESCO: Teachers cannot be coded", "url": "https://www.unesco.org/en/teachers-cannot-be-coded", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Institutional context on continuing human teachers, shortages and AI assistance. Normative guidance is not a statistical census of all learning hours.. Institutional context on continuing human teachers, shortages and AI assistance. Normative guidance is not a statistical census of all learning hours." }, { "sourceId": "N45", "id": "N45-2", "title": "NCES: School technology support during COVID", "url": "https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/annualreports/topical-studies/covid/theme/elementary-and-secondary-education-technology-support/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "96% of public schools provided devices to students who needed them by 2021–22; 23% assigned take-home devices to all students before COVID. Not proof every student owned a sub-pound tablet.. 96% of public schools provided devices to students who needed them by 2021–22; 23% assigned take-home devices to all students before COVID. Not proof every student owned a sub-pound tablet." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009. Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Qualitative role judgment, not a measured global allocation of teacher minutes. UNESCO’s guidance is context, not by itself proof of adoption rates.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Qualitative role judgment, not a measured global allocation of teacher minutes. UNESCO’s guidance is context, not by itself proof of adoption rates.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009. Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Software supplies enough instruction that teachers primarily handle motivation, well-being and socialization.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009. Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N33\",\"N22\",\"N45\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Software supplies enough instruction that teachers primarily handle motivation, well-being and socialization.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009. Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N33\",\"N22\",\"N45\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Software supports instruction and lets teachers spend some more attention on mentoring.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The direction of classroom augmentation was already present by 2009.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Primarily mentoring rather than instructing\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N33\",\"N22\",\"N45\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K058\",\"slug\":\"k058-teachers-shift-mainly-to-mentoring\",\"title\":\"Teachers shift mainly to mentoring\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Teachers shift mainly to mentoring\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Media, education & culture\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K058\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Software supplies enough instruction that teachers primarily handle motivation, well-being and socialization.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Classroom software was real, but the human teacher’s principal instructional role had not generally been displaced in 2009. Digital materials and AI help instruction, yet human teachers remain central knowledge instructors. The claimed role rebalancing remains partial, not merely awaiting a perfect survey.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Education in 2009, final bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N33\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N22\",\"locator\":\"Institutional context on continuing human teachers, shortages and AI assistance. Normative guidance is not a statistical census of all learning hours.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N45\",\"locator\":\"96% of public schools provided devices to students who needed them by 2021–22; 23% assigned take-home devices to all students before COVID. Not proof every student owned a sub-pound tablet.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Qualitative role judgment, not a measured global allocation of teacher minutes. UNESCO’s guidance is context, not by itself proof of adoption rates.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Online purchase transactions dominate ordinary consumer commerce; retail sales value is the stated empirical proxy.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation. The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation.", "at_review_rationale": "The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N30", "N31" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Online purchase transactions dominate ordinary consumer commerce; retail sales value is the stated empirical proxy.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation. The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation.", "at_review_rationale": "The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N30", "N31" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Many forms of commercial transactions are digitally processed, including offline-origin transactions.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Digital transaction handling is widespread, but this changes online purchasing into electronic processing and supplies no comparable majority-count denominator.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Online purchasing versus electronic processing", "Consumer retail versus all financial activity" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N30", "N31" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K059", "slug": "k059-at-least-half-of-transactions-occur-online", "title": "At least half of transactions occur online", "prediction_paraphrase": "At least half of transactions occur online", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Economy & society", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K059", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Online purchase transactions dominate ordinary consumer commerce; retail sales value is the stated empirical proxy.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation.", "at_review_rationale": "The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation. The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Business in 2009, first bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N30", "locator": "2009 retail e-commerce share about 3.7% by value. US consumer retail proxy, not all worldwide transactions or number of payments.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N31", "locator": "Second quarter 2026 e-commerce share 17.1% of retail sales by value. Not B2B, securities trading, or a count of all transactions.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "This is an explicit proxy-based conditional miss, not a false claim to measure all global transactions. Value share differs from transaction count. Reference confidence is medium; display that limitation next to the verdict.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K059", "familyId": "K059", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K059", "category": "Economy & society", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "At least half of transactions occur online", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "At least half of transactions occur online", "successCriteria": "Online purchase transactions dominate ordinary consumer commerce; retail sales value is the stated empirical proxy.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Business in 2009, first bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N30", "id": "N30-0", "title": "US Census: Retail e-commerce, fourth quarter 2009", "url": "https://www2.census.gov/historical/ecomm/09q4.html", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "2009 retail e-commerce share about 3.7% by value. US consumer retail proxy, not all worldwide transactions or number of payments.. 2009 retail e-commerce share about 3.7% by value. US consumer retail proxy, not all worldwide transactions or number of payments." }, { "sourceId": "N31", "id": "N31-1", "title": "US Census: Quarterly retail e-commerce, 2026", "url": "https://www.census.gov/retail/eCommerce.html", "publishedAt": "2026-08-18", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Second quarter 2026 e-commerce share 17.1% of retail sales by value. Not B2B, securities trading, or a count of all transactions.. Second quarter 2026 e-commerce share 17.1% of retail sales by value. Not B2B, securities trading, or a count of all transactions." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation. The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.", "alternativeInterpretation": "This is an explicit proxy-based conditional miss, not a false claim to measure all global transactions. Value share differs from transaction count. Reference confidence is medium; display that limitation next to the verdict.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "This is an explicit proxy-based conditional miss, not a false claim to measure all global transactions. Value share differs from transaction count. Reference confidence is medium; display that limitation next to the verdict.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation. The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Online purchase transactions dominate ordinary consumer commerce; retail sales value is the stated empirical proxy.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation. The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N30\",\"N31\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Online purchase transactions dominate ordinary consumer commerce; retail sales value is the stated empirical proxy.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation. The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N30\",\"N31\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Many forms of commercial transactions are digitally processed, including offline-origin transactions.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Digital transaction handling is widespread, but this changes online purchasing into electronic processing and supplies no comparable majority-count denominator.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Online purchasing versus electronic processing\",\"Consumer retail versus all financial activity\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N30\",\"N31\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K059\",\"slug\":\"k059-at-least-half-of-transactions-occur-online\",\"title\":\"At least half of transactions occur online\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"At least half of transactions occur online\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Economy & society\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K059\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Online purchase transactions dominate ordinary consumer commerce; retail sales value is the stated empirical proxy.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"US retail e-commerce was only about 3.7% of retail sales in 2009, far from a half-share consumer-commerce interpretation. The 2026 Q2 US share was 17.1%, still below half. This does not decide whether a different denominator including interbank, stock-market or B2B messages might pass.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Business in 2009, first bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N30\",\"locator\":\"2009 retail e-commerce share about 3.7% by value. US consumer retail proxy, not all worldwide transactions or number of payments.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N31\",\"locator\":\"Second quarter 2026 e-commerce share 17.1% of retail sales by value. Not B2B, securities trading, or a count of all transactions.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"This is an explicit proxy-based conditional miss, not a false claim to measure all global transactions. Value share differs from transaction count. Reference confidence is medium; display that limitation next to the verdict.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "A strong practical trend toward geographically distributed collaboration emerges.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online. Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2007, "at_deadline_rationale": "Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online.", "at_review_rationale": "Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N42", "N46" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "A strong practical trend toward geographically distributed collaboration emerges.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online. Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2007, "at_deadline_rationale": "Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online.", "at_review_rationale": "Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N42", "N46" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "A strong practical trend toward geographically distributed collaboration emerges.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online. Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2007, "at_deadline_rationale": "Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online.", "at_review_rationale": "Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N42", "N46" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2007, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2007", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K060", "slug": "k060-work-groups-become-geographically-distributed", "title": "Work groups become geographically distributed", "prediction_paraphrase": "Work groups become geographically distributed", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Economy & society", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "TREND", "family_id": "K060", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "A strong practical trend toward geographically distributed collaboration emerges.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online.", "at_review_rationale": "Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online. Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2007, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Business in 2009, geographically separated work-groups bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N42", "locator": "WebEx had more than 2.2 million registered users; evidence of established distributed collaboration, not most employees working from home.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N46", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K060", "familyId": "K060", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K060", "category": "Economy & society", "tags": [], "claimType": "TREND", "importedClaim": "Work groups become geographically distributed", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Work groups become geographically distributed", "successCriteria": "A strong practical trend toward geographically distributed collaboration emerges.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Business in 2009, geographically separated work-groups bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N42", "id": "N42-0", "title": "Cisco announces acquisition of WebEx", "url": "https://newsroom.cisco.com/c/r/newsroom/en/us/a/y2007/m03/cisco-announces-agreement-to-acquire-webex.html", "publishedAt": "2007-03-15", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "WebEx had more than 2.2 million registered users; evidence of established distributed collaboration, not most employees working from home.. WebEx had more than 2.2 million registered users; evidence of established distributed collaboration, not most employees working from home." }, { "sourceId": "N46", "id": "N46-1", "title": "Microsoft Teams reaches 13 million daily active users", "url": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/blog/2019/07/11/microsoft-teams-reaches-13-million-daily-active-users-introduces-4-new-ways-for-teams-to-work-better-together/", "publishedAt": "2019-07-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online. Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online. Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"A strong practical trend toward geographically distributed collaboration emerges.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online. Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2007,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N42\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"A strong practical trend toward geographically distributed collaboration emerges.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online. Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2007,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N42\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"A strong practical trend toward geographically distributed collaboration emerges.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online. Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2007,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N42\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2007,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2007\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K060\",\"slug\":\"k060-work-groups-become-geographically-distributed\",\"title\":\"Work groups become geographically distributed\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Work groups become geographically distributed\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Economy & society\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"TREND\",\"family_id\":\"K060\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"A strong practical trend toward geographically distributed collaboration emerges.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Cisco’s 2007 WebEx acquisition described more than 2.2 million registered users collaborating online. Teams’ 2019 usage further substantiates the direction. The forecast does not require most workers to work remotely or the end of offices.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2007,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Business in 2009, geographically separated work-groups bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N42\",\"locator\":\"WebEx had more than 2.2 million registered users; evidence of established distributed collaboration, not most employees working from home.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N46\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Useful household robots are commercially established but not yet universally accepted.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category. The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category.", "at_review_rationale": "The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N52", "N21" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Useful household robots are commercially established but not yet universally accepted.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category. The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category.", "at_review_rationale": "The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N52", "N21" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Useful household robots are commercially established but not yet universally accepted.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category. The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "at_deadline_rationale": "Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category.", "at_review_rationale": "The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N52", "N21" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2009, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2009", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K061", "slug": "k061-household-robots-emerge-before-full-acceptance", "title": "Household robots emerge before full acceptance", "prediction_paraphrase": "Household robots emerge before full acceptance", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Robotics & transportation", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K061", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Useful household robots are commercially established but not yet universally accepted.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category.", "at_review_rationale": "The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category. The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2009, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Business in 2009, household-robots bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N52", "locator": "January 2010 retrospective on robots launched in 2002 and already commercially established in the 2000s; do not shift the threshold by one year just because the tally was announced in January.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N21", "locator": "23.2 million consumer/domestic service robots sold in 2019, +34%. Annual sales are not household penetration or a count of robot-owning homes.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "The January 2010 tally is retrospective evidence, not a reason to treat the entire 2000s robot emergence as late. This is distinct from the stronger 2019 ubiquity forecast K080.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K061", "familyId": "K061", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K061", "category": "Robotics & transportation", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Household robots emerge before full acceptance", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Household robots emerge before full acceptance", "successCriteria": "Useful household robots are commercially established but not yet universally accepted.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Business in 2009, household-robots bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N52", "id": "N52-0", "title": "iRobot: More than five million home robots sold", "url": "https://investor.irobot.com/news-releases/news-release-details/irobot-achieves-milestone-home-robot-market", "publishedAt": "2010-01-05", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "January 2010 retrospective on robots launched in 2002 and already commercially established in the 2000s; do not shift the threshold by one year just because the tally was announced in January.. January 2010 retrospective on robots launched in 2002 and already commercially established in the 2000s; do not shift the threshold by one year just because the tally was announced in January." }, { "sourceId": "N21", "id": "N21-1", "title": "IFR: Service robots record sales worldwide", "url": "https://ifr.org/ifr-press-releases/news/service-robots-record-sales-worldwide-up-32", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "23.2 million consumer/domestic service robots sold in 2019, +34%. Annual sales are not household penetration or a count of robot-owning homes.. 23.2 million consumer/domestic service robots sold in 2019, +34%. Annual sales are not household penetration or a count of robot-owning homes." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category. The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "The January 2010 tally is retrospective evidence, not a reason to treat the entire 2000s robot emergence as late. This is distinct from the stronger 2019 ubiquity forecast K080.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category. The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Useful household robots are commercially established but not yet universally accepted.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category. The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N52\",\"N21\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Useful household robots are commercially established but not yet universally accepted.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category. The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N52\",\"N21\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Useful household robots are commercially established but not yet universally accepted.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category. The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N52\",\"N21\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2009\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K061\",\"slug\":\"k061-household-robots-emerge-before-full-acceptance\",\"title\":\"Household robots emerge before full acceptance\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Household robots emerge before full acceptance\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Robotics & transportation\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K061\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Useful household robots are commercially established but not yet universally accepted.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Roomba launched in 2002 and iRobot reported five million home robots sold just after the 2009 year-end; this confirms a substantial pre-deadline product category. The existence/emergence claim was met. Later broader adoption does not retroactively invalidate the accurate early-stage description.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2009,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Business in 2009, household-robots bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N52\",\"locator\":\"January 2010 retrospective on robots launched in 2002 and already commercially established in the 2000s; do not shift the threshold by one year just because the tally was announced in January.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N21\",\"locator\":\"23.2 million consumer/domestic service robots sold in 2019, +34%. Annual sales are not household penetration or a count of robot-owning homes.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"The January 2010 tally is retrospective evidence, not a reason to treat the entire 2000s robot emergence as late. This is distinct from the stronger 2019 ubiquity forecast K080.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Remote examinations using sight, sound and tactile sensing are widely used.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009. The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N19", "N41" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Remote examinations using sight, sound and tactile sensing are widely used.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009. The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N19", "N41" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Visual/audio telemedicine is widely used, with tactile capability an optional extension.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Audio/video use reached an unmistakably common level by 2021.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Widespread haptic examination" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2021, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N19", "N41" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K062", "slug": "k062-telemedicine-includes-remote-tactile-examinations", "title": "Telemedicine includes remote tactile examinations", "prediction_paraphrase": "Telemedicine includes remote tactile examinations", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Biology & medicine", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K062", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Remote examinations using sight, sound and tactile sensing are widely used.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009. The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Health care in 2009, telemedicine bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N19", "locator": "37% of US adults used phone or video telemedicine in 2021. Does not establish widespread tactile remote examination.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N41", "locator": "Describes 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake and networked force feedback; supports emerging remote touch, not full-body realism.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Does not infer telemedicine efficacy or recommend care. The input-modality difference is material and remains visible.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K062", "familyId": "K062", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K062", "category": "Biology & medicine", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Telemedicine includes remote tactile examinations", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Telemedicine includes remote tactile examinations", "successCriteria": "Remote examinations using sight, sound and tactile sensing are widely used.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Health care in 2009, telemedicine bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N19", "id": "N19-0", "title": "CDC: Telemedicine use among adults, United States, 2021", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db445.htm", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "37% of US adults used phone or video telemedicine in 2021. Does not establish widespread tactile remote examination.. 37% of US adults used phone or video telemedicine in 2021. Does not establish widespread tactile remote examination." }, { "sourceId": "N41", "id": "N41-1", "title": "Paterson: Feel the Presence—Technologies of Touch and Distance", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1068/d394t", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Describes 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake and networked force feedback; supports emerging remote touch, not full-body realism.. Describes 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake and networked force feedback; supports emerging remote touch, not full-body realism." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009. The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Does not infer telemedicine efficacy or recommend care. The input-modality difference is material and remains visible.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Does not infer telemedicine efficacy or recommend care. The input-modality difference is material and remains visible.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009. The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Remote examinations using sight, sound and tactile sensing are widely used.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009. The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N19\",\"N41\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Remote examinations using sight, sound and tactile sensing are widely used.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009. The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N19\",\"N41\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Visual/audio telemedicine is widely used, with tactile capability an optional extension.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Audio/video use reached an unmistakably common level by 2021.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Widespread haptic examination\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2021,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N19\",\"N41\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K062\",\"slug\":\"k062-telemedicine-includes-remote-tactile-examinations\",\"title\":\"Telemedicine includes remote tactile examinations\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Telemedicine includes remote tactile examinations\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Biology & medicine\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K062\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Remote examinations using sight, sound and tactile sensing are widely used.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Audio/video telemedicine and remote-device demonstrations did not make the full visual-auditory-haptic package widespread in 2009. The 37% US adult telemedicine-use figure for 2021 establishes ordinary audio/video care, but not widespread remotely conveyed tactile examination.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Health care in 2009, telemedicine bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N19\",\"locator\":\"37% of US adults used phone or video telemedicine in 2021. Does not establish widespread tactile remote examination.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N41\",\"locator\":\"Describes 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake and networked force feedback; supports emerging remote touch, not full-body realism.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Does not infer telemedicine efficacy or recommend care. The input-modality difference is material and remains visible.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Computer pattern recognition is used routinely in important diagnostic imaging workflows.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow. This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2008, "at_deadline_rationale": "Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow.", "at_review_rationale": "This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N18" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Computer pattern recognition is used routinely in important diagnostic imaging workflows.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow. This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2008, "at_deadline_rationale": "Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow.", "at_review_rationale": "This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N18" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Computer pattern recognition is used routinely in important diagnostic imaging workflows.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow. This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2008, "at_deadline_rationale": "Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow.", "at_review_rationale": "This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N18" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2008, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2008", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K063", "slug": "k063-pattern-recognition-becomes-routine-in-medical-imaging", "title": "Pattern recognition becomes routine in medical imaging", "prediction_paraphrase": "Pattern recognition becomes routine in medical imaging", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Biology & medicine", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K063", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Computer pattern recognition is used routinely in important diagnostic imaging workflows.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow.", "at_review_rationale": "This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow. This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2008, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Health care in 2009, pattern-recognition bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N18", "locator": "Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008. Routine use is established, not improved accuracy or autonomous diagnosis.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Medicare screening mammography is a documented substantial use case, not evidence all imaging was automated or that CAD was superior to clinicians.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K063", "familyId": "K063", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K063", "category": "Biology & medicine", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Pattern recognition becomes routine in medical imaging", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Pattern recognition becomes routine in medical imaging", "successCriteria": "Computer pattern recognition is used routinely in important diagnostic imaging workflows.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Health care in 2009, pattern-recognition bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N18", "id": "N18-0", "title": "Rao et al.: Trends in utilization of CAD mammography, 2004–2008", "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1546144010002735", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008. Routine use is established, not improved accuracy or autonomous diagnosis.. Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008. Routine use is established, not improved accuracy or autonomous diagnosis." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow. This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Medicare screening mammography is a documented substantial use case, not evidence all imaging was automated or that CAD was superior to clinicians.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow. This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Computer pattern recognition is used routinely in important diagnostic imaging workflows.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow. This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2008,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N18\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Computer pattern recognition is used routinely in important diagnostic imaging workflows.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow. This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2008,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N18\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Computer pattern recognition is used routinely in important diagnostic imaging workflows.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow. This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2008,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N18\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2008,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2008\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K063\",\"slug\":\"k063-pattern-recognition-becomes-routine-in-medical-imaging\",\"title\":\"Pattern recognition becomes routine in medical imaging\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Pattern recognition becomes routine in medical imaging\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Biology & medicine\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K063\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Computer pattern recognition is used routinely in important diagnostic imaging workflows.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008, a concrete routine clinical workflow. This fulfills routine use even though CAD does not always improve outcomes. It does not require autonomous diagnosis in every specialty.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2008,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Health care in 2009, pattern-recognition bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N18\",\"locator\":\"Computer-aided detection accompanied 74% of Medicare screening mammograms in 2008. Routine use is established, not improved accuracy or autonomous diagnosis.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Medicare screening mammography is a documented substantial use case, not evidence all imaging was automated or that CAD was superior to clinicians.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Longitudinal patient histories are ordinarily kept digitally; “lifetime” means accumulating records over a patient’s life, not retroactive digitization of every scrap.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized. By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2014, "at_deadline_rationale": "EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized.", "at_review_rationale": "By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N17" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Longitudinal patient histories are ordinarily kept digitally; “lifetime” means accumulating records over a patient’s life, not retroactive digitization of every scrap.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized. By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "SAME_AS_REFERENCE", "documented_by_year": 2014, "at_deadline_rationale": "EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized.", "at_review_rationale": "By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N17" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Longitudinal patient histories are ordinarily kept digitally; “lifetime” means accumulating records over a patient’s life, not retroactive digitization of every scrap.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized. By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2014, "at_deadline_rationale": "EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized.", "at_review_rationale": "By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N17" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "non_scoring_comparators": [ { "criterion": "Each person has a complete interoperable cradle-to-grave record spanning all providers.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "rationale": "EHR adoption does not establish complete lifetime coverage or interoperability. The stronger literal completeness reading remains partial.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "same_as_reference": false, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N17" ], "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "eligible_for_author_accuracy": false, "comparator_warning": "Stronger than the located wording; not an obligation of the original forecast and excluded from accuracy calculations." } ], "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2014, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2014; after 2009, no later than 2014", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K064", "slug": "k064-patient-histories-become-lifelong-digital-records", "title": "Patient histories become lifelong digital records", "prediction_paraphrase": "Patient histories become lifelong digital records", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Biology & medicine", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K064", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Longitudinal patient histories are ordinarily kept digitally; “lifetime” means accumulating records over a patient’s life, not retroactive digitization of every scrap.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized.", "at_review_rationale": "By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "LATE", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized. By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2014, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Health care in 2009, lifetime-records bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N17", "locator": "US series: 2008 hospitals 9%, physicians 17%; 2014 76% and 51%; 2022 99% and 84%. Definitions evolve; adoption does not prove complete interoperable lifetime records.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "US adoption is the explicit evaluation population. Reference does not demand universality, but it also does not claim all historic records are complete or interoperable.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K064", "familyId": "K064", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K064", "category": "Biology & medicine", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Patient histories become lifelong digital records", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Patient histories become lifelong digital records", "successCriteria": "Longitudinal patient histories are ordinarily kept digitally; “lifetime” means accumulating records over a patient’s life, not retroactive digitization of every scrap.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Health care in 2009, lifetime-records bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N17", "id": "N17-0", "title": "ONC: National trends in hospital and physician EHR adoption", "url": "https://healthit.gov/data/quickstats/national-trends-hospital-and-physician-adoption-electronic-health-records/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "US series: 2008 hospitals 9%, physicians 17%; 2014 76% and 51%; 2022 99% and 84%. Definitions evolve; adoption does not prove complete interoperable lifetime records.. US series: 2008 hospitals 9%, physicians 17%; 2014 76% and 51%; 2022 99% and 84%. Definitions evolve; adoption does not prove complete interoperable lifetime records." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized. By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.", "alternativeInterpretation": "US adoption is the explicit evaluation population. Reference does not demand universality, but it also does not claim all historic records are complete or interoperable.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "US adoption is the explicit evaluation population. Reference does not demand universality, but it also does not claim all historic records are complete or interoperable.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict LATE. EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized. By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Longitudinal patient histories are ordinarily kept digitally; “lifetime” means accumulating records over a patient’s life, not retroactive digitization of every scrap.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized. By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2014,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N17\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Longitudinal patient histories are ordinarily kept digitally; “lifetime” means accumulating records over a patient’s life, not retroactive digitization of every scrap.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized. By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"SAME_AS_REFERENCE\",\"documented_by_year\":2014,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N17\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Longitudinal patient histories are ordinarily kept digitally; “lifetime” means accumulating records over a patient’s life, not retroactive digitization of every scrap.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized. By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2014,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N17\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"non_scoring_comparators\":[{\"criterion\":\"Each person has a complete interoperable cradle-to-grave record spanning all providers.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"rationale\":\"EHR adoption does not establish complete lifetime coverage or interoperability. The stronger literal completeness reading remains partial.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"same_as_reference\":false,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N17\"],\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"eligible_for_author_accuracy\":false,\"comparator_warning\":\"Stronger than the located wording; not an obligation of the original forecast and excluded from accuracy calculations.\"}],\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2014,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2014; after 2009, no later than 2014\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K064\",\"slug\":\"k064-patient-histories-become-lifelong-digital-records\",\"title\":\"Patient histories become lifelong digital records\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Patient histories become lifelong digital records\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Biology & medicine\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K064\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Longitudinal patient histories are ordinarily kept digitally; “lifetime” means accumulating records over a patient’s life, not retroactive digitization of every scrap.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"EHR adoption was still low in the 2008–2009 US baseline, so ordinary digital longitudinal records were only partly realized. By 2014 most US hospitals and more than half of physicians had adopted EHRs; subsequent adoption increased. This supports late longitudinal-database fulfillment.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2014,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Health care in 2009, lifetime-records bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N17\",\"locator\":\"US series: 2008 hospitals 9%, physicians 17%; 2014 76% and 51%; 2022 99% and 84%. Definitions evolve; adoption does not prove complete interoperable lifetime records.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"US adoption is the explicit evaluation population. Reference does not demand universality, but it also does not claim all historic records are complete or interoperable.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Computer screens become the prevailing medium for visual-art creation/presentation, with intelligent software collaboration.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability. AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability.", "at_review_rationale": "AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N27", "P01" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Computer screens become the prevailing medium for visual-art creation/presentation, with intelligent software collaboration.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability. AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability.", "at_review_rationale": "AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N27", "P01" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Screens and intelligent tools become a normal major medium for visual creativity.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Digital creation and machine-assisted art clearly meet the less exclusive normal-medium reading.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Preferred medium across all visual art" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2009, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N27", "P01" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K065", "slug": "k065-screens-become-the-preferred-visual-art-medium", "title": "Screens become the preferred visual-art medium", "prediction_paraphrase": "Screens become the preferred visual-art medium", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K065", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Computer screens become the prevailing medium for visual-art creation/presentation, with intelligent software collaboration.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability.", "at_review_rationale": "AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability. AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Arts in 2009, opening bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N27", "locator": "Obvious/GAN portrait sold October 2018 for $432,500. Supports serious institutional attention, not majority adoption by artists.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "P01", "locator": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "This is a mixed adoption judgment, not a claim that physical art’s continued existence alone defeats a majority claim. The relevant market-share denominator is intrinsically diffuse.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K065", "familyId": "K065", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K065", "category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Screens become the preferred visual-art medium", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Screens become the preferred visual-art medium", "successCriteria": "Computer screens become the prevailing medium for visual-art creation/presentation, with intelligent software collaboration.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Arts in 2009, opening bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N27", "id": "N27-0", "title": "Christie’s: Human-machine art collaboration at auction", "url": "https://www.christies.com/stories/a-collaboration-between-two-artists-one-human-one-a-machine-0cd01f4e232f4279a525a446d60d4cd1", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Obvious/GAN portrait sold October 2018 for $432,500. Supports serious institutional attention, not majority adoption by artists.. Obvious/GAN portrait sold October 2018 for $432,500. Supports serious institutional attention, not majority adoption by artists." }, { "sourceId": "P01", "id": "P01-1", "title": "How My Predictions Are Faring — Ray Kurzweil", "url": "https://www.thekurzweillibrary.com/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.. Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability. AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.", "alternativeInterpretation": "This is a mixed adoption judgment, not a claim that physical art’s continued existence alone defeats a majority claim. The relevant market-share denominator is intrinsically diffuse.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "This is a mixed adoption judgment, not a claim that physical art’s continued existence alone defeats a majority claim. The relevant market-share denominator is intrinsically diffuse.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability. AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Computer screens become the prevailing medium for visual-art creation/presentation, with intelligent software collaboration.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability. AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N27\",\"P01\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Computer screens become the prevailing medium for visual-art creation/presentation, with intelligent software collaboration.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability. AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N27\",\"P01\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Screens and intelligent tools become a normal major medium for visual creativity.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Digital creation and machine-assisted art clearly meet the less exclusive normal-medium reading.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Preferred medium across all visual art\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2009,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N27\",\"P01\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K065\",\"slug\":\"k065-screens-become-the-preferred-visual-art-medium\",\"title\":\"Screens become the preferred visual-art medium\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Screens become the preferred visual-art medium\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Media, education & culture\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K065\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Computer screens become the prevailing medium for visual-art creation/presentation, with intelligent software collaboration.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Digital art tools were established, but the broad claim of preference across visual art was stronger than the evidence of availability. AI art receives serious recognition, yet painting, sculpture, print and physical display remain important; there is no defensible universal medium-of-choice ranking here.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Arts in 2009, opening bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N27\",\"locator\":\"Obvious/GAN portrait sold October 2018 for $432,500. Supports serious institutional attention, not majority adoption by artists.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"P01\",\"locator\":\"Official author archive. Cover says October 2010, but the available file contains later updates. Reprinted forecast passages are used for attribution; the author’s favorable self-grades are not independent outcome evidence. Original book editions were not inspected. Page locators below are PRINTED pages, not PDF viewer indices.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"This is a mixed adoption judgment, not a claim that physical art’s continued existence alone defeats a majority claim. The relevant market-share denominator is intrinsically diffuse.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Ordinary people without instrumental training can construct music with software.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship. The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2004, "at_deadline_rationale": "GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship.", "at_review_rationale": "The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N26" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Ordinary people without instrumental training can construct music with software.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship. The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2004, "at_deadline_rationale": "GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship.", "at_review_rationale": "The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N26" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Ordinary people without instrumental training can construct music with software.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship. The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2004, "at_deadline_rationale": "GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship.", "at_review_rationale": "The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N26" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2004, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2004", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K066", "slug": "k066-nonmusicians-compose-music-with-software", "title": "Nonmusicians compose music with software", "prediction_paraphrase": "Nonmusicians compose music with software", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K066", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Ordinary people without instrumental training can construct music with software.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship.", "at_review_rationale": "The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship. The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2004, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Arts in 2009, nonmusicians bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N26", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K066", "familyId": "K066", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K066", "category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Nonmusicians compose music with software", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Nonmusicians compose music with software", "successCriteria": "Ordinary people without instrumental training can construct music with software.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Arts in 2009, nonmusicians bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N26", "id": "N26-0", "title": "Apple introduces GarageBand with iLife 04", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2004/01/06Apple-Announces-iLife-04/", "publishedAt": "2004-01-06", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship. The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship. The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Ordinary people without instrumental training can construct music with software.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship. The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2004,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N26\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Ordinary people without instrumental training can construct music with software.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship. The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2004,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N26\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Ordinary people without instrumental training can construct music with software.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship. The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2004,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N26\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2004,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2004\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K066\",\"slug\":\"k066-nonmusicians-compose-music-with-software\",\"title\":\"Nonmusicians compose music with software\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Nonmusicians compose music with software\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Media, education & culture\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K066\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Ordinary people without instrumental training can construct music with software.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"GarageBand’s 2004 loop/instrument tools were explicitly designed to make music creation accessible without conventional musicianship. The functional prediction was met; brain-wave control in the passage is an example, not a condition imposed on all composition.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2004,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Arts in 2009, nonmusicians bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N26\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Networked haptics let people touch or manipulate distant objects/other users in limited practical demonstrations.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009. Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2002, "at_deadline_rationale": "The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N41", "N28" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Networked haptics let people touch or manipulate distant objects/other users in limited practical demonstrations.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009. Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2002, "at_deadline_rationale": "The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N41", "N28" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Networked haptics let people touch or manipulate distant objects/other users in limited practical demonstrations.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009. Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2002, "at_deadline_rationale": "The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N41", "N28" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2002, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2002", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K067", "slug": "k067-remote-touch-technology-begins-to-emerge", "title": "Remote touch technology begins to emerge", "prediction_paraphrase": "Remote touch technology begins to emerge", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K067", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Networked haptics let people touch or manipulate distant objects/other users in limited practical demonstrations.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009. Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2002, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Personal relationships in 2009, first clause of haptics/chat bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N41", "locator": "Describes 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake and networked force feedback; supports emerging remote touch, not full-body realism.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N28", "locator": "Local finger-scale multimodal haptics; not whole-body, all-sensation realism. Preprint status retained.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K067", "familyId": "K067", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K067", "category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Remote touch technology begins to emerge", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Remote touch technology begins to emerge", "successCriteria": "Networked haptics let people touch or manipulate distant objects/other users in limited practical demonstrations.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Personal relationships in 2009, first clause of haptics/chat bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N41", "id": "N41-0", "title": "Paterson: Feel the Presence—Technologies of Touch and Distance", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1068/d394t", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Describes 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake and networked force feedback; supports emerging remote touch, not full-body realism.. Describes 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake and networked force feedback; supports emerging remote touch, not full-body realism." }, { "sourceId": "N28", "id": "N28-1", "title": "Research prototype for thermal and pressure haptics", "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.20831", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Local finger-scale multimodal haptics; not whole-body, all-sensation realism. Preprint status retained.. Local finger-scale multimodal haptics; not whole-body, all-sensation realism. Preprint status retained." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009. Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009. Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Networked haptics let people touch or manipulate distant objects/other users in limited practical demonstrations.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009. Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2002,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N41\",\"N28\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Networked haptics let people touch or manipulate distant objects/other users in limited practical demonstrations.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009. Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2002,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N41\",\"N28\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Networked haptics let people touch or manipulate distant objects/other users in limited practical demonstrations.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009. Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2002,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N41\",\"N28\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2002,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2002\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K067\",\"slug\":\"k067-remote-touch-technology-begins-to-emerge\",\"title\":\"Remote touch technology begins to emerge\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Remote touch technology begins to emerge\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Interfaces & virtual worlds\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K067\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Networked haptics let people touch or manipulate distant objects/other users in limited practical demonstrations.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The scholarly account of the 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake establishes the emerging capability well before 2009. Further haptics progress preserves this modest success. The stronger full-body tactile claim is separately scored K031.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2002,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Personal relationships in 2009, first clause of haptics/chat bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N41\",\"locator\":\"Describes 2002 Boston–London virtual handshake and networked force feedback; supports emerging remote touch, not full-body realism.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N28\",\"locator\":\"Local finger-scale multimodal haptics; not whole-body, all-sensation realism. Preprint status retained.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Full-visual-realism virtual environments displace ordinary text chat rooms.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009. Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N46", "N05" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Full-visual-realism virtual environments displace ordinary text chat rooms.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009. Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N46", "N05" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Social virtual environments become a usable additional way to meet online.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Consumer VR and social virtual environments establish the alternate medium without the replacement or photorealism condition.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Replacement of text chat", "Full visual realism" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N46", "N05" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K068", "slug": "k068-photorealistic-virtual-rooms-replace-text-chat", "title": "Photorealistic virtual rooms replace text chat", "prediction_paraphrase": "Photorealistic virtual rooms replace text chat", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K068", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Full-visual-realism virtual environments displace ordinary text chat rooms.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009. Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Personal relationships in 2009, second clause of haptics/chat bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N46", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N05", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K068", "familyId": "K068", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K068", "category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Photorealistic virtual rooms replace text chat", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Photorealistic virtual rooms replace text chat", "successCriteria": "Full-visual-realism virtual environments displace ordinary text chat rooms.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Personal relationships in 2009, second clause of haptics/chat bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N46", "id": "N46-0", "title": "Microsoft Teams reaches 13 million daily active users", "url": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/blog/2019/07/11/microsoft-teams-reaches-13-million-daily-active-users-introduces-4-new-ways-for-teams-to-work-better-together/", "publishedAt": "2019-07-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." }, { "sourceId": "N05", "id": "N05-1", "title": "Qualcomm: Snapdragon platform powers shipping Oculus Quest", "url": "https://www.qualcomm.com/news/releases/2019/05/qualcomm-snapdragon-mobile-vr-platform-powers-oculus-quest", "publishedAt": "2019-05-20", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009. Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009. Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Full-visual-realism virtual environments displace ordinary text chat rooms.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009. Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N46\",\"N05\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Full-visual-realism virtual environments displace ordinary text chat rooms.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009. Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N46\",\"N05\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Social virtual environments become a usable additional way to meet online.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Consumer VR and social virtual environments establish the alternate medium without the replacement or photorealism condition.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Replacement of text chat\",\"Full visual realism\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N46\",\"N05\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K068\",\"slug\":\"k068-photorealistic-virtual-rooms-replace-text-chat\",\"title\":\"Photorealistic virtual rooms replace text chat\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Photorealistic virtual rooms replace text chat\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Interfaces & virtual worlds\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K068\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Full-visual-realism virtual environments displace ordinary text chat rooms.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Early virtual worlds did not provide full realism or replace mainstream text conversation in 2009. Widely used text-centered collaboration and messaging persist alongside virtual environments. Coexistence is not replacement.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Personal relationships in 2009, second clause of haptics/chat bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N46\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N05\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Wireless personal calls routinely include usable live video, not merely an experimental video phone.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009. Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N42", "N44", "N46" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Wireless personal calls routinely include usable live video, not merely an experimental video phone.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009. Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N42", "N44", "N46" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Wireless personal calls routinely include usable live video, not merely an experimental video phone.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009. Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N42", "N44", "N46" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2009, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2019, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2019; after 2009, no later than 2019", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K069", "slug": "k069-wireless-phones-routinely-carry-live-video", "title": "Wireless phones routinely carry live video", "prediction_paraphrase": "Wireless phones routinely carry live video", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Networks & communications", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K069", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2009", "deadline_year": 2009, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2009, "year_end": 2009, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Wireless personal calls routinely include usable live video, not merely an experimental video phone.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009.", "at_review_rationale": "Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "LATE", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009. Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2019, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 2009 Computers and communications, telephone-communication paragraph", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N42", "locator": "WebEx had more than 2.2 million registered users; evidence of established distributed collaboration, not most employees working from home.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N44", "locator": "Announced September, retail availability November 3, 2017. Documented secure everyday owner recognition; not first-ever face recognition.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N46", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "2019 is a conservative documented-by date for routine use, not the invention of video calling. The claim is capability/adoption, not that every call transmits video.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K069", "familyId": "K069", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K069", "category": "Networks & communications", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Wireless phones routinely carry live video", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Wireless phones routinely carry live video", "successCriteria": "Wireless personal calls routinely include usable live video, not merely an experimental video phone.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 2009 Computers and communications, telephone-communication paragraph", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2009", "year": 2009, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N42", "id": "N42-0", "title": "Cisco announces acquisition of WebEx", "url": "https://newsroom.cisco.com/c/r/newsroom/en/us/a/y2007/m03/cisco-announces-agreement-to-acquire-webex.html", "publishedAt": "2007-03-15", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "WebEx had more than 2.2 million registered users; evidence of established distributed collaboration, not most employees working from home.. WebEx had more than 2.2 million registered users; evidence of established distributed collaboration, not most employees working from home." }, { "sourceId": "N44", "id": "N44-1", "title": "Apple: iPhone X and Face ID", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2017/09/the-future-is-here-iphone-x/", "publishedAt": "2017-09-12", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Announced September, retail availability November 3, 2017. Documented secure everyday owner recognition; not first-ever face recognition.. Announced September, retail availability November 3, 2017. Documented secure everyday owner recognition; not first-ever face recognition." }, { "sourceId": "N46", "id": "N46-2", "title": "Microsoft Teams reaches 13 million daily active users", "url": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/blog/2019/07/11/microsoft-teams-reaches-13-million-daily-active-users-introduces-4-new-ways-for-teams-to-work-better-together/", "publishedAt": "2019-07-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009. Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "2019 is a conservative documented-by date for routine use, not the invention of video calling. The claim is capability/adoption, not that every call transmits video.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict LATE. Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009. Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Wireless personal calls routinely include usable live video, not merely an experimental video phone.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009. Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N42\",\"N44\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Wireless personal calls routinely include usable live video, not merely an experimental video phone.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009. Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N42\",\"N44\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Wireless personal calls routinely include usable live video, not merely an experimental video phone.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009. Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N42\",\"N44\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2009,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2019; after 2009, no later than 2019\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K069\",\"slug\":\"k069-wireless-phones-routinely-carry-live-video\",\"title\":\"Wireless phones routinely carry live video\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Wireless phones routinely carry live video\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Networks & communications\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K069\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2009\",\"deadline_year\":2009,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2009,\"year_end\":2009,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Wireless personal calls routinely include usable live video, not merely an experimental video phone.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Wireless voice and webcam meetings were real, but ordinary handset video calling was not yet routine in 2009. Integrated phone cameras, mobile video services and established consumer communication platforms make the function ordinary by the 2010s.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2019,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 2009 Computers and communications, telephone-communication paragraph\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N42\",\"locator\":\"WebEx had more than 2.2 million registered users; evidence of established distributed collaboration, not most employees working from home.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N44\",\"locator\":\"Announced September, retail availability November 3, 2017. Documented secure everyday owner recognition; not first-ever face recognition.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N46\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"2019 is a conservative documented-by date for routine use, not the invention of video calling. The claim is capability/adoption, not that every call transmits video.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Rotating magnetic and optical computer storage is fully replaced by electronic storage.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement. Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement.", "at_review_rationale": "Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N14" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Rotating magnetic and optical computer storage is fully replaced by electronic storage.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement. Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement.", "at_review_rationale": "Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N14" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Solid-state storage dominates pocket devices and becomes a major PC storage format.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The broader direction is correct, but drops the explicit end of rotating storage.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Full replacement across computing" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N14" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K070", "slug": "k070-electronic-storage-fully-replaces-rotating-media", "title": "Electronic storage fully replaces rotating media", "prediction_paraphrase": "Electronic storage fully replaces rotating media", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K070", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Rotating magnetic and optical computer storage is fully replaced by electronic storage.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement.", "at_review_rationale": "Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement. Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 2019 computing, rotating-memories paragraph", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N14", "locator": "Current counterexample to complete displacement of rotating magnetic storage; shipping announcement for January 14, 2026.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K070", "familyId": "K070", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K070", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Electronic storage fully replaces rotating media", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Electronic storage fully replaces rotating media", "successCriteria": "Rotating magnetic and optical computer storage is fully replaced by electronic storage.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 2019 computing, rotating-memories paragraph", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N14", "id": "N14-0", "title": "Seagate: 32 TB hard drives ship to channel and retail partners", "url": "https://www.seagate.com/stories/articles/seagate-32TB-capacities-now-shipping-to-channel-and-retail-partners-globally/", "publishedAt": "2026-01-12", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Current counterexample to complete displacement of rotating magnetic storage; shipping announcement for January 14, 2026.. Current counterexample to complete displacement of rotating magnetic storage; shipping announcement for January 14, 2026." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement. Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement. Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”" } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Rotating magnetic and optical computer storage is fully replaced by electronic storage.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement. Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N14\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Rotating magnetic and optical computer storage is fully replaced by electronic storage.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement. Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N14\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Solid-state storage dominates pocket devices and becomes a major PC storage format.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The broader direction is correct, but drops the explicit end of rotating storage.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Full replacement across computing\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N14\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K070\",\"slug\":\"k070-electronic-storage-fully-replaces-rotating-media\",\"title\":\"Electronic storage fully replaces rotating media\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Electronic storage fully replaces rotating media\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K070\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Rotating magnetic and optical computer storage is fully replaced by electronic storage.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Hard drives remained substantial in 2019; solid-state adoption did not amount to full replacement. Seagate’s 2026 32 TB drive rollout provides a direct current counterexample. “Fully replaced” is genuinely stronger than “widely available.”\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 2019 computing, rotating-memories paragraph\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N14\",\"locator\":\"Current counterexample to complete displacement of rotating magnetic storage; shipping announcement for January 14, 2026.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Three-dimensional carbon-nanotube lattices are a prevalent computing-circuit technology.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture. Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture.", "at_review_rationale": "Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N13", "N10" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Three-dimensional carbon-nanotube lattices are a prevalent computing-circuit technology.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture. Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture.", "at_review_rationale": "Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N13", "N10" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Three-dimensional semiconductor structures become an important commercial technology regardless of material.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "3D NAND realizes that relaxed direction, but silicon multilayer storage is not nanotube-lattice computation.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Carbon-nanotube material and lattice architecture" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N13", "N10" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K071", "slug": "k071-carbon-nanotube-circuitry-becomes-prevalent", "title": "Carbon-nanotube circuitry becomes prevalent", "prediction_paraphrase": "Carbon-nanotube circuitry becomes prevalent", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K071", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Three-dimensional carbon-nanotube lattices are a prevalent computing-circuit technology.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture.", "at_review_rationale": "Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture. Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 2019 computing, same paragraph as rotating memories", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N13", "locator": "Research prototype with more than 14,000 carbon-nanotube transistors, not commercial prevalence.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N10", "locator": "10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K071", "familyId": "K071", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K071", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Carbon-nanotube circuitry becomes prevalent", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Carbon-nanotube circuitry becomes prevalent", "successCriteria": "Three-dimensional carbon-nanotube lattices are a prevalent computing-circuit technology.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 2019 computing, same paragraph as rotating memories", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N13", "id": "N13-0", "title": "MIT: Carbon-nanotube microprocessor", "url": "https://news.mit.edu/2019/carbon-nanotubes-microprocessor-0828", "publishedAt": "2019-08-28", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Research prototype with more than 14,000 carbon-nanotube transistors, not commercial prevalence.. Research prototype with more than 14,000 carbon-nanotube transistors, not commercial prevalence." }, { "sourceId": "N10", "id": "N10-1", "title": "NVIDIA: RTX 5080 specifications", "url": "https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/geforce/graphics-cards/50-series/rtx-5080/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence.. 10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": true, "rationale": "MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture. Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture. Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Three-dimensional carbon-nanotube lattices are a prevalent computing-circuit technology.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture. Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N13\",\"N10\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Three-dimensional carbon-nanotube lattices are a prevalent computing-circuit technology.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture. Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N13\",\"N10\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Three-dimensional semiconductor structures become an important commercial technology regardless of material.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"3D NAND realizes that relaxed direction, but silicon multilayer storage is not nanotube-lattice computation.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Carbon-nanotube material and lattice architecture\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N13\",\"N10\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K071\",\"slug\":\"k071-carbon-nanotube-circuitry-becomes-prevalent\",\"title\":\"Carbon-nanotube circuitry becomes prevalent\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Carbon-nanotube circuitry becomes prevalent\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K071\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Three-dimensional carbon-nanotube lattices are a prevalent computing-circuit technology.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"MIT’s 2019 carbon-nanotube processor was a research prototype, not the prevalent industrial circuit architecture. Carbon-nanotube research is not evidence of dominant production adoption. The forecast’s material choice was not realized by ordinary silicon scaling.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 2019 computing, same paragraph as rotating memories\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N13\",\"locator\":\"Research prototype with more than 14,000 carbon-nanotube transistors, not commercial prevalence.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N10\",\"locator\":\"10,752 CUDA cores, 2.62 GHz boost; theoretical FP32 about 56.3 TFLOPS using 2 operations/core/cycle. AI TOPS use different precision and cannot establish brain equivalence.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Neural networks and genetic algorithms account for more than half of computing work across the intended general computing population.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation. AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation.", "at_review_rationale": "AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N35", "N11", "N55" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Neural networks and genetic algorithms account for more than half of computing work across the intended general computing population.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation. AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation.", "at_review_rationale": "AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N35", "N11", "N55" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Massively parallel neural computation becomes central to frontier AI and a major driver of hardware.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The narrower AI-industry population clearly satisfies central importance by 2019.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "All computing narrowed to frontier AI", "Majority threshold narrowed to central importance" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N35", "N11", "N55" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K072", "slug": "k072-neural-and-genetic-methods-consume-most-computation", "title": "Neural and genetic methods consume most computation", "prediction_paraphrase": "Neural and genetic methods consume most computation", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "AI & software", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K072", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Neural networks and genetic algorithms account for more than half of computing work across the intended general computing population.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation.", "at_review_rationale": "AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation. AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 2019 computing, majority-of-computations paragraph", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N35", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N11", "locator": "RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N55", "locator": "Protocol and reference implementations; not evidence most real-world transactions use simulated people.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "No invented count of all global operations. Reference PARTIAL reflects genuine importance plus an unestablished majority, not confidence that the majority is mathematically impossible.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K072", "familyId": "K072", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K072", "category": "AI & software", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Neural and genetic methods consume most computation", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Neural and genetic methods consume most computation", "successCriteria": "Neural networks and genetic algorithms account for more than half of computing work across the intended general computing population.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 2019 computing, majority-of-computations paragraph", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N35", "id": "N35-0", "title": "Krizhevsky et al.: ImageNet Classification with Deep Convolutional Neural Networks", "url": "https://papers.nips.cc/paper/4824-imagenet-classification-with-deep-convolutional-neural-networks", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." }, { "sourceId": "N11", "id": "N11-1", "title": "NVIDIA: Blackwell GeForce RTX 50-series launch", "url": "https://investor.nvidia.com/news/press-release-details/2025/NVIDIA-Blackwell-GeForce-RTX-50-Series-Opens-New-World-of-AI-Computer-Graphics/default.aspx", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC.. RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC." }, { "sourceId": "N55", "id": "N55-2", "title": "Google: Agent Payments Protocol AP2", "url": "https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/ai-machine-learning/announcing-agents-to-payments-ap2-protocol", "publishedAt": "2025-09-16", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Protocol and reference implementations; not evidence most real-world transactions use simulated people.. Protocol and reference implementations; not evidence most real-world transactions use simulated people." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation. AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.", "alternativeInterpretation": "No invented count of all global operations. Reference PARTIAL reflects genuine importance plus an unestablished majority, not confidence that the majority is mathematically impossible.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "No invented count of all global operations. Reference PARTIAL reflects genuine importance plus an unestablished majority, not confidence that the majority is mathematically impossible.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation. AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Neural networks and genetic algorithms account for more than half of computing work across the intended general computing population.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation. AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N35\",\"N11\",\"N55\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Neural networks and genetic algorithms account for more than half of computing work across the intended general computing population.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation. AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N35\",\"N11\",\"N55\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Massively parallel neural computation becomes central to frontier AI and a major driver of hardware.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The narrower AI-industry population clearly satisfies central importance by 2019.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"All computing narrowed to frontier AI\",\"Majority threshold narrowed to central importance\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N35\",\"N11\",\"N55\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K072\",\"slug\":\"k072-neural-and-genetic-methods-consume-most-computation\",\"title\":\"Neural and genetic methods consume most computation\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Neural and genetic methods consume most computation\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"AI & software\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K072\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Neural networks and genetic algorithms account for more than half of computing work across the intended general computing population.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Important neural successes by 2019 did not establish majority use across all computation. AI compute has become a major workload, but a global majority depends on the population and unit of work. The directional expansion is substantial; the literal aggregate threshold is not established.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 2019 computing, majority-of-computations paragraph\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N35\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N11\",\"locator\":\"RTX 5080 launch MSRP $999, 1,801 AI TOPS. Launch prices are not represented as October 2026 retail quotes; a GPU also is not a whole PC.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N55\",\"locator\":\"Protocol and reference implementations; not evidence most real-world transactions use simulated people.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"No invented count of all global operations. Reference PARTIAL reflects genuine importance plus an unestablished majority, not confidence that the majority is mathematically impossible.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Brain scanning makes significant progress in identifying specialized regions and computational organization.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance. Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2016, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance.", "at_review_rationale": "Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N48", "N15", "N16" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Scanning yields understood algorithms for the major regions and those algorithms demonstrably drive machine neural-network design.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Regional mapping is strong; the complete algorithm-understanding and causal transfer-to-AI chain is less established.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N48", "N15", "N16" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Brain scanning makes significant progress in identifying specialized regions and computational organization.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance. Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2016, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance.", "at_review_rationale": "Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N48", "N15", "N16" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2016, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2016", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K073", "slug": "k073-brain-scanning-clarifies-specialized-neural-regions", "title": "Brain scanning clarifies specialized neural regions", "prediction_paraphrase": "Brain scanning clarifies specialized neural regions", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Neuroscience & human augmentation", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "RESEARCH_MILESTONE", "family_id": "K073", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Brain scanning makes significant progress in identifying specialized regions and computational organization.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance.", "at_review_rationale": "Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance. Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2016, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 2019 computing, reverse-engineering paragraph", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N48", "locator": "180 cortical areas per hemisphere; direct evidence of improved regional brain understanding, not whole-brain functional reconstruction.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N15", "locator": "Mouse cell atlas, not a functional emulation of the entire human brain.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N16", "locator": "Adult fruit-fly connectome. Species, wiring map and functional cognitive model must not be conflated.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K073", "familyId": "K073", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K073", "category": "Neuroscience & human augmentation", "tags": [], "claimType": "RESEARCH_MILESTONE", "importedClaim": "Brain scanning clarifies specialized neural regions", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Brain scanning clarifies specialized neural regions", "successCriteria": "Brain scanning makes significant progress in identifying specialized regions and computational organization.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 2019 computing, reverse-engineering paragraph", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N48", "id": "N48-0", "title": "Glasser et al.: A multi-modal parcellation of human cerebral cortex", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/nature18933", "publishedAt": "2016-07-20", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "180 cortical areas per hemisphere; direct evidence of improved regional brain understanding, not whole-brain functional reconstruction.. 180 cortical areas per hemisphere; direct evidence of improved regional brain understanding, not whole-brain functional reconstruction." }, { "sourceId": "N15", "id": "N15-1", "title": "NIH: Complete cell map of a whole mammalian brain", "url": "https://www.nimh.nih.gov/news/science-updates/2023/scientists-unveil-complete-cell-map-of-a-whole-mammalian-brain", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Mouse cell atlas, not a functional emulation of the entire human brain.. Mouse cell atlas, not a functional emulation of the entire human brain." }, { "sourceId": "N16", "id": "N16-2", "title": "Dorkenwald et al.: Neuronal wiring diagram of an adult brain", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07686-5", "publishedAt": "2024-10-02", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Adult fruit-fly connectome. Species, wiring map and functional cognitive model must not be conflated.. Adult fruit-fly connectome. Species, wiring map and functional cognitive model must not be conflated." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance. Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance. Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Brain scanning makes significant progress in identifying specialized regions and computational organization.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance. Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2016,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N48\",\"N15\",\"N16\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Scanning yields understood algorithms for the major regions and those algorithms demonstrably drive machine neural-network design.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Regional mapping is strong; the complete algorithm-understanding and causal transfer-to-AI chain is less established.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N48\",\"N15\",\"N16\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Brain scanning makes significant progress in identifying specialized regions and computational organization.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance. Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2016,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N48\",\"N15\",\"N16\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2016,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2016\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K073\",\"slug\":\"k073-brain-scanning-clarifies-specialized-neural-regions\",\"title\":\"Brain scanning clarifies specialized neural regions\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Brain scanning clarifies specialized neural regions\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Neuroscience & human augmentation\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"RESEARCH_MILESTONE\",\"family_id\":\"K073\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Brain scanning makes significant progress in identifying specialized regions and computational organization.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The 2016 human cortical map identified 180 areas per hemisphere, a concrete regional reverse-engineering advance. Whole-animal connectomes and cell atlases add substantial progress. This modest forecast does not require a complete human emulation.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2016,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 2019 computing, reverse-engineering paragraph\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N48\",\"locator\":\"180 cortical areas per hemisphere; direct evidence of improved regional brain understanding, not whole-brain functional reconstruction.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N15\",\"locator\":\"Mouse cell atlas, not a functional emulation of the entire human brain.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N16\",\"locator\":\"Adult fruit-fly connectome. Species, wiring map and functional cognitive model must not be conflated.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "The specified pinhead-scale lensless/diffraction technology replaces most conventional camera lenses.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution. Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution.", "at_review_rationale": "Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N44", "N65" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "The specified pinhead-scale lensless/diffraction technology replaces most conventional camera lenses.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution. Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution.", "at_review_rationale": "Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N44", "N65" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Small computational cameras become pervasive.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Phones establish miniaturized computational imaging, while retaining lenses.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Lens replacement", "Specified quantum/diffraction mechanism" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N44", "N65" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K074", "slug": "k074-tiny-diffraction-cameras-replace-most-lenses", "title": "Tiny diffraction cameras replace most lenses", "prediction_paraphrase": "Tiny diffraction cameras replace most lenses", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K074", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "The specified pinhead-scale lensless/diffraction technology replaces most conventional camera lenses.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution.", "at_review_rationale": "Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution. Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 2019 computing, quantum-based diffraction imaging paragraph", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N44", "locator": "Announced September, retail availability November 3, 2017. Documented secure everyday owner recognition; not first-ever face recognition.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N65", "locator": "Current mainstream digital imaging and interchangeable optical lenses. Supports the present digital-camera ecosystem and persistence of lenses, not an exact historic film crossover year.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Current nonfulfillment is a technology-market judgment supported by mainstream device architecture, not a quantitative global lens census. Laboratory lensless devices do not prove replacement.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K074", "familyId": "K074", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K074", "category": "Computing hardware", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Tiny diffraction cameras replace most lenses", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Tiny diffraction cameras replace most lenses", "successCriteria": "The specified pinhead-scale lensless/diffraction technology replaces most conventional camera lenses.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 2019 computing, quantum-based diffraction imaging paragraph", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N44", "id": "N44-0", "title": "Apple: iPhone X and Face ID", "url": "https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2017/09/the-future-is-here-iphone-x/", "publishedAt": "2017-09-12", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Announced September, retail availability November 3, 2017. Documented secure everyday owner recognition; not first-ever face recognition.. Announced September, retail availability November 3, 2017. Documented secure everyday owner recognition; not first-ever face recognition." }, { "sourceId": "N65", "id": "N65-1", "title": "Canon: 2026 digital imaging system and market release", "url": "https://global.canon/en/news/2026/20260224.html", "publishedAt": "2026-02-24", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Current mainstream digital imaging and interchangeable optical lenses. Supports the present digital-camera ecosystem and persistence of lenses, not an exact historic film crossover year.. Current mainstream digital imaging and interchangeable optical lenses. Supports the present digital-camera ecosystem and persistence of lenses, not an exact historic film crossover year." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution. Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Current nonfulfillment is a technology-market judgment supported by mainstream device architecture, not a quantitative global lens census. Laboratory lensless devices do not prove replacement.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Current nonfulfillment is a technology-market judgment supported by mainstream device architecture, not a quantitative global lens census. Laboratory lensless devices do not prove replacement.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution. Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"The specified pinhead-scale lensless/diffraction technology replaces most conventional camera lenses.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution. Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N44\",\"N65\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"The specified pinhead-scale lensless/diffraction technology replaces most conventional camera lenses.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution. Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N44\",\"N65\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Small computational cameras become pervasive.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Phones establish miniaturized computational imaging, while retaining lenses.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Lens replacement\",\"Specified quantum/diffraction mechanism\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N44\",\"N65\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K074\",\"slug\":\"k074-tiny-diffraction-cameras-replace-most-lenses\",\"title\":\"Tiny diffraction cameras replace most lenses\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Tiny diffraction cameras replace most lenses\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Computing hardware\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K074\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"The specified pinhead-scale lensless/diffraction technology replaces most conventional camera lenses.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Ordinary smartphone cameras still relied on lenses in 2019; tiny camera sensors did not fulfill the optical substitution. Computational imaging is widespread, but not equivalent to majority replacement of optics with the specified diffraction architecture.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 2019 computing, quantum-based diffraction imaging paragraph\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N44\",\"locator\":\"Announced September, retail availability November 3, 2017. Documented secure everyday owner recognition; not first-ever face recognition.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N65\",\"locator\":\"Current mainstream digital imaging and interchangeable optical lenses. Supports the present digital-camera ecosystem and persistence of lenses, not an exact historic film crossover year.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Current nonfulfillment is a technology-market judgment supported by mainstream device architecture, not a quantitative global lens census. Laboratory lensless devices do not prove replacement.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Routine calls offer three-dimensional physical-presence realism using the specified direct-eye or holographic display systems.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity. Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity.", "at_review_rationale": "Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N34", "N46" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Routine calls offer three-dimensional physical-presence realism using the specified direct-eye or holographic display systems.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity. Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity.", "at_review_rationale": "Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N34", "N46" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Convincing 3D telepresence exists in practical specialist systems, without routine adoption or retinal implementation.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Beam’s light-field demonstration/commercial platform realizes the central presence function by 2025. This is a capability assessment, not proof of installed scale.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Routine use", "Direct-eye implementation", "Above-human acuity" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2025, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N34", "N46" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K075", "slug": "k075-calls-provide-convincing-three-dimensional-presence", "title": "Calls provide convincing three-dimensional presence", "prediction_paraphrase": "Calls provide convincing three-dimensional presence", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K075", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Routine calls offer three-dimensional physical-presence realism using the specified direct-eye or holographic display systems.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity.", "at_review_rationale": "Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity. Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 2019 communications, holography/phone-call paragraph", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N34", "locator": "Enterprise light-field telepresence, six-camera capture. Launch/availability plan supports capability and commercialization, not routine calls or demonstrated above-human acuity.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N46", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "A product announcement is evidence of a demonstrated capability and commercial offering, not of widespread deployment. The broader label is explicitly limited to practical specialist availability.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K075", "familyId": "K075", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K075", "category": "Interfaces & virtual worlds", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Calls provide convincing three-dimensional presence", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Calls provide convincing three-dimensional presence", "successCriteria": "Routine calls offer three-dimensional physical-presence realism using the specified direct-eye or holographic display systems.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 2019 communications, holography/phone-call paragraph", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N34", "id": "N34-0", "title": "HP: Dimension with Google Beam at InfoComm 2025", "url": "https://www.hp.com/us-en/newsroom/press-releases/2025/hp-dimension-with-google-beam-at-infocomm-2025.html", "publishedAt": "2025-06-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Enterprise light-field telepresence, six-camera capture. Launch/availability plan supports capability and commercialization, not routine calls or demonstrated above-human acuity.. Enterprise light-field telepresence, six-camera capture. Launch/availability plan supports capability and commercialization, not routine calls or demonstrated above-human acuity." }, { "sourceId": "N46", "id": "N46-1", "title": "Microsoft Teams reaches 13 million daily active users", "url": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/blog/2019/07/11/microsoft-teams-reaches-13-million-daily-active-users-introduces-4-new-ways-for-teams-to-work-better-together/", "publishedAt": "2019-07-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity. Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.", "alternativeInterpretation": "A product announcement is evidence of a demonstrated capability and commercial offering, not of widespread deployment. The broader label is explicitly limited to practical specialist availability.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "A product announcement is evidence of a demonstrated capability and commercial offering, not of widespread deployment. The broader label is explicitly limited to practical specialist availability.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity. Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Routine calls offer three-dimensional physical-presence realism using the specified direct-eye or holographic display systems.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity. Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N34\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Routine calls offer three-dimensional physical-presence realism using the specified direct-eye or holographic display systems.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity. Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N34\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Convincing 3D telepresence exists in practical specialist systems, without routine adoption or retinal implementation.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Beam’s light-field demonstration/commercial platform realizes the central presence function by 2025. This is a capability assessment, not proof of installed scale.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Routine use\",\"Direct-eye implementation\",\"Above-human acuity\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2025,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N34\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K075\",\"slug\":\"k075-calls-provide-convincing-three-dimensional-presence\",\"title\":\"Calls provide convincing three-dimensional presence\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Calls provide convincing three-dimensional presence\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Interfaces & virtual worlds\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K075\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Routine calls offer three-dimensional physical-presence realism using the specified direct-eye or holographic display systems.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Ordinary 2019 video calls did not deliver the asserted 3D physical-presence experience and acuity. Google Beam/HP Dimension demonstrates a serious enterprise 3D telepresence direction, but not routine consumer calls or proven above-human acuity.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 2019 communications, holography/phone-call paragraph\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N34\",\"locator\":\"Enterprise light-field telepresence, six-camera capture. Launch/availability plan supports capability and commercialization, not routine calls or demonstrated above-human acuity.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N46\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"A product announcement is evidence of a demonstrated capability and commercial offering, not of widespread deployment. The broader label is explicitly limited to practical specialist availability.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Most ordinary information-sharing meetings can be conducted without co-location; the wording is about need, not actual venue share.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019. The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N42", "N46" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Most ordinary information-sharing meetings can be conducted without co-location; the wording is about need, not actual venue share.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019. The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N42", "N46" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Most ordinary information-sharing meetings can be conducted without co-location; the wording is about need, not actual venue share.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019. The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "at_deadline_rationale": "Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N42", "N46" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2019, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2019", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K076", "slug": "k076-most-meetings-need-no-physical-co-location", "title": "Most meetings need no physical co-location", "prediction_paraphrase": "Most meetings need no physical co-location", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Economy & society", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K076", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Most ordinary information-sharing meetings can be conducted without co-location; the wording is about need, not actual venue share.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019. The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2019, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 2019 communications, majority-of-meetings sentence", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N42", "locator": "WebEx had more than 2.2 million registered users; evidence of established distributed collaboration, not most employees working from home.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N46", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Excludes hands-on physical work for which co-location may be intrinsic. The word “need” is not silently changed into a survey claim about where all meetings occurred.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K076", "familyId": "K076", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K076", "category": "Economy & society", "tags": [], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Most meetings need no physical co-location", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Most meetings need no physical co-location", "successCriteria": "Most ordinary information-sharing meetings can be conducted without co-location; the wording is about need, not actual venue share.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 2019 communications, majority-of-meetings sentence", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N42", "id": "N42-0", "title": "Cisco announces acquisition of WebEx", "url": "https://newsroom.cisco.com/c/r/newsroom/en/us/a/y2007/m03/cisco-announces-agreement-to-acquire-webex.html", "publishedAt": "2007-03-15", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "WebEx had more than 2.2 million registered users; evidence of established distributed collaboration, not most employees working from home.. WebEx had more than 2.2 million registered users; evidence of established distributed collaboration, not most employees working from home." }, { "sourceId": "N46", "id": "N46-1", "title": "Microsoft Teams reaches 13 million daily active users", "url": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/blog/2019/07/11/microsoft-teams-reaches-13-million-daily-active-users-introduces-4-new-ways-for-teams-to-work-better-together/", "publishedAt": "2019-07-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019. The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Excludes hands-on physical work for which co-location may be intrinsic. The word “need” is not silently changed into a survey claim about where all meetings occurred.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019. The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Most ordinary information-sharing meetings can be conducted without co-location; the wording is about need, not actual venue share.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019. The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N42\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Most ordinary information-sharing meetings can be conducted without co-location; the wording is about need, not actual venue share.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019. The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N42\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Most ordinary information-sharing meetings can be conducted without co-location; the wording is about need, not actual venue share.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019. The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N42\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2019\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K076\",\"slug\":\"k076-most-meetings-need-no-physical-co-location\",\"title\":\"Most meetings need no physical co-location\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Most meetings need no physical co-location\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Economy & society\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K076\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Most ordinary information-sharing meetings can be conducted without co-location; the wording is about need, not actual venue share.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Large-scale video and collaboration platforms already supported ordinary distributed meetings by 2019. The capability remains established. It would misread this claim to require proof that most meetings actually happened online.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2019,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 2019 communications, majority-of-meetings sentence\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N42\",\"locator\":\"WebEx had more than 2.2 million registered users; evidence of established distributed collaboration, not most employees working from home.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N46\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Excludes hands-on physical work for which co-location may be intrinsic. The word “need” is not silently changed into a survey claim about where all meetings occurred.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Ordinary users can access useful two-way speech translation for common languages in everyday contexts.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019. Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2015, "at_deadline_rationale": "Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O12", "N20" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "High-quality human-equivalent interpretation is reliable across nearly all ordinary conversational contexts for most common language pairs.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Availability and useful short exchanges do not establish professional-interpreter reliability in every relevant context.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "O12", "N20" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Ordinary users can access useful two-way speech translation for common languages in everyday contexts.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019. Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2015, "at_deadline_rationale": "Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "O12", "N20" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2015, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2015", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K077", "slug": "k077-practical-speech-translation-covers-common-language-pairs", "title": "Practical speech translation covers common language pairs", "prediction_paraphrase": "Practical speech translation covers common language pairs", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "AI & software", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "CAPABILITY", "family_id": "K077", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Ordinary users can access useful two-way speech translation for common languages in everyday contexts.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019. Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2015, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 2019 communications, high-quality speech-translation sentence", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "O12", "locator": "Speech conversation mode expanded to 14 languages; still described as alpha. Not equivalent to translation quality or universal adoption.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N20", "locator": "Conversation and speech translation documented in product updates. Text-language counts must not be presented as speech-language counts; 44-language wearable speech support is separately identified.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "No clinical/legal interpretation recommendation. “High quality” is explicitly operationalized as useful everyday communication, not flawless or expert-grade output.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K077", "familyId": "K077", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K077", "category": "AI & software", "tags": [], "claimType": "CAPABILITY", "importedClaim": "Practical speech translation covers common language pairs", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Practical speech translation covers common language pairs", "successCriteria": "Ordinary users can access useful two-way speech translation for common languages in everyday contexts.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 2019 communications, high-quality speech-translation sentence", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "O12", "id": "O12-0", "title": "Start a conversation with Google", "url": "https://translate.googleblog.com/2011/10/start-conversation-with-google.html", "publishedAt": "2011-10-13", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Speech conversation mode expanded to 14 languages; still described as alpha. Not equivalent to translation quality or universal adoption.. Speech conversation mode expanded to 14 languages; still described as alpha. Not equivalent to translation quality or universal adoption." }, { "sourceId": "N20", "id": "N20-1", "title": "Google Translate: 2015 official product updates", "url": "https://translate.googleblog.com/2015/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Conversation and speech translation documented in product updates. Text-language counts must not be presented as speech-language counts; 44-language wearable speech support is separately identified.. Conversation and speech translation documented in product updates. Text-language counts must not be presented as speech-language counts; 44-language wearable speech support is separately identified." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019. Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.", "alternativeInterpretation": "No clinical/legal interpretation recommendation. “High quality” is explicitly operationalized as useful everyday communication, not flawless or expert-grade output.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "No clinical/legal interpretation recommendation. “High quality” is explicitly operationalized as useful everyday communication, not flawless or expert-grade output.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019. Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Ordinary users can access useful two-way speech translation for common languages in everyday contexts.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019. Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O12\",\"N20\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"High-quality human-equivalent interpretation is reliable across nearly all ordinary conversational contexts for most common language pairs.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Availability and useful short exchanges do not establish professional-interpreter reliability in every relevant context.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O12\",\"N20\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Ordinary users can access useful two-way speech translation for common languages in everyday contexts.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019. Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"O12\",\"N20\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2015,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2015\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K077\",\"slug\":\"k077-practical-speech-translation-covers-common-language-pairs\",\"title\":\"Practical speech translation covers common language pairs\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Practical speech translation covers common language pairs\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"AI & software\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"CAPABILITY\",\"family_id\":\"K077\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Ordinary users can access useful two-way speech translation for common languages in everyday contexts.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Google’s earlier conversation/speech products support this ordinary functional reading well before 2019. Practical translation is a success; errors in idioms, accents or specialist contexts do not justify demanding universal perfect translation.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2015,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 2019 communications, high-quality speech-translation sentence\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"O12\",\"locator\":\"Speech conversation mode expanded to 14 languages; still described as alpha. Not equivalent to translation quality or universal adoption.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N20\",\"locator\":\"Conversation and speech translation documented in product updates. Text-language counts must not be presented as speech-language counts; 44-language wearable speech support is separately identified.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"No clinical/legal interpretation recommendation. “High quality” is explicitly operationalized as useful everyday communication, not flawless or expert-grade output.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "More than half of learning is supplied by intelligent simulated teachers, rather than human instruction or ordinary learning resources.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers. AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers.", "at_review_rationale": "AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N33", "N45", "N22", "N46" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "More than half of learning is supplied by intelligent simulated teachers, rather than human instruction or ordinary learning resources.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers. AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers.", "at_review_rationale": "AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N33", "N45", "N22", "N46" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Digital software becomes a major aid to learning, including online classes and AI assistance.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Digital learning access is widespread, while this broader criterion relaxes both intelligence and majority requirements.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Most learning", "Simulated intelligent teacher" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2022, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N33", "N45", "N22", "N46" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K078", "slug": "k078-ai-tutors-deliver-most-learning", "title": "AI tutors deliver most learning", "prediction_paraphrase": "AI tutors deliver most learning", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K078", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "More than half of learning is supplied by intelligent simulated teachers, rather than human instruction or ordinary learning resources.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers.", "at_review_rationale": "AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers. AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Education in 2019, first bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N33", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N45", "locator": "96% of public schools provided devices to students who needed them by 2021–22; 23% assigned take-home devices to all students before COVID. Not proof every student owned a sub-pound tablet.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N22", "locator": "Institutional context on continuing human teachers, shortages and AI assistance. Normative guidance is not a statistical census of all learning hours.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N46", "locator": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "There is no global all-learning-hours census. The miss is a reasoned medium-confidence assessment of the central majority claim, not an invented precise share.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K078", "familyId": "K078", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K078", "category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "AI tutors deliver most learning", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "AI tutors deliver most learning", "successCriteria": "More than half of learning is supplied by intelligent simulated teachers, rather than human instruction or ordinary learning resources.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Education in 2019, first bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N33", "id": "N33-0", "title": "NCES: Teachers’ use of educational technology in 2009", "url": "https://ies.ed.gov/use-work/resource-library/report/first-look-ed-tab/teachers-use-educational-technology-u-s-public-schools-2009", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." }, { "sourceId": "N45", "id": "N45-1", "title": "NCES: School technology support during COVID", "url": "https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/annualreports/topical-studies/covid/theme/elementary-and-secondary-education-technology-support/", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "96% of public schools provided devices to students who needed them by 2021–22; 23% assigned take-home devices to all students before COVID. Not proof every student owned a sub-pound tablet.. 96% of public schools provided devices to students who needed them by 2021–22; 23% assigned take-home devices to all students before COVID. Not proof every student owned a sub-pound tablet." }, { "sourceId": "N22", "id": "N22-2", "title": "UNESCO: Teachers cannot be coded", "url": "https://www.unesco.org/en/teachers-cannot-be-coded", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Institutional context on continuing human teachers, shortages and AI assistance. Normative guidance is not a statistical census of all learning hours.. Institutional context on continuing human teachers, shortages and AI assistance. Normative guidance is not a statistical census of all learning hours." }, { "sourceId": "N46", "id": "N46-3", "title": "Microsoft Teams reaches 13 million daily active users", "url": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/blog/2019/07/11/microsoft-teams-reaches-13-million-daily-active-users-introduces-4-new-ways-for-teams-to-work-better-together/", "publishedAt": "2019-07-11", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.. Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers. AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.", "alternativeInterpretation": "There is no global all-learning-hours census. The miss is a reasoned medium-confidence assessment of the central majority claim, not an invented precise share.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "There is no global all-learning-hours census. The miss is a reasoned medium-confidence assessment of the central majority claim, not an invented precise share.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. 2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers. AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"More than half of learning is supplied by intelligent simulated teachers, rather than human instruction or ordinary learning resources.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers. AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N33\",\"N45\",\"N22\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"More than half of learning is supplied by intelligent simulated teachers, rather than human instruction or ordinary learning resources.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers. AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N33\",\"N45\",\"N22\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Digital software becomes a major aid to learning, including online classes and AI assistance.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Digital learning access is widespread, while this broader criterion relaxes both intelligence and majority requirements.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Most learning\",\"Simulated intelligent teacher\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2022,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N33\",\"N45\",\"N22\",\"N46\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K078\",\"slug\":\"k078-ai-tutors-deliver-most-learning\",\"title\":\"AI tutors deliver most learning\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"AI tutors deliver most learning\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Media, education & culture\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K078\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"More than half of learning is supplied by intelligent simulated teachers, rather than human instruction or ordinary learning resources.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"2019 classroom and distance learning did not predominantly use intelligent simulated teachers. AI tutoring is a growing capability, but teacher-based education and other learning remain central. A video lecture or web page is not automatically an intelligent tutor.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Education in 2019, first bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N33\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N45\",\"locator\":\"96% of public schools provided devices to students who needed them by 2021–22; 23% assigned take-home devices to all students before COVID. Not proof every student owned a sub-pound tablet.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N22\",\"locator\":\"Institutional context on continuing human teachers, shortages and AI assistance. Normative guidance is not a statistical census of all learning hours.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N46\",\"locator\":\"Primary institutional, research, or issuer source. Dates in the claim refer to the observation or product event, not the review date.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"There is no global all-learning-hours census. The miss is a reasoned medium-confidence assessment of the central majority claim, not an invented precise share.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Typical adult workers spend a majority of their time acquiring new knowledge/skills as a primary activity, not merely incidental learning while doing any job.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining. Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining.", "at_review_rationale": "Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N23" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Typical adult workers spend a majority of their time acquiring new knowledge/skills as a primary activity, not merely incidental learning while doing any job.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining. Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining.", "at_review_rationale": "Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N23" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Knowledge acquisition and recurrent retraining become important parts of working life.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "This qualitative lifelong-learning direction is plausible and widely consistent with digital work, but lacks a global majority-time claim.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Majority time", "Learning as primary activity" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N23" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K079", "slug": "k079-workers-spend-most-time-learning", "title": "Workers spend most time learning", "prediction_paraphrase": "Workers spend most time learning", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Economy & society", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K079", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Typical adult workers spend a majority of their time acquiring new knowledge/skills as a primary activity, not merely incidental learning while doing any job.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining.", "at_review_rationale": "Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining. Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Education in 2019, adult-workers bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N23", "locator": "Time-use study separates work and educational activity. Does not fully count informal on-the-job learning, which is an interpretation limitation.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Formal time-use measures undercount informal workplace learning. That affects confidence, not the distinction between an activity-majority claim and an all-work-is-learning tautology.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K079", "familyId": "K079", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K079", "category": "Economy & society", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Workers spend most time learning", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Workers spend most time learning", "successCriteria": "Typical adult workers spend a majority of their time acquiring new knowledge/skills as a primary activity, not merely incidental learning while doing any job.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Education in 2019, adult-workers bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N23", "id": "N23-0", "title": "BLS: Time use of millennials and nonmillennials", "url": "https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2019/article/time-use-of-millennials-and-nonmillennials.htm", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Time-use study separates work and educational activity. Does not fully count informal on-the-job learning, which is an interpretation limitation.. Time-use study separates work and educational activity. Does not fully count informal on-the-job learning, which is an interpretation limitation." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining. Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Formal time-use measures undercount informal workplace learning. That affects confidence, not the distinction between an activity-majority claim and an all-work-is-learning tautology.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Formal time-use measures undercount informal workplace learning. That affects confidence, not the distinction between an activity-majority claim and an all-work-is-learning tautology.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining. Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Typical adult workers spend a majority of their time acquiring new knowledge/skills as a primary activity, not merely incidental learning while doing any job.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining. Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N23\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Typical adult workers spend a majority of their time acquiring new knowledge/skills as a primary activity, not merely incidental learning while doing any job.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining. Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N23\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Knowledge acquisition and recurrent retraining become important parts of working life.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"This qualitative lifelong-learning direction is plausible and widely consistent with digital work, but lacks a global majority-time claim.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Majority time\",\"Learning as primary activity\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N23\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K079\",\"slug\":\"k079-workers-spend-most-time-learning\",\"title\":\"Workers spend most time learning\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Workers spend most time learning\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Economy & society\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K079\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Typical adult workers spend a majority of their time acquiring new knowledge/skills as a primary activity, not merely incidental learning while doing any job.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"BLS time-use evidence does not resemble a majority of time devoted to study/retraining. Continuing education remains important, but calling all productive work “learning” would make the forecast untestable. On an ordinary primary-activity reading it remains a miss.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Education in 2019, adult-workers bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N23\",\"locator\":\"Time-use study separates work and educational activity. Does not fully count informal on-the-job learning, which is an interpretation limitation.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Formal time-use measures undercount informal workplace learning. That affects confidence, not the distinction between an activity-majority claim and an all-work-is-learning tautology.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Cleaning/chores robots are near-ubiquitous household equipment, not merely a successful appliance category.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence. Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence.", "at_review_rationale": "Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N21", "N52" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Cleaning/chores robots are near-ubiquitous household equipment, not merely a successful appliance category.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence. Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence.", "at_review_rationale": "Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N21", "N52" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Reliable household cleaning robots are a commonplace commercial appliance category.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Substantial sales and established manufacturers support this normal market-language reading of widespread, without literal near-universality.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Near-ubiquitous household penetration", "Broad chores range" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2019, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N21", "N52" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K080", "slug": "k080-reliable-household-robots-become-ubiquitous", "title": "Reliable household robots become ubiquitous", "prediction_paraphrase": "Reliable household robots become ubiquitous", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Robotics & transportation", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K080", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Cleaning/chores robots are near-ubiquitous household equipment, not merely a successful appliance category.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence.", "at_review_rationale": "Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence. Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Business in 2019, household-robots bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N21", "locator": "23.2 million consumer/domestic service robots sold in 2019, +34%. Annual sales are not household penetration or a count of robot-owning homes.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N52", "locator": "January 2010 retrospective on robots launched in 2002 and already commercially established in the 2000s; do not shift the threshold by one year just because the tally was announced in January.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "This forecast actually uses “ubiquitous,” unlike K061’s much weaker emergence claim. The alternative commonplace reading is visible because ordinary usage of ubiquitous can be rhetorical.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K080", "familyId": "K080", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K080", "category": "Robotics & transportation", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Reliable household robots become ubiquitous", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Reliable household robots become ubiquitous", "successCriteria": "Cleaning/chores robots are near-ubiquitous household equipment, not merely a successful appliance category.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Business in 2019, household-robots bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N21", "id": "N21-0", "title": "IFR: Service robots record sales worldwide", "url": "https://ifr.org/ifr-press-releases/news/service-robots-record-sales-worldwide-up-32", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "23.2 million consumer/domestic service robots sold in 2019, +34%. Annual sales are not household penetration or a count of robot-owning homes.. 23.2 million consumer/domestic service robots sold in 2019, +34%. Annual sales are not household penetration or a count of robot-owning homes." }, { "sourceId": "N52", "id": "N52-1", "title": "iRobot: More than five million home robots sold", "url": "https://investor.irobot.com/news-releases/news-release-details/irobot-achieves-milestone-home-robot-market", "publishedAt": "2010-01-05", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "January 2010 retrospective on robots launched in 2002 and already commercially established in the 2000s; do not shift the threshold by one year just because the tally was announced in January.. January 2010 retrospective on robots launched in 2002 and already commercially established in the 2000s; do not shift the threshold by one year just because the tally was announced in January." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "PARTIAL", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence. Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.", "alternativeInterpretation": "This forecast actually uses “ubiquitous,” unlike K061’s much weaker emergence claim. The alternative commonplace reading is visible because ordinary usage of ubiquitous can be rhetorical.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "This forecast actually uses “ubiquitous,” unlike K061’s much weaker emergence claim. The alternative commonplace reading is visible because ordinary usage of ubiquitous can be rhetorical.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence. Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Cleaning/chores robots are near-ubiquitous household equipment, not merely a successful appliance category.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence. Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N21\",\"N52\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Cleaning/chores robots are near-ubiquitous household equipment, not merely a successful appliance category.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence. Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N21\",\"N52\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Reliable household cleaning robots are a commonplace commercial appliance category.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Substantial sales and established manufacturers support this normal market-language reading of widespread, without literal near-universality.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Near-ubiquitous household penetration\",\"Broad chores range\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2019,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N21\",\"N52\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K080\",\"slug\":\"k080-reliable-household-robots-become-ubiquitous\",\"title\":\"Reliable household robots become ubiquitous\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Reliable household robots become ubiquitous\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Robotics & transportation\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K080\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Cleaning/chores robots are near-ubiquitous household equipment, not merely a successful appliance category.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"IFR’s 23.2 million consumer/domestic robot sales in 2019 show a large market, not near-universal household presence. Useful cleaning robots are established, but near-ubiquity across households and the broad chores range are not demonstrated.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Business in 2019, household-robots bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N21\",\"locator\":\"23.2 million consumer/domestic service robots sold in 2019, +34%. Annual sales are not household penetration or a count of robot-owning homes.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N52\",\"locator\":\"January 2010 retrospective on robots launched in 2002 and already commercially established in the 2000s; do not shift the threshold by one year just because the tally was announced in January.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"This forecast actually uses “ubiquitous,” unlike K061’s much weaker emergence claim. The alternative commonplace reading is visible because ordinary usage of ubiquitous can be rhetorical.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Automation reduces transportation accidents to a very low societal burden, not just a modest statistical improvement.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date. WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date.", "at_review_rationale": "WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N24" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Automation reduces transportation accidents to a very low societal burden, not just a modest statistical improvement.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date. WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date.", "at_review_rationale": "WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N24" ], "verdict": "WRONG", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Safety technology produces some meaningful reduction in accident risk.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Improvement is real but uneven and far weaker than the original near-elimination scenario.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Very few accidents" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N24" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K081", "slug": "k081-transportation-accidents-become-very-rare", "title": "Transportation accidents become very rare", "prediction_paraphrase": "Transportation accidents become very rare", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Robotics & transportation", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "SOCIAL_OUTCOME", "family_id": "K081", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Automation reduces transportation accidents to a very low societal burden, not just a modest statistical improvement.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date.", "at_review_rationale": "WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "WRONG", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "NOT_FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date. WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Business in 2019, final sentence of smart-roads bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N24", "locator": "2021 global annual road deaths 1.19 million; about 5% below 2010. These are observed-year figures, not invented 2026 counts.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Uses road deaths as a conservative indicator of the transport-harm burden, not an exact count of all transport accidents in October 2026.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K081", "familyId": "K081", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K081", "category": "Robotics & transportation", "tags": [], "claimType": "SOCIAL_INSTITUTIONAL", "importedClaim": "Transportation accidents become very rare", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Transportation accidents become very rare", "successCriteria": "Automation reduces transportation accidents to a very low societal burden, not just a modest statistical improvement.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Business in 2019, final sentence of smart-roads bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N24", "id": "N24-0", "title": "WHO: Global road safety progress remains insufficient", "url": "https://www.who.int/news/item/13-12-2023-despite-notable-progress-road-safety-remains-urgent-global-issue", "publishedAt": "2023-12-13", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "2021 global annual road deaths 1.19 million; about 5% below 2010. These are observed-year figures, not invented 2026 counts.. 2021 global annual road deaths 1.19 million; about 5% below 2010. These are observed-year figures, not invented 2026 counts." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "NOT_FULFILLED", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date. WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Uses road deaths as a conservative indicator of the transport-harm burden, not an exact count of all transport accidents in October 2026.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Uses road deaths as a conservative indicator of the transport-harm burden, not an exact count of all transport accidents in October 2026.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict WRONG. Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date. WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Automation reduces transportation accidents to a very low societal burden, not just a modest statistical improvement.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date. WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N24\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Automation reduces transportation accidents to a very low societal burden, not just a modest statistical improvement.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date. WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N24\"],\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Safety technology produces some meaningful reduction in accident risk.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Improvement is real but uneven and far weaker than the original near-elimination scenario.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Very few accidents\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N24\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K081\",\"slug\":\"k081-transportation-accidents-become-very-rare\",\"title\":\"Transportation accidents become very rare\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Transportation accidents become very rare\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Robotics & transportation\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"SOCIAL_OUTCOME\",\"family_id\":\"K081\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Automation reduces transportation accidents to a very low societal burden, not just a modest statistical improvement.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"WRONG\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Transport injury and death remained a major global burden around the target date. WHO’s 2021 estimate of 1.19 million annual road deaths, only modestly below 2010, contradicts the very-few-accidents scenario. Individual safer systems do not establish the whole-system outcome.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Business in 2019, final sentence of smart-roads bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N24\",\"locator\":\"2021 global annual road deaths 1.19 million; about 5% below 2010. These are observed-year figures, not invented 2026 counts.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Uses road deaths as a conservative indicator of the transport-harm burden, not an exact count of all transport accidents in October 2026.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "HIGH", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "HIGH", "at_review": "HIGH" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Human-machine artistic collaborations emerge and receive serious cultural/institutional attention.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019. The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2018, "at_deadline_rationale": "Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N27" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Human-machine artistic collaborations emerge and receive serious cultural/institutional attention.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019. The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2018, "at_deadline_rationale": "Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N27" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Human-machine artistic collaborations emerge and receive serious cultural/institutional attention.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019. The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2018, "at_deadline_rationale": "Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N27" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2018, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2018", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K082", "slug": "k082-human-machine-creative-collaborations-gain-recognition", "title": "Human-machine creative collaborations gain recognition", "prediction_paraphrase": "Human-machine creative collaborations gain recognition", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K082", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Human-machine artistic collaborations emerge and receive serious cultural/institutional attention.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed_interpretation": false, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019. The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2018, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Arts in 2019, cyberart bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N27", "locator": "Obvious/GAN portrait sold October 2018 for $432,500. Supports serious institutional attention, not majority adoption by artists.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K082", "familyId": "K082", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K082", "category": "Media, education & culture", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Human-machine creative collaborations gain recognition", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Human-machine creative collaborations gain recognition", "successCriteria": "Human-machine artistic collaborations emerge and receive serious cultural/institutional attention.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Arts in 2019, cyberart bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N27", "id": "N27-0", "title": "Christie’s: Human-machine art collaboration at auction", "url": "https://www.christies.com/stories/a-collaboration-between-two-artists-one-human-one-a-machine-0cd01f4e232f4279a525a446d60d4cd1", "publishedAt": null, "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Obvious/GAN portrait sold October 2018 for $432,500. Supports serious institutional attention, not majority adoption by artists.. Obvious/GAN portrait sold October 2018 for $432,500. Supports serious institutional attention, not majority adoption by artists." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "HIGH", "disputed": false, "rationale": "Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019. The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.", "alternativeInterpretation": null, "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019. The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"HIGH\",\"at_review\":\"HIGH\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Human-machine artistic collaborations emerge and receive serious cultural/institutional attention.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019. The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2018,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N27\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Human-machine artistic collaborations emerge and receive serious cultural/institutional attention.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019. The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2018,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N27\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Human-machine artistic collaborations emerge and receive serious cultural/institutional attention.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019. The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2018,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N27\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2018,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2018\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K082\",\"slug\":\"k082-human-machine-creative-collaborations-gain-recognition\",\"title\":\"Human-machine creative collaborations gain recognition\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Human-machine creative collaborations gain recognition\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Media, education & culture\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K082\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Human-machine artistic collaborations emerge and receive serious cultural/institutional attention.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"HIGH\",\"disputed_interpretation\":false,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Christie’s 2018 sale of a GAN-assisted work created by a human collective establishes serious institutional attention before 2019. The modest emergence-and-recognition claim was fulfilled. It did not require most artists or leading artists to be machines.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2018,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Arts in 2019, cyberart bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N27\",\"locator\":\"Obvious/GAN portrait sold October 2018 for $432,500. Supports serious institutional attention, not majority adoption by artists.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Assessment is conditional on the stated criterion and population. Documented examples establish availability, not universal adoption. The original book edition has not been independently collated.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "MEDIUM", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "Scientists understand many important genetic/cellular processes of aging and cancer; a complete causal model or cure is not required.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019. Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2018, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N38", "N39", "N40" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "Scientists understand many important genetic/cellular processes of aging and cancer; a complete causal model or cure is not required.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019. Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "SAME_AS_REFERENCE", "documented_by_year": 2018, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N38", "N39", "N40" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "Scientists understand many important genetic/cellular processes of aging and cancer; a complete causal model or cure is not required.", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019. Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2018, "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N38", "N39", "N40" ], "verdict": "CORRECT", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "non_scoring_comparators": [ { "criterion": "Aging and cancer are understood well enough for comprehensive predictive causal models across patients and mechanisms.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "rationale": "The cited research explicitly retains major uncertainties and interactions. That stronger comprehensive-understanding interpretation is partial.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "same_as_reference": false, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N38", "N39", "N40" ], "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": false, "eligible_for_author_accuracy": false, "comparator_warning": "Stronger than the located wording; not an obligation of the original forecast and excluded from accuracy calculations." } ], "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": 2018, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "DOCUMENTED_BY", "label": "Documented by 2018", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K083", "slug": "k083-major-aging-and-cancer-mechanisms-become-understood", "title": "Major aging and cancer mechanisms become understood", "prediction_paraphrase": "Major aging and cancer mechanisms become understood", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Biology & medicine", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "RESEARCH_MILESTONE", "family_id": "K083", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "Scientists understand many important genetic/cellular processes of aging and cancer; a complete causal model or cure is not required.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019.", "at_review_rationale": "Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "CORRECT", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019. Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": 2018, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Health care in 2019, first clause; lifespan clause separately K027", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N38", "locator": "Nine tentative mechanistic hallmarks; progress and unresolved interactions both explicit. Mechanistic insight does not establish a cure for aging.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N39", "locator": "Pan-Cancer Atlas, 33 tumor types. Molecular classification is evidence of biological understanding, not complete causal explanation or universal treatment.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N40", "locator": "Expanded 12-hallmark framework. Shows progress and continued open mechanisms, not a complete model of human lifespan.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Mechanistic knowledge, predictive understanding and treatment effectiveness are separate milestones. This judgment is not medical advice and awards no credit toward the linked lifespan-over-100 forecast.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K083", "familyId": "K083", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K083", "category": "Biology & medicine", "tags": [], "claimType": "RESEARCH_MILESTONE", "importedClaim": "Major aging and cancer mechanisms become understood", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Major aging and cancer mechanisms become understood", "successCriteria": "Scientists understand many important genetic/cellular processes of aging and cancer; a complete causal model or cure is not required.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Health care in 2019, first clause; lifespan clause separately K027", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N38", "id": "N38-0", "title": "López-Otín et al.: The Hallmarks of Aging", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2013.05.039", "publishedAt": "2013-06-06", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Nine tentative mechanistic hallmarks; progress and unresolved interactions both explicit. Mechanistic insight does not establish a cure for aging.. Nine tentative mechanistic hallmarks; progress and unresolved interactions both explicit. Mechanistic insight does not establish a cure for aging." }, { "sourceId": "N39", "id": "N39-1", "title": "NCI/TCGA: Molecular classification of 10,000 tumors", "url": "https://gdc.cancer.gov/about-data/publications/PanCan-CellOfOrigin", "publishedAt": "2018-04-05", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Pan-Cancer Atlas, 33 tumor types. Molecular classification is evidence of biological understanding, not complete causal explanation or universal treatment.. Pan-Cancer Atlas, 33 tumor types. Molecular classification is evidence of biological understanding, not complete causal explanation or universal treatment." }, { "sourceId": "N40", "id": "N40-2", "title": "López-Otín et al.: Hallmarks of aging, an expanding universe", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36599349/", "publishedAt": "2023-01-19", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Expanded 12-hallmark framework. Shows progress and continued open mechanisms, not a complete model of human lifespan.. Expanded 12-hallmark framework. Shows progress and continued open mechanisms, not a complete model of human lifespan." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "FULL", "atReview": "FULL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019. Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Mechanistic knowledge, predictive understanding and treatment effectiveness are separate milestones. This judgment is not medical advice and awards no credit toward the linked lifespan-over-100 forecast.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Mechanistic knowledge, predictive understanding and treatment effectiveness are separate milestones. This judgment is not medical advice and awards no credit toward the linked lifespan-over-100 forecast.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.", "An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict CORRECT. The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019. Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"Scientists understand many important genetic/cellular processes of aging and cancer; a complete causal model or cure is not required.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019. Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2018,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N38\",\"N39\",\"N40\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"Scientists understand many important genetic/cellular processes of aging and cancer; a complete causal model or cure is not required.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019. Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"SAME_AS_REFERENCE\",\"documented_by_year\":2018,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N38\",\"N39\",\"N40\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"Scientists understand many important genetic/cellular processes of aging and cancer; a complete causal model or cure is not required.\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019. Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2018,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N38\",\"N39\",\"N40\"],\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"non_scoring_comparators\":[{\"criterion\":\"Aging and cancer are understood well enough for comprehensive predictive causal models across patients and mechanisms.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"rationale\":\"The cited research explicitly retains major uncertainties and interactions. That stronger comprehensive-understanding interpretation is partial.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"same_as_reference\":false,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N38\",\"N39\",\"N40\"],\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":false,\"eligible_for_author_accuracy\":false,\"comparator_warning\":\"Stronger than the located wording; not an obligation of the original forecast and excluded from accuracy calculations.\"}],\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":2018,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"DOCUMENTED_BY\",\"label\":\"Documented by 2018\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K083\",\"slug\":\"k083-major-aging-and-cancer-mechanisms-become-understood\",\"title\":\"Major aging and cancer mechanisms become understood\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Major aging and cancer mechanisms become understood\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Biology & medicine\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"RESEARCH_MILESTONE\",\"family_id\":\"K083\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"Scientists understand many important genetic/cellular processes of aging and cancer; a complete causal model or cure is not required.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"CORRECT\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"The 2013 hallmarks framework and 2018 Pan-Cancer Atlas demonstrate substantial mechanistic and molecular understanding before 2019. Continued refinement, including 12 aging hallmarks in 2023, does not erase those real insights. The source says many processes, not all biology solved.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":2018,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Health care in 2019, first clause; lifespan clause separately K027\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N38\",\"locator\":\"Nine tentative mechanistic hallmarks; progress and unresolved interactions both explicit. Mechanistic insight does not establish a cure for aging.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N39\",\"locator\":\"Pan-Cancer Atlas, 33 tumor types. Molecular classification is evidence of biological understanding, not complete causal explanation or universal treatment.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N40\",\"locator\":\"Expanded 12-hallmark framework. Shows progress and continued open mechanisms, not a complete model of human lifespan.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Mechanistic knowledge, predictive understanding and treatment effectiveness are separate milestones. This judgment is not medical advice and awards no credit toward the linked lifespan-over-100 forecast.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\",\"An earlier documented instance could refine timing; the documented-by date is not claimed to be the invention year.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } }, { "release": { "population_scope": "Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.", "attribution_confidence": "MEDIUM", "interpretation_confidence": "MEDIUM", "outcome_confidence": { "at_deadline": "MEDIUM", "at_review": "MEDIUM" }, "timing_confidence": "LOW", "date_uncertainty_affects_verdict": false, "interpretations": { "reference": { "criterion": "The vast majority of transactions involve an AI-like simulated person, often agent-to-agent without direct human involvement.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions. Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions.", "at_review_rationale": "Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N55", "N56", "N31" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "strict": { "criterion": "The vast majority of transactions involve an AI-like simulated person, often agent-to-agent without direct human involvement.", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "rationale": "Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions. Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [], "kind": "REFERENCE_READING", "documented_by_year": null, "at_deadline_rationale": "Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions.", "at_review_rationale": "Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.", "evidence_source_ids": [ "N55", "N56", "N31" ], "verdict": "PARTIAL", "same_as_reference": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true }, "broader": { "criterion": "AI agents become capable of completing commercial transactions for users.", "at_deadline": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "at_review": "FULFILLED", "rationale": "The later agentic-commerce offering realizes useful transactional agents, without a market-share claim.", "relaxed_or_changed_conditions": [ "Vast majority", "Routine human-free inter-agent execution" ], "kind": "ALTERNATIVE_READING", "documented_by_year": 2025, "evidence_source_ids": [ "N55", "N56", "N31" ], "verdict": "LATE", "same_as_reference": false, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "deadline_year": 2019, "outcome_assessment_complete": true } }, "timing": { "first_full_achievement_year": null, "documented_by_year": null, "achievement_interval_years": null, "kind": "UNESTABLISHED", "label": "Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay", "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null }, "deduplication": { "is_canonical": true, "is_repeated_identical_claim": false, "counting_unit": "DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION", "note": "Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted." }, "revision_history": [], "is_new_in_v03": true, "counting_policy": { "unit": "distinct_forecast_version", "identical_repetitions_count_once": true, "alternative_interpretations_count_once": true, "legacy_conditional_rows_count": false }, "id": "K084", "slug": "k084-simulated-people-mediate-nearly-all-transactions", "title": "Simulated people mediate nearly all transactions", "prediction_paraphrase": "Simulated people mediate nearly all transactions", "wording_kind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "original_quote": null, "primary_category": "Economy & society", "tags": [], "subcategory": "", "claim_type": "ADOPTION", "family_id": "K084", "parent_statement_id": null, "legacy_ids": [], "origin": "NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION", "publication": { "forecast_year": 1999, "year_basis": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE", "original_book_edition_checked": false, "forecast_year_status": "ATTRIBUTED_1999" }, "target": { "text": "2019", "deadline_year": 2019, "precision": "YEAR", "year_start": 2019, "year_end": 2019, "interpretation": "End of named target year." }, "source_verification": { "state": "AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "book_text_not_independently_collated": true }, "success_criteria": "The vast majority of transactions involve an AI-like simulated person, often agent-to-agent without direct human involvement.", "assessment": { "at_deadline_rationale": "Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions.", "at_review_rationale": "Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.", "verdict_qualifier": null, "outcome_evidence_basis": "DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION", "attribution_is_separate": true, "first_event_date_required_for_verdict": false, "at_review_semantics": "FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES", "review_state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "as_of": "2026-10-15", "at_deadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "at_review": "PARTLY_FULFILLED", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed_interpretation": true, "benchmark_ready": true, "rationale": "Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions. Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.", "first_full_achievement_year": null, "full_achievement_documented_by_year": null, "drift_years": null, "drift_range_years": null, "still_unfulfilled_as_of_review": true, "eligible_for_deadline_metrics": true, "withheld_reason": null }, "prediction_sources": [ { "source_id": "P02", "locator": "P02 Business in 2019, simulated-person transactions bullet", "role": "FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION" } ], "evidence": [ { "source_id": "N55", "locator": "Protocol and reference implementations; not evidence most real-world transactions use simulated people.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N56", "locator": "Commercial offering and agent interaction architecture. No market-wide transaction-share denominator supplied.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" }, { "source_id": "N31", "locator": "Second quarter 2026 e-commerce share 17.1% of retail sales by value. Not B2B, securities trading, or a count of all transactions.", "role": "OUTCOME_EVIDENCE" } ], "limitations": "Protocol membership and product announcements are not market-wide transaction volumes. Electronic processing alone is not a simulated person.", "open_questions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "legacy_relations": [] }, "id": "K084", "familyId": "K084", "parentStatementId": null, "duplicateOf": null, "canonical": true, "scoringKey": "K084", "category": "Economy & society", "tags": [], "claimType": "ADOPTION", "importedClaim": "Simulated people mediate nearly all transactions", "originalWording": null, "wordingKind": "EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE", "normalizedClaim": "Simulated people mediate nearly all transactions", "successCriteria": "The vast majority of transactions involve an AI-like simulated person, often agent-to-agent without direct human involvement.", "scope": { "population": null, "geography": null, "adoptionStage": null, "conditions": null, "units": null }, "sources": [ { "id": "P02", "title": "Spiritual Machines: The Merging of Man and Machine — Ray Kurzweil", "publicationYear": 1999, "publicationYearVerified": false, "url": "https://iranscope.ghandchi.com/Anthology/Kurzweil-SM.htm", "locator": "P02 Business in 2019, simulated-person transactions bullet", "wordingVerified": false } ], "deadline": { "originalText": "2019", "year": 2019, "exactDate": null, "startYear": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "evidence": [ { "sourceId": "N55", "id": "N55-0", "title": "Google: Agent Payments Protocol AP2", "url": "https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/ai-machine-learning/announcing-agents-to-payments-ap2-protocol", "publishedAt": "2025-09-16", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Protocol and reference implementations; not evidence most real-world transactions use simulated people.. Protocol and reference implementations; not evidence most real-world transactions use simulated people." }, { "sourceId": "N56", "id": "N56-1", "title": "Google Cloud and PayPal: Agentic commerce solution", "url": "https://cloud.google.com/blog/topics/financial-services/introducing-an-agentic-commerce-solution-for-merchants-from-paypal-and-google-cloud", "publishedAt": "2025-10-27", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Commercial offering and agent interaction architecture. No market-wide transaction-share denominator supplied.. Commercial offering and agent interaction architecture. No market-wide transaction-share denominator supplied." }, { "sourceId": "N31", "id": "N31-2", "title": "US Census: Quarterly retail e-commerce, 2026", "url": "https://www.census.gov/retail/eCommerce.html", "publishedAt": "2026-08-18", "accessedAt": "2026-10-15", "stance": "CONTEXT", "note": "Second quarter 2026 e-commerce share 17.1% of retail sales by value. Not B2B, securities trading, or a count of all transactions.. Second quarter 2026 e-commerce share 17.1% of retail sales by value. Not B2B, securities trading, or a count of all transactions." } ], "assessment": { "state": "EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE", "scorable": true, "atDeadline": "NOT_FULFILLED", "atReview": "PARTIAL", "firstAchievementYear": null, "firstAchievementDate": null, "lastReviewedAt": "2026-10-15", "reviewer": "AI-assisted source review; editorial assessment, not human peer review", "confidence": "MEDIUM", "disputed": true, "rationale": "Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions. Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.", "alternativeInterpretation": "Protocol membership and product announcements are not market-wide transaction volumes. Electronic processing alone is not a simulated person.", "exclusionReason": null }, "research": { "notes": "Protocol membership and product announcements are not market-wide transaction volumes. Electronic processing alone is not a simulated person.", "unresolvedQuestions": [ "Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment." ], "history": [ { "date": "2026-10-15", "note": "Evidence v0.3: EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE; supplied verdict PARTIAL. Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions. Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share." } ] }, "provenance": { "inputFile": "kurzweil_verification_v0_3_package/predictions.canonical.v0.3.json", "inputSha256": "93ae54d9ea2f1bd1817c481b85e2b707812bcd934c74d0f1715fa098d9b5f51b", "row": null, "legacyId": null, "raw": { "release_record": "{\"population_scope\":\"Technology markets and relevant users; no universality unless the forecast expressly requires it.\",\"attribution_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"interpretation_confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"outcome_confidence\":{\"at_deadline\":\"MEDIUM\",\"at_review\":\"MEDIUM\"},\"timing_confidence\":\"LOW\",\"date_uncertainty_affects_verdict\":false,\"interpretations\":{\"reference\":{\"criterion\":\"The vast majority of transactions involve an AI-like simulated person, often agent-to-agent without direct human involvement.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions. Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N55\",\"N56\",\"N31\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"strict\":{\"criterion\":\"The vast majority of transactions involve an AI-like simulated person, often agent-to-agent without direct human involvement.\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions. Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[],\"kind\":\"REFERENCE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":null,\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.\",\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N55\",\"N56\",\"N31\"],\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"same_as_reference\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true},\"broader\":{\"criterion\":\"AI agents become capable of completing commercial transactions for users.\",\"at_deadline\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"FULFILLED\",\"rationale\":\"The later agentic-commerce offering realizes useful transactional agents, without a market-share claim.\",\"relaxed_or_changed_conditions\":[\"Vast majority\",\"Routine human-free inter-agent execution\"],\"kind\":\"ALTERNATIVE_READING\",\"documented_by_year\":2025,\"evidence_source_ids\":[\"N55\",\"N56\",\"N31\"],\"verdict\":\"LATE\",\"same_as_reference\":false,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"deadline_year\":2019,\"outcome_assessment_complete\":true}},\"timing\":{\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"documented_by_year\":null,\"achievement_interval_years\":null,\"kind\":\"UNESTABLISHED\",\"label\":\"Not fully realized by 2026-10-15; overdue, not an observed delay\",\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null},\"deduplication\":{\"is_canonical\":true,\"is_repeated_identical_claim\":false,\"counting_unit\":\"DISTINCT_FORECAST_VERSION\",\"note\":\"Different deadlines or materially different thresholds remain separate versions; identical legacy repetitions are linked, not recounted.\"},\"revision_history\":[],\"is_new_in_v03\":true,\"counting_policy\":{\"unit\":\"distinct_forecast_version\",\"identical_repetitions_count_once\":true,\"alternative_interpretations_count_once\":true,\"legacy_conditional_rows_count\":false},\"id\":\"K084\",\"slug\":\"k084-simulated-people-mediate-nearly-all-transactions\",\"title\":\"Simulated people mediate nearly all transactions\",\"prediction_paraphrase\":\"Simulated people mediate nearly all transactions\",\"wording_kind\":\"EDITORIAL_PARAPHRASE\",\"original_quote\":null,\"primary_category\":\"Economy & society\",\"tags\":[],\"subcategory\":\"\",\"claim_type\":\"ADOPTION\",\"family_id\":\"K084\",\"parent_statement_id\":null,\"legacy_ids\":[],\"origin\":\"NEW_SOURCE_EXTRACTION\",\"publication\":{\"forecast_year\":1999,\"year_basis\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_OR_RETROSPECTIVE\",\"original_book_edition_checked\":false,\"forecast_year_status\":\"ATTRIBUTED_1999\"},\"target\":{\"text\":\"2019\",\"deadline_year\":2019,\"precision\":\"YEAR\",\"year_start\":2019,\"year_end\":2019,\"interpretation\":\"End of named target year.\"},\"source_verification\":{\"state\":\"AUTHOR_ADAPTATION_CHECKED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"book_text_not_independently_collated\":true},\"success_criteria\":\"The vast majority of transactions involve an AI-like simulated person, often agent-to-agent without direct human involvement.\",\"assessment\":{\"at_deadline_rationale\":\"Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions.\",\"at_review_rationale\":\"Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.\",\"verdict_qualifier\":null,\"outcome_evidence_basis\":\"DIRECT_AND_CONTEXTUAL_EVIDENCE_WITH_EXPLICIT_EDITORIAL_INTERPRETATION\",\"attribution_is_separate\":true,\"first_event_date_required_for_verdict\":false,\"at_review_semantics\":\"FULL_REALIZATION_HAS_OCCURRED_BY_REVIEW_NOT_NECESSARILY_CURRENT_PRODUCT_SALES\",\"review_state\":\"EDITORIAL_ASSESSMENT_COMPLETE\",\"verdict\":\"PARTIAL\",\"as_of\":\"2026-10-15\",\"at_deadline\":\"NOT_FULFILLED\",\"at_review\":\"PARTLY_FULFILLED\",\"confidence\":\"MEDIUM\",\"disputed_interpretation\":true,\"benchmark_ready\":true,\"rationale\":\"Ordinary online checkout and payment automation in 2019 were not predominantly simulated-person interactions. Agent payment protocols and commercial conversational-commerce offerings now make the direction concrete. They do not establish the original vast-majority share.\",\"first_full_achievement_year\":null,\"full_achievement_documented_by_year\":null,\"drift_years\":null,\"drift_range_years\":null,\"still_unfulfilled_as_of_review\":true,\"eligible_for_deadline_metrics\":true,\"withheld_reason\":null},\"prediction_sources\":[{\"source_id\":\"P02\",\"locator\":\"P02 Business in 2019, simulated-person transactions bullet\",\"role\":\"FORECAST_ATTRIBUTION\"}],\"evidence\":[{\"source_id\":\"N55\",\"locator\":\"Protocol and reference implementations; not evidence most real-world transactions use simulated people.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N56\",\"locator\":\"Commercial offering and agent interaction architecture. No market-wide transaction-share denominator supplied.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"},{\"source_id\":\"N31\",\"locator\":\"Second quarter 2026 e-commerce share 17.1% of retail sales by value. Not B2B, securities trading, or a count of all transactions.\",\"role\":\"OUTCOME_EVIDENCE\"}],\"limitations\":\"Protocol membership and product announcements are not market-wide transaction volumes. Electronic processing alone is not a simulated person.\",\"open_questions\":[\"Original-edition collation remains an attribution task; it does not erase the stated outcome assessment.\"],\"legacy_relations\":[]}" } } } ] }